Islands of Chaldea

Reviewed by: Peg Becksvoort - Falmouth Middle, Falmouth, Southern Maine Library District

Review Date: October 9, 2014

Review

A posthumous novel begun by well-known author Diana Wynne Jones; finished by her daughter Ursula Jones. This represents a difficult task and I was conscious of looking for transition of style or other rough patches. The story seemed smooth but has an abundance of characters and plot.

My 6th grade reviewer states: With a suspenseful and elaborate plot, this fantasy (book) draws the reader's attention. Although the plot is very complex, sometimes it becomes too complex to follow. Other times, if feels rushed, and some details are hazy. For the most part though, the captivating plot of (a) young wise woman trying to complete her quest makes the book exciting and hold the reader's interest.

Additional comments: With this complex plot, the Jones writing dynasty lives on. For libraries where Dian Wynne Jones fans abound and where readers exist for more challenging plots. Perhaps some additional editing would have been helpful?

Overall Book Score: good