One of Us is Lying

Reviewed by: Sheila Dube - Springvale Public Library, Springvale, Southern Maine Library District

Review Date: June 13, 2017

Review

High school detention is the setting of this murder thriller where a fatal allergic response to peanuts makes the four other students present in detention the main suspects. Motive seems to center around the gossip app developed by Simon, the victim, and suspense moves at a steady pace as each student's back story and secrets are revealed. Chapters are written from the alternating point of view of the four suspects who are blatantly described as stereotypical in their role or interests as the nerd, the druggie, the cheerleader and the jock. Reference to the chapter headings was necessary at times due to the lack of distinguish-ability of the four voices, but this is only a slight quibble. McManus delves into each suspect's character, situation and social pressures. The parents, lawyers and law enforcement involved are portrayed as short sighted which fuels the action and requires the students to take on the murder solving task. Amidst the murder investigation, McManus presents various pressures and family dynamics that are realistically portrayed. This is a fast-paced thriller that can be suggested for fans of beach reads and high school romance.

Overall Book Score: very good