WEBVTT
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/329-0
00:00:33.656 --> 00:00:34.936
Hello everybody.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/334-0
00:00:35.696 --> 00:00:37.576
Please make sure your computer were muted.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/336-0
00:00:39.986 --> 00:00:40.346
There we go.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/349-0
00:00:42.896 --> 00:00:47.096
So thank you for coming to Maine's
battery management plan update.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/360-0
00:00:47.496 --> 00:00:51.296
We're gonna give everyone a few more
minutes to join in.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/372-0
00:00:51.376 --> 00:00:55.856
Please make sure that your cameras are
off and that your computer is muted.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/402-0
00:00:56.136 --> 00:01:00.355
We will be going through our discussion
and if you have anything you'd like to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/402-1
00:01:00.355 --> 00:01:02.545
add,
please raise your hand first before
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/402-2
00:01:02.545 --> 00:01:06.016
adding to discussion.
We'll get started in the next few minutes.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/404-0
00:01:06.056 --> 00:01:06.496
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/451-0
00:03:32.656 --> 00:03:36.416
And tilt that little portion right away,
all right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/466-0
00:03:38.066 --> 00:03:42.364
Hello everyone,
can I just get a thumbs up from somebody
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/466-1
00:03:42.364 --> 00:03:44.626
online to if they can hear us?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/472-0
00:03:48.086 --> 00:03:49.686
Perfect. Thank you, Amanda.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/483-0
00:03:51.186 --> 00:03:52.986
Well,
I want to thank everyone for attending
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/483-1
00:03:52.986 --> 00:03:53.426
the 1st of.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/492-0
00:03:55.466 --> 00:03:57.306
The main department of viral protections.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/499-0
00:03:58.986 --> 00:04:01.386
Stakeholder meetings regarding.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/505-0
00:04:03.546 --> 00:04:06.786
Updating Maine's battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/508-0
00:04:08.626 --> 00:04:09.266
Stewardship program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/515-0
00:04:10.906 --> 00:04:13.706
This is gonna be the first of two
meetings and.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/517-0
00:04:15.426 --> 00:04:16.226
There's.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/543-0
00:04:20.736 --> 00:04:23.445
2/3 of us,
three of us had to think there was three
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/543-1
00:04:23.445 --> 00:04:26.935
of us from the department.
I'll let ourselves introduce each other
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/543-2
00:04:26.935 --> 00:04:29.279
first,
and then I'll start with some opening
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/543-3
00:04:29.279 --> 00:04:29.696
remarks.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/548-0
00:04:29.776 --> 00:04:31.256
I'm Brian benesky.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/571-0
00:04:32.016 --> 00:04:36.428
I'm head of the sustainability unit here
in the department,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/571-1
00:04:36.428 --> 00:04:41.576
which overseas all of the product
stewardship and recycling programs.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/589-0
00:04:43.106 --> 00:04:46.715
Which includes the battery program,
but also includes the programs such as
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/589-1
00:04:46.715 --> 00:04:49.746
the Bottle Redemption Program,
our packaging program and such.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/605-0
00:04:50.336 --> 00:04:54.736
And I'll let Rob introduce himself and my
name is Robert Burks.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/608-0
00:04:54.736 --> 00:04:55.696
I work under Brian.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/620-0
00:04:55.696 --> 00:05:00.896
I had a pharmaceutical program and also
worked with solar panels.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/627-0
00:05:02.646 --> 00:05:06.086
And and wind turbine blades.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/631-0
00:05:06.086 --> 00:05:07.286
Just the OIT guys.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/641-0
00:05:07.286 --> 00:05:08.406
Wanna make sure you guys get it?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/642-0
00:05:09.366 --> 00:05:10.206
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/651-0
00:05:10.206 --> 00:05:14.046
So we're just working off of the computer.
Yep. OK, thanks.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/653-0
00:05:14.046 --> 00:05:15.086
Thank you. Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/662-0
00:05:16.546 --> 00:05:20.306
But also wind turbine blades and battery
issues as well.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/665-0
00:05:22.546 --> 00:05:22.626
So.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/672-0
00:05:25.736 --> 00:05:27.176
And I am Courtney Hafner.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/689-0
00:05:27.176 --> 00:05:31.768
I work in the sustainability unit under
multiple product products steward
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/689-1
00:05:31.768 --> 00:05:34.560
programs,
including that of the rechargeable
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/689-2
00:05:34.560 --> 00:05:35.056
battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/700-0
00:05:36.866 --> 00:05:40.586
This was going to move that shots.
Maybe talk, yeah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/707-0
00:05:40.626 --> 00:05:43.186
So just due to some technical
difficulties.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/729-0
00:05:44.906 --> 00:05:50.443
Our our technology here in the office
room, is it quite functioning up to par.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/729-1
00:05:50.443 --> 00:05:52.826
So we we aren't unable to use our.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/731-0
00:05:54.546 --> 00:05:55.066
Camera.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/753-0
00:05:56.076 --> 00:05:59.703
From the video room itself,
we have to use a camera from the one of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/753-1
00:05:59.703 --> 00:06:02.796
our laptops here, but we can see everyone.
You'll see us.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/768-0
00:06:02.796 --> 00:06:05.612
We're all looking up at one of the big
TV's on the screen.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/768-1
00:06:05.612 --> 00:06:06.996
We can see everyone up there.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/770-0
00:06:08.466 --> 00:06:08.666
Great.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/776-0
00:06:10.266 --> 00:06:12.106
So again, just to start us off.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/789-0
00:06:14.226 --> 00:06:20.586
And there's actually 1235 of us 55 other
attendees here.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/791-0
00:06:22.426 --> 00:06:22.826
In the.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/794-0
00:06:22.826 --> 00:06:23.466
In the room as well.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/798-0
00:06:26.026 --> 00:06:26.986
So yeah, so.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/810-0
00:06:27.296 --> 00:06:31.856
This is the first of the stakeholder
meetings to kind of solicit input into.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/814-0
00:06:33.946 --> 00:06:36.426
Changes to main.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/824-0
00:06:37.786 --> 00:06:45.386
Tain this is the the second the second
meeting is scheduled for September 4th.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/846-0
00:06:47.066 --> 00:06:51.169
And if I hope everyone had a chance to
see it, but we did put, put,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/846-1
00:06:51.169 --> 00:06:54.186
put up a background document that we hope
people.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/853-0
00:06:55.866 --> 00:06:57.786
Were able to read before attending the
meeting.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/865-0
00:06:58.336 --> 00:07:04.456
It provided an overview of Maine's
current battery program law.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/892-0
00:07:06.626 --> 00:07:12.784
And I'm not going to provide a synopsis
of the of the current law other than to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/892-1
00:07:12.784 --> 00:07:16.786
say it's been in place for several
decades now and.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/905-0
00:07:18.306 --> 00:07:24.426
It only addresses recycled batteries of
certain chemistries. It does.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/908-0
00:07:24.466 --> 00:07:27.186
It is out of date and.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/921-0
00:07:27.576 --> 00:07:35.341
So one of the things what we're looking
for is is input on where and how we
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/921-1
00:07:35.341 --> 00:07:36.056
should.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/927-0
00:07:37.866 --> 00:07:40.066
Update it and increase.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/932-0
00:07:41.946 --> 00:07:42.906
Products in the program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/957-0
00:07:45.266 --> 00:07:49.561
Also on the on the stakeholder
stakeholder document,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/957-1
00:07:49.561 --> 00:07:54.666
we put some questions for discussion,
which we can start with.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/966-0
00:07:57.346 --> 00:07:59.546
But I don't want us to be limited to
those.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/989-0
00:07:59.856 --> 00:08:03.806
Those questions,
if others have any other items they wish
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/989-1
00:08:03.806 --> 00:08:07.347
to discuss,
like just kind of be considered an open
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/989-2
00:08:07.347 --> 00:08:11.296
forum to hear from people and and discuss
back and forth.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1022-0
00:08:13.026 --> 00:08:17.599
The different ideas that we'll hear today
and then with the idea that in the second
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1022-1
00:08:17.599 --> 00:08:20.267
meeting,
we'll try to summarize what we've heard
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1022-2
00:08:20.267 --> 00:08:24.186
and maybe even Purdue provide for the
meeting some a bit of a straw man
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1022-3
00:08:24.186 --> 00:08:26.146
document for what we're looking for.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1026-0
00:08:28.586 --> 00:08:29.706
And there we have.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1037-0
00:08:30.376 --> 00:08:35.336
In addition to the in people in house,
we have 34 attending.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1058-0
00:08:36.746 --> 00:08:39.029
Online,
so I don't think it given the numbers,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1058-1
00:08:39.029 --> 00:08:42.866
I don't think it's useful to go around
and have everyone introduce themselves.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1074-0
00:08:42.906 --> 00:08:47.904
But if you do participate,
please identify yourself in any
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1074-1
00:08:47.904 --> 00:08:50.106
organization you are with.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1084-0
00:08:54.466 --> 00:08:59.466
And I will stop right there and ask if
anyone.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1090-0
00:09:00.056 --> 00:09:03.016
Wants to make a statement to begin with.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1094-0
00:09:21.486 --> 00:09:22.206
Jennifer.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1111-0
00:09:24.156 --> 00:09:30.025
Hi there, Jennifer Dapolonio main DEP.
I'm with the hazardous waste management
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1111-1
00:09:30.025 --> 00:09:30.396
unit.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1137-0
00:09:31.866 --> 00:09:37.066
Not a comment right this moment,
but I wanted to ask if you would throw
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1137-1
00:09:37.066 --> 00:09:42.265
the link to that document you had
previously posted up somewhere in the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1137-2
00:09:42.265 --> 00:09:42.626
chat.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1144-0
00:09:44.786 --> 00:09:47.586
Sure. We will see if we can do that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1146-0
00:09:48.046 --> 00:09:48.766
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1152-0
00:09:51.086 --> 00:09:54.446
It was available on the website.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1179-0
00:09:55.856 --> 00:09:59.609
I think I've looked at it before,
but I've I've looked at so many documents
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1179-1
00:09:59.609 --> 00:10:02.176
in the past week I need to put my eyes on
it again.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1180-0
00:10:03.996 --> 00:10:04.156
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1182-0
00:10:04.156 --> 00:10:05.596
We'll try a little link for that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1185-0
00:10:05.666 --> 00:10:06.226
I have that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1186-0
00:10:06.556 --> 00:10:07.396
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1188-0
00:10:11.106 --> 00:10:11.626
One second.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1197-0
00:10:13.746 --> 00:10:16.186
That was the one document I did not have
up.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1205-0
00:10:34.566 --> 00:10:35.726
How the chat's turned off.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1208-0
00:10:36.646 --> 00:10:37.366
Yeah, king.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1213-0
00:10:37.486 --> 00:10:40.206
Chat is turned off the moment they'd have
to go back to their.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1215-0
00:10:41.666 --> 00:10:41.746
Uh.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1217-0
00:10:44.816 --> 00:10:44.896
Oh.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1221-0
00:10:47.816 --> 00:10:49.216
Yeah, we have to tell them there.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1236-0
00:10:50.836 --> 00:10:54.456
Yeah. So as of right now,
our chat is turned off just for this
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1236-1
00:10:54.456 --> 00:10:54.916
meeting.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1253-0
00:10:55.676 --> 00:11:00.750
People would probably have to go back to
our main DEP site with the batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1253-1
00:11:00.750 --> 00:11:02.676
It was also in the invitation.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1258-0
00:11:02.676 --> 00:11:07.676
It is underneath the registration button
so OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1260-0
00:11:09.316 --> 00:11:09.436
Yep.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1263-0
00:11:11.066 --> 00:11:11.746
Andy.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1269-0
00:11:12.826 --> 00:11:13.786
Yeah. Thanks, Brian.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1270-0
00:11:14.226 --> 00:11:15.866
Just maybe a question.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1280-0
00:11:15.866 --> 00:11:18.626
I know you mentioned the the battery laws
outdated.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1305-0
00:11:20.116 --> 00:11:24.019
Obviously it hasn't had reform,
but in terms of the department looking
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1305-1
00:11:24.019 --> 00:11:26.877
into this,
is the department going to be sponsoring
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1305-2
00:11:26.877 --> 00:11:28.636
legislation in the next session?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1338-0
00:11:28.956 --> 00:11:33.360
Where is sort of the interest in in sort
of the reform and and where are we headed
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1338-1
00:11:33.360 --> 00:11:36.809
with the stakeholders?
Discussions are is the department putting
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1338-2
00:11:36.809 --> 00:11:40.788
a bill in and should we be focused on
thinking about it from a legislative
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1338-3
00:11:40.788 --> 00:11:41.796
change perspective?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1345-0
00:11:42.106 --> 00:11:44.106
Are you thinking about regulatory change?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1348-0
00:11:44.106 --> 00:11:45.346
Just help help us.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1355-0
00:11:45.346 --> 00:11:46.546
Maybe understand a little bit more.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1387-0
00:11:46.546 --> 00:11:50.227
I know the questions sort of talked about
specific policy areas,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1387-1
00:11:50.227 --> 00:11:54.473
but but are we headed towards, you know,
working together to try to get to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1387-2
00:11:54.473 --> 00:11:58.777
consensus on legislative language or or
you know what other avenues are you
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1387-3
00:11:58.777 --> 00:11:59.626
thinking about?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1394-0
00:12:00.106 --> 00:12:04.146
Yeah. So the background on on that is.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1398-0
00:12:06.156 --> 00:12:06.636
In in the.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1422-0
00:12:09.196 --> 00:12:14.604
Last year's or actually, I should say,
this year's product stewardship report we
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1422-1
00:12:14.604 --> 00:12:18.076
had proposed doing a review of the
battery program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1437-0
00:12:20.626 --> 00:12:24.276
And proposing some legislation,
some language,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1437-1
00:12:24.276 --> 00:12:27.226
for legislation to update the program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1457-0
00:12:28.676 --> 00:12:33.640
Based on input we hear from these
stakeholder meetings and additionally,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1457-1
00:12:33.640 --> 00:12:35.476
I unfortunately don't know.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1481-0
00:12:35.796 --> 00:12:41.420
I can't remember the name of of the
number of Senator Bennett's bill, but we,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1481-1
00:12:41.420 --> 00:12:47.476
Senator Bennett introduced a bill in this
past legislative session which basically.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1487-0
00:12:49.196 --> 00:12:50.836
Directed the department to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1506-0
00:12:52.236 --> 00:12:58.181
Do exactly what we're doing,
which is convened a couple of stakeholder
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1506-1
00:12:58.181 --> 00:13:02.116
meetings to look into updating and
increasing.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1529-0
00:13:04.516 --> 00:13:11.160
The and look into adding other other
types of batteries into the program,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1529-1
00:13:11.160 --> 00:13:16.636
and it also looked wanted us to look at
adding specifically.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1536-0
00:13:18.276 --> 00:13:20.116
I'll call them vape vape pens.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1549-0
00:13:20.786 --> 00:13:24.586
And their viability and putting them in
the in the program as well.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1591-0
00:13:24.626 --> 00:13:28.513
So it's kind of a,
it's been directed by both our own,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1591-1
00:13:28.513 --> 00:13:32.895
the department kind of going down to
solicit input into what,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1591-2
00:13:32.895 --> 00:13:38.337
what's what's what are thoughts for
updating the the current battery program
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1591-3
00:13:38.337 --> 00:13:43.426
as well as being directed legislatively
to look into the issue as well.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1618-0
00:13:45.746 --> 00:13:49.418
And then that's the goal is to in this
year's well,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1618-1
00:13:49.418 --> 00:13:53.866
I should say next year's in the January
26 stewardship report.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1624-0
00:13:54.226 --> 00:13:58.626
Our goal is to have proposed bill
language.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1629-0
00:14:00.756 --> 00:14:03.756
To update the battery program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1647-0
00:14:04.966 --> 00:14:08.297
OK. If I recall correctly,
the committee can offer language based
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1647-1
00:14:08.297 --> 00:14:10.366
upon the report each year. Is that right?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1650-0
00:14:10.766 --> 00:14:12.406
That's my understanding, yes.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1652-0
00:14:12.666 --> 00:14:13.746
OK. Thanks.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1658-0
00:14:25.296 --> 00:14:27.336
All right. OK, well.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1662-0
00:14:29.116 --> 00:14:29.796
Ashley Ashley.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1664-0
00:14:29.796 --> 00:14:30.636
OK, Ashley, great.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1670-0
00:14:31.996 --> 00:14:33.276
Hi, thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1676-0
00:14:33.276 --> 00:14:34.276
My name is Ashley.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1683-0
00:14:34.276 --> 00:14:37.116
I'm here representing Redwood materials.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1693-0
00:14:37.116 --> 00:14:40.556
We're North America's largest lithium ion
battery recycler.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1735-0
00:14:40.956 --> 00:14:45.259
Thanks for creating this,
this time for us to talk about this and
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1735-1
00:14:45.259 --> 00:14:49.301
have this discussion.
I just have a quick question at the top
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1735-2
00:14:49.301 --> 00:14:52.431
here and apologies if it was in your your
memo,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1735-3
00:14:52.431 --> 00:14:57.516
but is there like a formal comment period
or opportunity to send in a letter?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1750-0
00:14:58.316 --> 00:15:02.396
Or just like synthesize some of our our
feedback to your questions.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1752-0
00:15:02.786 --> 00:15:03.666
In a written format.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1762-0
00:15:04.256 --> 00:15:06.292
Right.
So we're kind of in an informal
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1762-1
00:15:06.292 --> 00:15:07.336
stakeholder process.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1769-0
00:15:07.336 --> 00:15:11.016
You can we we wholeheartedly encourage.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1777-0
00:15:12.716 --> 00:15:14.876
All to send us comments during this time
period.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1791-0
00:15:16.716 --> 00:15:21.676
We're we're probably going to have
because we have to have an end point.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1798-0
00:15:23.556 --> 00:15:25.156
So we can start working on that language.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1809-0
00:15:26.916 --> 00:15:32.516
We're probably gonna have a an endpoint
the week after the second meeting.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1823-0
00:15:33.906 --> 00:15:39.906
Calendar in front of me,
but any and all comments can be submitted.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1826-0
00:15:41.396 --> 00:15:42.596
To the battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1836-0
00:15:44.596 --> 00:15:48.676
Web the battery program e-mail that's on
our website.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1838-0
00:15:51.976 --> 00:15:52.256
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1841-0
00:15:52.126 --> 00:15:52.806
Ah, thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1840-0
00:15:52.256 --> 00:15:52.656
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1857-0
00:15:54.556 --> 00:15:58.155
Yeah.
So actually we're looking to get put an
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1857-1
00:15:58.155 --> 00:16:01.676
endpoint of written comments September
12th.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1859-0
00:16:12.976 --> 00:16:13.416
Katie.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1868-0
00:16:15.876 --> 00:16:19.516
Brian Nope. OK, sure, Katie.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1887-0
00:16:20.776 --> 00:16:24.821
Hi, thank you, Katie Riley.
I'm with the Consumer Technology
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1887-1
00:16:24.821 --> 00:16:25.616
Association.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1890-0
00:16:25.896 --> 00:16:27.536
I sent an e-mail this morning.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1915-0
00:16:27.536 --> 00:16:32.743
I did just want to flag for you all that
your September 4th meeting overlaps with
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1915-1
00:16:32.743 --> 00:16:36.616
a similar stakeholder process that's
happening in Minnesota.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1939-0
00:16:36.776 --> 00:16:40.372
So I did want to see if there was a
possibility of either delaying that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1939-1
00:16:40.372 --> 00:16:43.967
meeting or moving to a different date
just because I think a lot of the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1939-2
00:16:43.967 --> 00:16:44.616
stakeholders.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1954-0
00:16:45.356 --> 00:16:49.556
Participating here are also involved in
the Minnesota process and the Minnesota
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1954-1
00:16:49.556 --> 00:16:50.396
dates have been.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1971-0
00:16:50.826 --> 00:16:55.786
That for quite a while at this point.
Just wondering if like that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1979-0
00:16:54.146 --> 00:16:58.212
Sure. Yeah.
I think what we'll probably look at doing
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/1979-1
00:16:58.212 --> 00:17:00.546
is just moving our time period.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2006-0
00:17:01.996 --> 00:17:05.540
So it's after Minnesota's on that same
day.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2006-1
00:17:05.540 --> 00:17:11.822
Just because we are kind of on a tight
time schedule in order to meet the the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2006-2
00:17:11.822 --> 00:17:13.996
reporting requirements. So.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2005-0
00:17:14.816 --> 00:17:15.176
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2015-0
00:17:15.216 --> 00:17:16.456
Thank you for considering that move.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2017-0
00:17:15.756 --> 00:17:16.916
We'll we will.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2021-0
00:17:16.456 --> 00:17:18.056
I think I put the end time in there.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2026-0
00:17:18.636 --> 00:17:21.066
Yeah,
we'll follow up with anyone who sent an
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2026-1
00:17:21.066 --> 00:17:21.436
e-mail.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2028-0
00:17:23.116 --> 00:17:23.436
Or is attending.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2042-0
00:17:23.666 --> 00:17:27.446
I guess we'll, we'll,
we'll we'll firm up that within the next
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2042-1
00:17:27.446 --> 00:17:27.746
week.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2063-0
00:17:34.066 --> 00:17:38.500
Yeah. Hi, Anthony.
Scott with the Vapors Association on the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2063-1
00:17:38.500 --> 00:17:42.786
chain of H stores and just wanted to give
a little input.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2085-0
00:17:44.316 --> 00:17:46.821
You spoke about Senator Bennett,
who met with him.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2085-1
00:17:46.821 --> 00:17:49.276
He told one of our stores to one of our
location.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2116-0
00:17:49.556 --> 00:17:52.707
And you know,
we started talking for for a little while
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2116-1
00:17:52.707 --> 00:17:56.421
and he understood, like,
some of the difficulties that it's going
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2116-2
00:17:56.421 --> 00:17:59.178
to be to create a stewardship program for,
like,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2116-3
00:17:59.178 --> 00:18:03.116
disposable base to be able to get rid of
these products and bring in.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2128-0
00:18:03.586 --> 00:18:07.391
It being acute hazardous waste because
the nicotine is all built in with the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2128-1
00:18:07.391 --> 00:18:07.786
battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2143-0
00:18:09.276 --> 00:18:12.456
So I mean,
we're looking for a pathway forward to be
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2143-1
00:18:12.456 --> 00:18:14.316
able to dispose of these items.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2149-0
00:18:15.956 --> 00:18:18.756
Efficiently and cost effectively.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2171-0
00:18:20.436 --> 00:18:23.346
And it also the base that we sell,
there's two different kinds,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2171-1
00:18:23.346 --> 00:18:25.756
some that batters have broken apart from
each other.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2181-0
00:18:26.156 --> 00:18:29.956
So I think those are easier Ave.
for us to be able to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2184-0
00:18:31.676 --> 00:18:32.196
Dispose of.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2206-0
00:18:33.646 --> 00:18:37.363
Even with like the call the recycle
program that's already set up in the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2206-1
00:18:37.363 --> 00:18:40.366
state of Maine,
just looking for some more input and then,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2206-2
00:18:40.366 --> 00:18:41.486
you know, maybe I can.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2211-0
00:18:42.946 --> 00:18:45.426
Get more info later. Mm-hmm. Bye.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2222-0
00:18:45.746 --> 00:18:48.626
Yeah, I mean, I actually should say too,
that there was a, a, A.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2224-0
00:18:52.156 --> 00:18:52.476
Product stewardship.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2226-0
00:18:54.236 --> 00:18:54.436
Program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2233-0
00:18:56.076 --> 00:18:57.196
Came out of the ENR committee.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2243-0
00:18:59.996 --> 00:19:04.716
And was tabled at the appropriations
table to be taken up next year.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2254-0
00:19:06.356 --> 00:19:11.676
That was specific as vape product
stewardship program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2256-0
00:19:12.686 --> 00:19:13.526
Specific.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2269-0
00:19:20.906 --> 00:19:23.434
Brett Scott,
I also a member of the Main Labour
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2269-1
00:19:23.434 --> 00:19:24.066
Association.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2296-0
00:19:24.066 --> 00:19:27.845
I own Smoker Tavern canvas haven with
location New Hampshire, Maine.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2296-1
00:19:27.845 --> 00:19:31.733
But one other thing I just want to
mention is that you know has a bank
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2296-2
00:19:31.733 --> 00:19:35.786
considered to establish separate sales
tax rate for items with a battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2330-0
00:19:35.866 --> 00:19:39.813
So then it's kind of Fair and equitable
across all industries and then some of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2330-1
00:19:39.813 --> 00:19:43.509
that money could be used towards
establishing a larger state program that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2330-2
00:19:43.509 --> 00:19:46.906
you know is across the state as a whole
to address this as a whole.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2338-0
00:19:46.946 --> 00:19:50.306
I know vapes are one piece of it,
but you know there's batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2349-0
00:19:50.386 --> 00:19:53.709
And so many devices at this point,
it would really bring all the industries
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2349-1
00:19:53.709 --> 00:19:54.146
into this.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2373-0
00:19:55.636 --> 00:19:58.931
Right.
So that's part of The thing is that we're
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2373-1
00:19:58.931 --> 00:20:03.436
looking at is a is A is a a wider
universe of of battery programs.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2387-0
00:20:05.236 --> 00:20:09.301
And probably not a sales tax type of
program,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2387-1
00:20:09.301 --> 00:20:12.836
but more of a a producer funded program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2395-0
00:20:19.316 --> 00:20:21.865
Yeah.
So what happens if producers aren't
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2395-1
00:20:21.865 --> 00:20:22.836
willing to join?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2398-0
00:20:24.436 --> 00:20:25.276
Generally.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2430-0
00:20:27.596 --> 00:20:32.731
The requirement are for producers to join
and the biggest thing is a salesman.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2430-1
00:20:32.731 --> 00:20:35.591
If if.
If someone is not participating in a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2430-2
00:20:35.591 --> 00:20:39.816
program then their products can't be sold
in the state of Maine.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2430-3
00:20:39.816 --> 00:20:41.116
So like for example.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2432-0
00:20:42.836 --> 00:20:43.716
Paint care.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2440-0
00:20:45.476 --> 00:20:49.556
Paint producers are members of a product
stewardship program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2457-0
00:20:50.586 --> 00:20:53.811
And if a paint manufacturer is not a
member,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2457-1
00:20:53.811 --> 00:20:57.466
then it's its products can't be sold in
the state.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2462-0
00:21:05.776 --> 00:21:07.936
You got a question back there.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2465-0
00:21:07.936 --> 00:21:09.016
Oh, hi.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2469-0
00:21:09.416 --> 00:21:11.096
Hi, how are you, Brian?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2473-0
00:21:11.136 --> 00:21:12.336
Good. Hi, good.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2482-0
00:21:12.336 --> 00:21:15.216
I'm Owen Casas,
also with the Vapors Association.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2498-0
00:21:15.216 --> 00:21:18.350
Apologies for coming late,
so if I bring up something that was
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2498-1
00:21:18.350 --> 00:21:21.136
already discussed,
please feel free to just correct me.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2528-0
00:21:22.716 --> 00:21:27.229
But when you and I had talked one of the
aspects that I thought related to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2528-1
00:21:27.229 --> 00:21:31.683
electronic smoking devices that the
department did want to figure out is,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2528-2
00:21:31.683 --> 00:21:36.316
did you have like a term for like
integrated battery or something like that?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2555-0
00:21:36.866 --> 00:21:43.530
And do we look at devices with integrated
batteries in a separate bin than
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2555-1
00:21:43.530 --> 00:21:48.506
batteries that are not integrated to the
device itself?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2561-0
00:21:48.906 --> 00:21:51.666
So I guess first, do I have that correct?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2582-0
00:21:51.826 --> 00:21:55.886
And then second is,
I would provide input based on how you
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2582-1
00:21:55.886 --> 00:21:59.395
responded,
whether I had that correct or well sure
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2582-2
00:21:59.395 --> 00:22:01.666
that's actually a a question for.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2593-0
00:22:02.476 --> 00:22:06.556
The larger the larger universe of battery
containing items.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2633-0
00:22:06.706 --> 00:22:10.025
'Cause,
there's a lot that is one of the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2633-1
00:22:10.025 --> 00:22:15.933
questions that we've posed in in our
background document are looking for
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2633-2
00:22:15.933 --> 00:22:22.003
feedback on or or or how how should
products that have and not just fakes,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2633-3
00:22:22.003 --> 00:22:27.426
but any products that have embedded
batteries, what is the way to?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2645-0
00:22:30.156 --> 00:22:33.448
What is the?
What is the way to to handle the end of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2645-1
00:22:33.448 --> 00:22:34.876
life of those products?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2652-0
00:22:37.106 --> 00:22:38.386
Is it through?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2658-0
00:22:39.066 --> 00:22:42.226
Would it be through a larger the battery?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2659-0
00:22:42.706 --> 00:22:43.266
It's several.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2667-0
00:22:43.266 --> 00:22:44.626
There's, I mean, there's several options.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2671-0
00:22:44.626 --> 00:22:45.986
You can go with that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2685-0
00:22:46.226 --> 00:22:52.995
You can have them have the the producers
of those products be part of the battery
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2685-1
00:22:52.995 --> 00:22:55.306
product stewardship program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2703-0
00:22:56.756 --> 00:23:04.127
Or you could have those be a separate
program that would either be of their own
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2703-1
00:23:04.127 --> 00:23:04.956
or could.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2714-0
00:23:05.346 --> 00:23:10.106
Or could fall into an existing the
existing e-waste program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2736-0
00:23:10.106 --> 00:23:16.933
And that's part of what we're looking for
feedback on is what, what what's what?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2736-1
00:23:16.933 --> 00:23:21.906
Our thoughts for how embedded batteries
are to be handled.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2751-0
00:23:24.636 --> 00:23:27.836
Based on you confirming that was like
part of what you're looking for.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2759-0
00:23:27.836 --> 00:23:29.716
Feedback on that's what we're looking for.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2764-0
00:23:29.716 --> 00:23:32.436
Feedback on building on what Anthony was
saying.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2770-0
00:23:33.996 --> 00:23:35.836
And what you're saying,
so there's products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2812-0
00:23:36.066 --> 00:23:39.642
Generally,
we're more interested or like concerned
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2812-1
00:23:39.642 --> 00:23:45.461
about electronic smoking devices and they
seem to fall into like a couple of bins.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2812-2
00:23:45.461 --> 00:23:51.139
One of the bins to where the batteries
are not integrated or the other term that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2812-3
00:23:51.139 --> 00:23:54.575
you use,
it's really easy to separate those into
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2812-4
00:23:54.575 --> 00:23:55.556
their own was.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2816-0
00:23:55.556 --> 00:23:56.786
Stream there's not like.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2837-0
00:23:58.076 --> 00:24:03.654
Hazardous waste concerns and then the
tapes that have are electronic smoking
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2837-1
00:24:03.654 --> 00:24:07.276
devices that have batteries integrated
into them.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2856-0
00:24:07.906 --> 00:24:11.342
They seem to fall also into a couple of
bins,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2856-1
00:24:11.342 --> 00:24:16.346
ones to where you can reasonably extract
and separate the battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2884-0
00:24:16.666 --> 00:24:22.397
Now making it just like any other battery
that you kind of have around and then a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2884-1
00:24:22.397 --> 00:24:27.987
number of products that have batteries
that you can't necessarily or reasonably
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2884-2
00:24:27.987 --> 00:24:28.546
extract.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2908-0
00:24:30.236 --> 00:24:35.608
With tools that are not specialized or
something of that nature or specialized
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2908-1
00:24:35.608 --> 00:24:38.736
process,
and that's something that I'm really
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2908-2
00:24:38.736 --> 00:24:41.116
interested in because I think that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2916-0
00:24:42.876 --> 00:24:45.996
Our interests align with Debs as far as.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2955-0
00:24:46.386 --> 00:24:51.927
End of life care with these products.
And so for me and I believe a lot of shop
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2955-1
00:24:51.927 --> 00:24:56.983
owners getting as many of those
integrated batteries that can reasonably
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2955-2
00:24:56.983 --> 00:25:02.316
be removed from the devices into the
waste stream with all the other product
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2955-3
00:25:02.316 --> 00:25:05.156
batteries that we're trying to have. Ste.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2969-0
00:25:05.226 --> 00:25:09.146
Over is something that I would like to
better understand.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2972-0
00:25:09.466 --> 00:25:10.906
What does reasonable look like?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2980-0
00:25:10.906 --> 00:25:12.626
I've taken some of these devices apart.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/2984-0
00:25:12.626 --> 00:25:15.306
They're on large portion of the market.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3023-0
00:25:16.266 --> 00:25:21.676
And so to have this very large and
growing portion of the market be viewed
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3023-1
00:25:21.676 --> 00:25:26.004
as entirely separate,
when I believe you can reasonably get
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3023-2
00:25:26.004 --> 00:25:31.486
some of a lot of these batteries out that
I would just love to know how the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3023-3
00:25:31.486 --> 00:25:34.876
department plans to kind of evaluate that
and.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3031-0
00:25:34.876 --> 00:25:36.226
Find out what are we?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3035-0
00:25:36.266 --> 00:25:38.146
What percentage are we talking here?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3036-0
00:25:38.186 --> 00:25:38.866
How easy?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3038-0
00:25:38.866 --> 00:25:39.866
How hard?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3046-0
00:25:40.146 --> 00:25:42.375
Well,
part of that would be like the definition
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3046-1
00:25:42.375 --> 00:25:42.746
of what?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3052-0
00:25:43.476 --> 00:25:45.076
An A product with an embedded battery is.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3062-0
00:25:45.426 --> 00:25:47.266
Is and that's part of it. Is what?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3111-0
00:25:47.466 --> 00:25:53.145
What would be the level of effort for
removing a battery from a product that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3111-1
00:25:53.145 --> 00:25:59.118
would make it embedded versus actually a
removable and what's what we're looking
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3111-2
00:25:59.118 --> 00:26:02.363
for input on and like and and when we
talk,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3111-3
00:26:02.363 --> 00:26:07.156
nonscientific to try to figure out how
easy it seems like there.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3120-0
00:26:07.156 --> 00:26:10.626
Are a lot of these products electronic
spoken devices and otherwise?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3132-0
00:26:11.356 --> 00:26:14.128
That the batteries are considered
embedded,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3132-1
00:26:14.128 --> 00:26:16.396
but through a simple process can be.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3138-0
00:26:16.866 --> 00:26:20.586
Removed extracted and flow into the
regular waste stream.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3148-0
00:26:20.706 --> 00:26:22.826
OK. And then the other products can't,
right?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3166-0
00:26:22.826 --> 00:26:27.920
And that would be something that we would
be looking for input on as to what what
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3166-1
00:26:27.920 --> 00:26:31.026
makes a battery embedded versus removable,
right?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3173-0
00:26:31.026 --> 00:26:32.666
With that, we have some other hands.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3188-0
00:26:32.866 --> 00:26:36.170
Yep,
let's go first with Katie and for people
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3188-1
00:26:36.170 --> 00:26:39.546
online,
we are going through a laptop speaker.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3196-0
00:26:39.546 --> 00:26:42.352
So please,
if you could speak loudly and clearly,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3196-1
00:26:42.352 --> 00:26:43.306
we appreciate it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3213-0
00:26:44.926 --> 00:26:47.845
Sure.
Katie Riley with Consumer Technology
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3213-1
00:26:47.845 --> 00:26:49.406
association. CTA again.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3253-0
00:26:49.606 --> 00:26:53.781
We'll also be happy to provide written
comments and we're not sure it's sort of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3253-1
00:26:53.781 --> 00:26:57.748
how we're structuring this meeting if
we're going to be responding later to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3253-2
00:26:57.748 --> 00:27:01.766
like specific questions or like have an
agenda, we're going to flow through.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3270-0
00:27:02.006 --> 00:27:05.853
But I do just want to note that loose
batteries and products have very
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3270-1
00:27:05.853 --> 00:27:07.966
different collection systems and needs.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3273-0
00:27:07.966 --> 00:27:09.526
And so we shouldn't be looking.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3288-0
00:27:10.436 --> 00:27:14.676
To lump the collection of loose batteries
in with products that may have.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3295-0
00:27:14.826 --> 00:27:16.786
Embedded batteries in them.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3299-0
00:27:16.826 --> 00:27:18.746
They need separate systems.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3349-0
00:27:18.986 --> 00:27:22.398
Additionally,
we have an existing electronics EPR
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3349-1
00:27:22.398 --> 00:27:26.355
program here in Maine.
I think as we talk about products,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3349-2
00:27:26.355 --> 00:27:31.608
we should view it through the lens of
what's compatible with the electronics
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3349-3
00:27:31.608 --> 00:27:35.634
recycling system itself.
As we talk about battery embedded
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3349-4
00:27:35.634 --> 00:27:39.113
products,
not all products with embedded batteries
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3349-5
00:27:39.113 --> 00:27:39.386
are.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3358-0
00:27:40.036 --> 00:27:42.516
Compatible with the electronics recycling
system.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3397-0
00:27:43.106 --> 00:27:45.885
Are capable of being managed within that
system,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3397-1
00:27:45.885 --> 00:27:49.799
and since the discussion has been on
vapes, I'm not a vaping expert.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3397-2
00:27:49.799 --> 00:27:54.279
But I do know that cannabis is legal
there in Maine and therefore you get into
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3397-3
00:27:54.279 --> 00:27:58.476
a lot of hazardous waste laws and ability
to move those products outside.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3427-0
00:27:58.476 --> 00:28:02.653
The state of Maine to be handled or
recycled, and I know that vapes,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3427-1
00:28:02.653 --> 00:28:06.831
if you would talk to an electronics
recycling company are not at all
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3427-2
00:28:06.831 --> 00:28:08.586
compatible with their system.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3432-0
00:28:08.586 --> 00:28:10.786
So just something for us to think about,
I think.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3434-0
00:28:11.516 --> 00:28:11.836
We probably.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3488-0
00:28:12.186 --> 00:28:18.019
We need to move products into a separate
discussion on away from loose batteries
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3488-1
00:28:18.019 --> 00:28:23.203
and then talk about, you know,
within that embedded broad product world
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3488-2
00:28:23.203 --> 00:28:28.748
or scope what is compatible with systems
that may exist like our electronics
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3488-3
00:28:28.748 --> 00:28:32.996
recycling system or what other systems
may need to be set.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3509-0
00:28:32.996 --> 00:28:37.582
Up to manage different materials and I
think at this point in time nobody has a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3509-1
00:28:37.582 --> 00:28:40.906
great picture of what the embedded
battery product world.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3511-0
00:28:41.636 --> 00:28:41.876
Entails.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3526-0
00:28:42.266 --> 00:28:45.906
Other than that,
it's probably a wide variety of products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3567-0
00:28:46.186 --> 00:28:51.127
California's Advanced Recovery Fee system
for battery embedded products officially
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3567-1
00:28:51.127 --> 00:28:54.937
launches on January 1,
and I think once we get that list out of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3567-2
00:28:54.937 --> 00:28:57.795
California,
we'll have a better idea of all the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3567-3
00:28:57.795 --> 00:28:58.866
products in scope.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3585-0
00:28:58.866 --> 00:29:03.990
So this may be a conversation that based
on some additional efforts coming out of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3585-1
00:29:03.990 --> 00:29:07.426
other states,
could be beneficial to sort of delay and
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3585-2
00:29:07.426 --> 00:29:08.426
assess based on.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3589-0
00:29:09.196 --> 00:29:09.716
What we see?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3593-0
00:29:10.466 --> 00:29:11.786
In terms of those lists.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3619-0
00:29:10.696 --> 00:29:14.807
Right. Just to build on that,
I mean one of the things that we're
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3619-1
00:29:14.807 --> 00:29:19.353
looking for too is if there are
particular states or other jurisdictions
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3619-2
00:29:19.353 --> 00:29:19.976
that have.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3637-0
00:29:21.916 --> 00:29:26.076
People feel are very are successful
programs that may could harmonize with.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3644-0
00:29:26.076 --> 00:29:29.196
That's what we would be looking for
information on.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3665-0
00:29:27.976 --> 00:29:31.422
No. Yeah,
no and no state right now has a program
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3665-1
00:29:31.422 --> 00:29:34.936
specifically focused on battery embedded
products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3681-0
00:29:34.936 --> 00:29:37.525
Just so you know,
with the exception of California,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3681-1
00:29:37.525 --> 00:29:39.416
but that's that advanced recovery fee.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3710-0
00:29:39.456 --> 00:29:43.643
It's the fee charged at the point of sale
or purchase to consumers,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3710-1
00:29:43.643 --> 00:29:48.692
so it's a very different structure than
what you all are talking about here under
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3710-2
00:29:48.692 --> 00:29:51.216
kind of the guise of product stewardship.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3712-0
00:29:54.636 --> 00:29:55.036
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3714-0
00:29:55.036 --> 00:29:55.956
Thank you for that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3717-0
00:29:57.436 --> 00:29:58.716
Mark, you are next.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3723-0
00:30:01.356 --> 00:30:02.196
Yes, good afternoon.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3728-0
00:30:02.196 --> 00:30:03.236
My name is Mark Miller.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3733-0
00:30:03.236 --> 00:30:05.476
I represent Volvo Group North America.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3743-0
00:30:05.556 --> 00:30:08.676
We're a producer of medium,
heavy and heavy heavy duty.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3759-0
00:30:10.596 --> 00:30:13.318
Trucks, buses,
motor coaches as well as non road
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3759-1
00:30:13.318 --> 00:30:14.596
construction equipment.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3784-0
00:30:15.666 --> 00:30:20.151
I just heard a lot about this universe of
batteries and I wanted to make sure that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3784-1
00:30:20.151 --> 00:30:23.826
everybody understands how big this
universe of batteries really is.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3790-0
00:30:24.226 --> 00:30:27.106
We deal with battery packs.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3801-0
00:30:27.146 --> 00:30:33.138
Multiple battery packs on a Class 8
tractor that are 94 kilowatt hours or
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3801-1
00:30:33.138 --> 00:30:33.786
greater.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3818-0
00:30:35.516 --> 00:30:39.760
And we could have anywhere from 4:00 to
6:00 battery packs on these these
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3818-1
00:30:39.760 --> 00:30:40.276
tractors.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3824-0
00:30:42.036 --> 00:30:44.516
So keep in mind that that we're.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3831-0
00:30:44.866 --> 00:30:46.826
Just talking small vape batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3835-0
00:30:47.066 --> 00:30:50.866
We're talking very large capacity.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3839-0
00:30:52.236 --> 00:30:52.876
Vehicle batteries as well.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3873-0
00:30:54.636 --> 00:30:59.362
So I know that in the collection and
convenience section of your your document
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3873-1
00:30:59.362 --> 00:31:03.848
that you put out to kind of guide this
conversation you were asking about,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3873-2
00:31:03.848 --> 00:31:07.676
should vehicle batteries be a specific
program through dealers?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3886-0
00:31:09.476 --> 00:31:12.192
I wouldn't say necessarily through the
dealers themselves,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3886-1
00:31:12.192 --> 00:31:14.356
but I think it needs to be a separate
program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3888-0
00:31:14.666 --> 00:31:15.866
Gramp for sure.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3894-0
00:31:17.316 --> 00:31:18.596
Because the concerns are very different
here.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3896-0
00:31:19.306 --> 00:31:19.866
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3898-0
00:31:21.106 --> 00:31:21.826
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3903-0
00:31:22.036 --> 00:31:23.076
Sure. Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3914-0
00:31:23.076 --> 00:31:26.516
Yeah, that's the thing we're looking for.
Input on what?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3935-0
00:31:26.516 --> 00:31:32.325
You know what format size batteries would
be appropriate for a program and which
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3935-1
00:31:32.325 --> 00:31:34.476
ones would be best suited for?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3940-0
00:31:36.876 --> 00:31:38.756
Another means of end of life.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3943-0
00:31:44.056 --> 00:31:44.416
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3946-0
00:31:44.416 --> 00:31:46.296
Thank you, mark. Jennifer.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3953-0
00:31:52.746 --> 00:31:53.466
There we go.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3963-0
00:31:53.586 --> 00:31:58.677
Hello, Jennifer Dappolonio, again.
Main DEP's hazardous Waste management
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3963-1
00:31:58.677 --> 00:31:59.026
unit.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3973-0
00:31:59.866 --> 00:32:03.986
I just wanted to give everybody a little
more information about.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3993-0
00:32:05.396 --> 00:32:09.817
Batteries under and how they're handled
on their R program at end of life,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/3993-1
00:32:09.817 --> 00:32:12.116
they are a category of universal waste.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4012-0
00:32:14.236 --> 00:32:21.667
We we follow the federal rules in 40 CFR
part 273 when it comes to waste battery
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4012-1
00:32:21.667 --> 00:32:22.676
management.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4041-0
00:32:23.906 --> 00:32:27.882
And excuse me,
we also have an abbreviated license
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4041-1
00:32:27.882 --> 00:32:34.118
requirement here in the state of Maine
and that gets into what is considered an
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4041-2
00:32:34.118 --> 00:32:37.626
embedded battery versus a removable
battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4059-0
00:32:39.116 --> 00:32:44.021
If you are dealing with an embedded
battery and you take apart in a device
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4059-1
00:32:44.021 --> 00:32:47.356
whether it's a computer or a vape device,
whatnot.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4072-0
00:32:49.076 --> 00:32:52.196
To remove a battery that is not designed
to be removed.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4092-0
00:32:52.806 --> 00:32:56.895
That is considered dismantling of
universal waste and it requires a license,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4092-1
00:32:56.895 --> 00:32:58.966
a demanding factoring facility license.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4118-0
00:33:00.556 --> 00:33:05.107
So that that will have some challenges
when we're talking about vape devices
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4118-1
00:33:05.107 --> 00:33:08.476
that have batteries that are not designed
to be removed.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4145-0
00:33:10.556 --> 00:33:16.712
We have been in talks with other States
and the EPA going back to specifically
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4145-1
00:33:16.712 --> 00:33:21.076
the issue of vapes where it is a multi
pronged problem.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4194-0
00:33:21.986 --> 00:33:26.041
That's going to require the multi pronged
solution because like the,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4194-1
00:33:26.041 --> 00:33:29.333
the third gentleman who spoke about vapes
talked about,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4194-2
00:33:29.333 --> 00:33:32.741
we're not only looking at the battery as
universal waste,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4194-3
00:33:32.741 --> 00:33:36.209
but we're looking at nicotine as an acute
hazardous waste.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4194-4
00:33:36.209 --> 00:33:39.676
And we're also looking at the potential
of cannabis being.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4203-0
00:33:39.676 --> 00:33:43.826
Transported across state lines as a
schedule one drug federally.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4210-0
00:33:44.746 --> 00:33:49.106
So EPA, we're still in talks.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4223-0
00:33:49.346 --> 00:33:53.426
We're looking at other states to to
figure out how we can all move forward.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4239-0
00:33:54.876 --> 00:33:59.238
In a consistent manner to to try to get a
hold on this nationally,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4239-1
00:33:59.238 --> 00:34:01.516
but I wanted to make you all aware.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4270-0
00:34:03.316 --> 00:34:07.665
That if the battery is not designed to be
removed from the vape,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4270-1
00:34:07.665 --> 00:34:12.951
then there are additional considerations
and we have been talking to receiving
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4270-2
00:34:12.951 --> 00:34:14.356
facilities universal.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4307-0
00:34:14.666 --> 00:34:17.723
And how's it was waste receiving
facilities across the country.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4307-1
00:34:17.723 --> 00:34:20.875
And the problem is when they get one of
these integrated devices,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4307-2
00:34:20.875 --> 00:34:23.358
the one the facilities who deal with the
batteries,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4307-3
00:34:23.358 --> 00:34:25.746
they don't want to deal with the
hazardous waste.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4328-0
00:34:25.746 --> 00:34:29.781
They don't want to deal with the nicotine,
the ones who are receiving the nicotine
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4328-1
00:34:29.781 --> 00:34:32.260
most of the time,
they don't want to deal with the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4328-2
00:34:32.260 --> 00:34:32.746
batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4339-0
00:34:33.186 --> 00:34:37.924
So perhaps finding out a way to separate
these waste streams is something that we
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4339-1
00:34:37.924 --> 00:34:38.906
should look into.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4386-0
00:34:42.106 --> 00:34:48.002
In general, as far as embedded devices go,
I'm sure you are all aware that they can
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4386-1
00:34:48.002 --> 00:34:53.616
be problematic at when they get to the
receiving facility. If they're glued in,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4386-2
00:34:53.616 --> 00:34:58.108
it could be dangerous for the technician
trying to remove them,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4386-3
00:34:58.108 --> 00:35:01.266
and once that battery is compromised in
any.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4402-0
00:35:01.266 --> 00:35:06.681
Way it falls out of Maine's universal
waste universe into the hazardous waste
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4402-1
00:35:06.681 --> 00:35:07.306
universe.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4418-0
00:35:08.076 --> 00:35:12.476
So there's also that consideration for
any battery that is not designed.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4422-0
00:35:12.946 --> 00:35:13.786
To be removed.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4426-0
00:35:16.466 --> 00:35:17.786
I think that's all I have for now.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4429-0
00:35:19.506 --> 00:35:20.186
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4431-0
00:35:21.026 --> 00:35:21.786
Thanks, Jennifer.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4433-0
00:35:23.316 --> 00:35:23.876
Mark.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4438-0
00:35:28.106 --> 00:35:28.586
There we go.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4444-0
00:35:28.586 --> 00:35:30.211
Sorry,
I was just making sure my camera was
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4444-1
00:35:30.211 --> 00:35:30.506
working.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4460-0
00:35:30.506 --> 00:35:34.026
Hi, it's Mark, bullish with Prba.
The Rechargeable Battery association.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4476-0
00:35:34.386 --> 00:35:37.275
I had spoken to Courtney about just,
you know,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4476-1
00:35:37.275 --> 00:35:41.700
what is happening with the loose
batteries around the the country right
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4476-2
00:35:41.700 --> 00:35:41.946
now.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4499-0
00:35:41.946 --> 00:35:44.866
I don't know if this would be the time to
to frame that up,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4499-1
00:35:44.866 --> 00:35:47.542
or if you had a idea of doing that a
little bit later,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4499-2
00:35:47.542 --> 00:35:49.586
but I'm happy to do it now or or whenever.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4516-0
00:35:51.566 --> 00:35:55.562
Yeah.
Why don't we go ahead and and do that now,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4516-1
00:35:55.562 --> 00:36:00.046
'cause. Yeah,
I believe I need to throw that up there.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4522-0
00:36:00.086 --> 00:36:01.166
OK, that's true.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4520-0
00:36:01.526 --> 00:36:01.766
I can.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4533-0
00:36:01.886 --> 00:36:04.246
I can share it as well if it's if it's
enabled.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4530-0
00:36:03.076 --> 00:36:03.436
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4531-0
00:36:03.436 --> 00:36:04.076
Yes, absolutely.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4534-0
00:36:04.076 --> 00:36:05.196
Go ahead. Yeah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4539-0
00:36:06.556 --> 00:36:09.196
Actually it's grayed out. Sorry.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4541-0
00:36:11.036 --> 00:36:11.196
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4545-0
00:36:11.196 --> 00:36:12.436
Yeah, 'cause, it's a webinar.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4551-0
00:36:12.436 --> 00:36:15.076
It's different than a meeting,
so one second.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4556-0
00:36:22.776 --> 00:36:24.276
That's not what I wanted to do.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4562-0
00:36:40.426 --> 00:36:40.946
Just gonna.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4566-0
00:36:42.386 --> 00:36:43.666
Move everybody to the side.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4568-0
00:36:50.356 --> 00:36:50.996
Sure.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4570-0
00:36:53.356 --> 00:36:53.516
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4572-0
00:36:55.006 --> 00:36:55.366
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4580-0
00:36:55.366 --> 00:36:57.166
Thank you. If you, I promised,
I'd be brief.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4584-0
00:36:57.166 --> 00:36:58.446
So go right to the next slide.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4586-0
00:36:58.446 --> 00:36:59.526
I already introduced myself.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4634-0
00:37:02.896 --> 00:37:05.132
So just a quick snapshot of of who is
prba.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4634-1
00:37:05.132 --> 00:37:08.334
This is just a lot of the different logos
of our Members here.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4634-2
00:37:08.334 --> 00:37:12.044
And if you go to the next slide,
I'll just briefly introduce who is prba
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4634-3
00:37:12.044 --> 00:37:15.296
and then I'll get into what's happening
within the rest of the.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4684-0
00:37:15.296 --> 00:37:18.448
Country prba represents the manufacturers
of batteries,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4684-1
00:37:18.448 --> 00:37:22.163
but also other stakeholders in the
rechargeable battery industry,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4684-2
00:37:22.163 --> 00:37:24.921
really dealing from anything from the
beginning.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4684-3
00:37:24.921 --> 00:37:29.255
Points of like mining all the way through
distribution and even end of life.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4684-4
00:37:29.255 --> 00:37:31.956
We do get involved in a lot of different
areas.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4712-0
00:37:32.786 --> 00:37:37.667
Related to interests of our Members and
not really Jermaine to this conversation
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4712-1
00:37:37.667 --> 00:37:40.740
particularly,
but we also get involved in a lot of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4712-2
00:37:40.740 --> 00:37:42.066
transportation forums.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4733-0
00:37:42.066 --> 00:37:46.420
But the the membership of who we have
there is probably the the best for for
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4733-1
00:37:46.420 --> 00:37:49.586
where you know who we represent in these
conversations.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4738-0
00:37:50.026 --> 00:37:51.546
So if you go to the next slide.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4775-0
00:37:54.136 --> 00:37:59.027
So where we are within the US as of this
is updated still update today.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4775-1
00:37:59.027 --> 00:38:04.054
I updated the slide on August 5th.
The way to look at this is the this is
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4775-2
00:38:04.054 --> 00:38:05.616
for portable batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4796-0
00:38:05.616 --> 00:38:10.914
So consider those we we put portable
batteries together as the small and
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4796-1
00:38:10.914 --> 00:38:12.656
medium format batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4829-0
00:38:12.696 --> 00:38:16.512
Small batteries would be something that
essentially you can fit in your pocket
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4829-1
00:38:16.512 --> 00:38:20.280
and medium format batteries are the
batteries that are of the size that would
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4829-2
00:38:20.280 --> 00:38:23.516
be like for an E bike or a scooter or
something along those lines.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4851-0
00:38:24.306 --> 00:38:26.983
And that distinguishes them from the
large batteries,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4851-1
00:38:26.983 --> 00:38:31.146
which would be something like an electric
vehicle battery or energy storage system.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4890-0
00:38:31.306 --> 00:38:35.094
So the the map that I have here just
covers the portable,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4890-1
00:38:35.094 --> 00:38:39.731
so the small and the medium format,
the states that are in red and the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4890-2
00:38:39.731 --> 00:38:44.759
District of Columbia already have laws on
the books covering EPR programs or
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4890-3
00:38:44.759 --> 00:38:47.306
portable batteries for all chemistries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4897-0
00:38:47.306 --> 00:38:49.826
Essentially,
all chemistries of portable batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4905-0
00:38:50.836 --> 00:38:53.036
So again,
the red states have laws that either.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4926-0
00:38:53.466 --> 00:38:57.544
Have passed in previous years or in the
case of this year, Colorado,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4926-1
00:38:57.544 --> 00:39:00.026
Nebraska and Connecticut passed this year.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4964-0
00:39:00.466 --> 00:39:05.253
The other states are either in the case
of DC, which I know is not a state,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4964-1
00:39:05.253 --> 00:39:09.599
but DC has their program up and running,
and Washington, California,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4964-2
00:39:09.599 --> 00:39:14.701
Illinois and Vermont are in the process
of moving forward with their programs to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4964-3
00:39:14.701 --> 00:39:17.346
start fairly soon. The states that are in.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4966-0
00:39:17.346 --> 00:39:17.706
Yellow.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4982-0
00:39:18.516 --> 00:39:22.802
Are two different versions of the yellows,
the ones that have the the crossing
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/4982-1
00:39:22.802 --> 00:39:23.236
through.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5017-0
00:39:23.546 --> 00:39:28.603
Them or states that had some level of
activity on battery, portable battery,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5017-1
00:39:28.603 --> 00:39:33.661
EPR this year but did not get out of
session with them for a very variety of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5017-2
00:39:33.661 --> 00:39:34.186
reasons.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5050-0
00:39:34.386 --> 00:39:37.493
And then New York,
PA and New Jersey have sessions that last
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5050-1
00:39:37.493 --> 00:39:40.854
either through the end of the year.
In the case of New Jersey and
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5050-2
00:39:40.854 --> 00:39:44.978
Pennsylvania, or in the case of New York,
they have something that is sitting on
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5050-3
00:39:44.978 --> 00:39:46.506
the governor's desk right now.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5054-0
00:39:46.506 --> 00:39:47.786
So it is still open there.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5071-0
00:39:49.036 --> 00:39:53.484
So and and obviously Hawaii's is an
addition there that is did not move
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5071-1
00:39:53.484 --> 00:39:54.596
forward this year.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5076-0
00:39:54.946 --> 00:39:56.466
Or at least with a plan as of yet.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5080-0
00:39:57.956 --> 00:39:58.596
So next slide please.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5115-0
00:40:01.186 --> 00:40:06.335
So Prba does have a model bill that we
have been using that with a lot of these
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5115-1
00:40:06.335 --> 00:40:10.132
state discussions,
the states that have passed laws either
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5115-2
00:40:10.132 --> 00:40:13.864
use a majority,
if not all of the model bill or certainly
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5115-3
00:40:13.864 --> 00:40:15.666
a significant portion of it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5140-0
00:40:16.546 --> 00:40:20.153
And I did promise to be brief,
so I'll quickly walk through these that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5140-1
00:40:20.153 --> 00:40:23.353
model, bill, as I said,
it has been a template for many of the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5140-2
00:40:23.353 --> 00:40:24.826
states that have passed laws.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5173-0
00:40:25.496 --> 00:40:28.917
And it does at a high level,
have key components to it,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5173-1
00:40:28.917 --> 00:40:33.315
the first one being state oversight,
such as review a plan submissions,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5173-2
00:40:33.315 --> 00:40:36.736
approval of those submissions,
and then annual reports.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5216-0
00:40:37.336 --> 00:40:41.297
It does contain a battery stewardship
organization in the model or
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5216-1
00:40:41.297 --> 00:40:43.899
organizations.
It does not limit it to one.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5216-2
00:40:43.899 --> 00:40:47.801
Some states choose to do that,
but it is not in our model and the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5216-3
00:40:47.801 --> 00:40:52.590
stewardship organization is because when
you're dealing with portable batteries,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5216-4
00:40:52.590 --> 00:40:54.186
you can be looking in some.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5219-0
00:40:54.256 --> 00:40:54.866
Cases as.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5259-0
00:40:55.096 --> 00:40:57.959
As many as hundreds of different
producers, when you,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5259-1
00:40:57.959 --> 00:41:01.563
when you look at all the batteries that
are coming into the market,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5259-2
00:41:01.563 --> 00:41:06.016
it also does set convenience targets for
having collection points within the state.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5263-0
00:41:06.056 --> 00:41:09.096
It calls for a education and training.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5289-0
00:41:09.496 --> 00:41:12.005
It talks,
it has parts in there about best
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5289-1
00:41:12.005 --> 00:41:16.206
practices for the movement and the
ultimate use of those materials once
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5289-2
00:41:16.206 --> 00:41:17.256
they're recovered.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5298-0
00:41:17.616 --> 00:41:21.576
It does contain limited antitrust
protection because you do have.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5307-0
00:41:22.346 --> 00:41:24.826
Competitors essentially getting together
to form a program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5321-0
00:41:25.776 --> 00:41:31.216
So it is limited around just discussions
for the purposes of creating a program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5362-0
00:41:32.586 --> 00:41:35.373
The bill or the model also does contain a
clause,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5362-1
00:41:35.373 --> 00:41:39.888
and they're about right of private action,
which is something that hasn't really
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5362-2
00:41:39.888 --> 00:41:42.564
been used,
but it would just be in the case of,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5362-3
00:41:42.564 --> 00:41:46.466
if a state does not enforce.
If it chooses to pass a law, it gives a.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5379-0
00:41:46.466 --> 00:41:49.470
Stewardship,
organization or organizations the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5379-1
00:41:49.470 --> 00:41:52.986
opportunity to pursue non compliant
producers civilly.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5400-0
00:41:54.096 --> 00:41:57.159
It also does have some limited retailer
obligation.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5400-1
00:41:57.159 --> 00:42:00.870
Retailers in the model are not forced to
be collection points,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5400-2
00:42:00.870 --> 00:42:02.696
but they can opt in to do that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5429-0
00:42:04.186 --> 00:42:08.152
And then the only other provision is that
there is a a sales prohibition in the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5429-1
00:42:08.152 --> 00:42:11.474
model and the retailers just have to
check to make sure that they,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5429-2
00:42:11.474 --> 00:42:13.506
whoever they're buying from is compliant.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5433-0
00:42:13.826 --> 00:42:16.266
There are some exemptions in the model
bill as well.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5448-0
00:42:17.986 --> 00:42:22.322
Some certain types of medical devices
that are not consumer facing are exempted
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5448-1
00:42:22.322 --> 00:42:23.026
in the model.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5506-0
00:42:23.816 --> 00:42:27.630
As well as embedded batteries and
automobile batteries,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5506-1
00:42:27.630 --> 00:42:31.239
regardless of how the automobile
batteries are used,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5506-2
00:42:31.239 --> 00:42:36.483
I know there's been some discussion on
the embedded batteries because of the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5506-3
00:42:36.483 --> 00:42:40.842
unique nature of them,
and that they don't fit perfectly into a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5506-4
00:42:40.842 --> 00:42:44.996
battery program that exists now.
The embedded batteries are.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5515-0
00:42:44.986 --> 00:42:48.136
Something that is being discussed behind
the scenes with a number of states.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5521-0
00:42:48.786 --> 00:42:51.906
And and in fact Washington state.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5563-0
00:42:52.576 --> 00:42:57.110
Illinois and Vermont all have a clause in
their laws that require some type of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5563-1
00:42:57.110 --> 00:43:01.530
report back to the legislatures there.
In the July 2027 time frame on how to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5563-2
00:43:01.530 --> 00:43:06.179
deal with embedded batteries and embedded
as defined as those batteries that are
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5563-3
00:43:06.179 --> 00:43:07.786
not easily removed from the.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5570-0
00:43:07.786 --> 00:43:10.256
Device without essentially damaging the
device.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5574-0
00:43:12.356 --> 00:43:13.356
And I think that's it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5585-0
00:43:13.356 --> 00:43:15.636
I think this next one is just asking for
questions.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5587-0
00:43:15.256 --> 00:43:17.296
May I ask what you got that definition
from?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5588-0
00:43:17.936 --> 00:43:18.536
Yeah, go ahead.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5616-0
00:43:20.226 --> 00:43:23.361
Sir,
that the most recent definition that you
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5616-1
00:43:23.361 --> 00:43:28.608
gave for embedded battery and how it
could be like removed without damaging.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5616-2
00:43:28.608 --> 00:43:31.266
Where did you get that definition from?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5639-0
00:43:33.046 --> 00:43:37.389
I don't know if I can cite one particular
source.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5639-1
00:43:37.389 --> 00:43:42.166
It's been a learning as we've gone along
historically.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5670-0
00:43:42.286 --> 00:43:47.319
There have been provisions in EPR laws,
whether they're in Europe or anywhere
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5670-1
00:43:47.319 --> 00:43:50.804
else in the world or in other states,
Canada as well,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5670-2
00:43:50.804 --> 00:43:55.966
that it says that you cannot remove the
battery without common household tools.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5685-0
00:43:56.606 --> 00:43:58.761
So in other words,
if you can just open the battery
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5685-1
00:43:58.761 --> 00:44:01.206
compartment with your hands,
that would not be considered.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5689-0
00:44:02.306 --> 00:44:03.146
That would be considered.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5711-0
00:44:03.576 --> 00:44:07.321
Considered easily removable,
we've refined it to some extent.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5711-1
00:44:07.321 --> 00:44:11.669
Because OK, I've I've heard this.
The statement that a common household
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5711-2
00:44:11.669 --> 00:44:12.696
tool is a hammer.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5740-0
00:44:13.136 --> 00:44:17.236
So we've refined that definition to some
extent to say that you can't if you use a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5740-1
00:44:17.236 --> 00:44:20.248
screwdriver. That's one thing,
it doesn't damage the device,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5740-2
00:44:20.248 --> 00:44:23.656
but obviously if you're using a hammer
that would damage the device.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5742-0
00:44:24.996 --> 00:44:25.396
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5747-0
00:44:34.606 --> 00:44:35.366
And thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5754-0
00:44:35.646 --> 00:44:37.966
I as as I mentioned to Courtney,
I promised I would be brief.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5779-0
00:44:39.116 --> 00:44:42.538
OK,
I'm gonna leave this for a second in case
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5779-1
00:44:42.538 --> 00:44:48.192
anybody would like Mark's information,
and then we'll go back and check on,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5779-2
00:44:48.192 --> 00:44:50.796
see if there's any other questions.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5788-0
00:45:01.636 --> 00:45:03.716
I think Katie might have a question for
me.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5804-0
00:45:03.766 --> 00:45:07.763
Yes. Yep.
Let me get the camera back on it and all
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5804-1
00:45:07.763 --> 00:45:09.566
right. Go ahead, Katie.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5854-0
00:45:10.296 --> 00:45:14.159
Sure. Not a question for you, Mark,
but I did just want to note,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5854-1
00:45:14.159 --> 00:45:17.369
as I mentioned,
the California law and some questions
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5854-2
00:45:17.369 --> 00:45:22.004
there about how things are defined,
California and its regulations right now,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5854-3
00:45:22.004 --> 00:45:25.273
they're still working on finalizing those
regulations,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5854-4
00:45:25.273 --> 00:45:28.066
but they have definitions around design
to be.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5877-0
00:45:28.066 --> 00:45:33.140
Easily removed from a product by the user
with no more than commonly used household
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5877-1
00:45:33.140 --> 00:45:35.616
tools, and then in conjunction with that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5886-0
00:45:36.386 --> 00:45:39.186
What the definition of commonly used
household tools?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5907-0
00:45:39.576 --> 00:45:43.171
Is. So,
once those regulations are finalized,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5907-1
00:45:43.171 --> 00:45:49.111
there will be a template in terms of
state law that Maine could potentially
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5907-2
00:45:49.111 --> 00:45:49.736
look to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5919-0
00:46:19.326 --> 00:46:20.446
Right, apologies.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5933-0
00:46:20.446 --> 00:46:25.244
Having a little technical difficulties
for a second, but thank you for that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5933-1
00:46:25.244 --> 00:46:26.926
Katie, any other questions?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5941-0
00:46:33.896 --> 00:46:36.776
Knowledge is great until it isn't, yeah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5958-0
00:46:44.596 --> 00:46:50.390
And also just to verify if people are
seeing the conference room and not just
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5958-1
00:46:50.390 --> 00:46:52.396
the question slide anymore.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5964-0
00:46:56.346 --> 00:46:56.986
Anybody can answer?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5966-0
00:46:56.596 --> 00:46:58.356
Yes,
we're just seeing the conference room.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5968-0
00:46:58.786 --> 00:46:59.146
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5972-0
00:46:59.426 --> 00:47:00.666
So it's just us.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/5983-0
00:47:05.236 --> 00:47:09.676
Was the questions like generally speaking,
I guess for his presentation, but.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6000-0
00:47:11.146 --> 00:47:13.749
Yes.
Should we move on to a next point or
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6000-1
00:47:13.749 --> 00:47:17.466
seems like we have no more questions on
Mark's slide marks?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6008-0
00:47:17.466 --> 00:47:20.346
Here is there anyone else anything about
what Mark talked about?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6012-0
00:47:25.396 --> 00:47:26.356
All right. OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6011-0
00:47:26.726 --> 00:47:27.046
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6015-0
00:47:27.046 --> 00:47:27.486
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6016-0
00:47:27.866 --> 00:47:28.706
Thanks mark.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6020-0
00:47:33.586 --> 00:47:35.786
So OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6033-0
00:47:35.786 --> 00:47:37.981
Well,
then I guess I'm going to start going
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6033-1
00:47:37.981 --> 00:47:40.026
through some of the background questions.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6053-0
00:47:41.506 --> 00:47:47.019
So I guess one of the things is in terms
of actual products, what products,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6053-1
00:47:47.019 --> 00:47:50.066
battery products would people like to see?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6066-0
00:47:52.146 --> 00:47:55.866
In in the stewardship program that are
currently in Maine's program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6068-0
00:48:01.956 --> 00:48:02.636
Yep, go ahead.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6073-0
00:48:07.476 --> 00:48:09.596
Oh, oh, yes. Oh, OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6103-0
00:48:11.506 --> 00:48:17.222
Oh, like including EV batteries.
And I would love to see the state of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6103-1
00:48:17.222 --> 00:48:21.386
Maine have every battery that is utilized
in here.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6135-0
00:48:21.386 --> 00:48:25.537
Have some level of stewardship because
batteries will never diminish in their
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6135-1
00:48:25.537 --> 00:48:29.581
value and all batteries big and small
like the big old tractor ones and the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6135-2
00:48:29.581 --> 00:48:33.466
little ones that are super hard to remove.
They're all gonna have value.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6147-0
00:48:34.196 --> 00:48:37.076
So I would love to see us have a
stewardship program for all.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6158-0
00:48:38.586 --> 00:48:41.580
And yeah,
each battery has its own little unique
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6158-1
00:48:41.580 --> 00:48:41.946
story.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6179-0
00:48:42.146 --> 00:48:47.994
But I don't see dismissing some battery
from stewardship as unless I'm misreading
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6179-1
00:48:47.994 --> 00:48:49.706
or misunderstanding. OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6201-0
00:48:52.386 --> 00:48:58.063
Could I ask what batteries you would see
is like I think for example like like.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6201-1
00:48:58.063 --> 00:49:00.546
Well so I'll throw out for example.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6215-0
00:49:03.226 --> 00:49:08.946
Currently V batteries is is what it means,
something that we worthwhile.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6235-0
00:49:08.946 --> 00:49:12.880
Would that be more appropriate to have a
program that's for?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6235-1
00:49:12.880 --> 00:49:17.910
That's dealerships are part of as opposed
to something that's a state oversaw
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6235-2
00:49:17.910 --> 00:49:18.426
program?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6242-0
00:49:19.626 --> 00:49:22.666
So that's this program that's in in this
type of program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6248-0
00:49:23.856 --> 00:49:27.256
I've got mark. So yeah, so Mark.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6251-0
00:49:28.666 --> 00:49:29.266
You're up.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6259-0
00:49:31.946 --> 00:49:33.106
Mark Draper. Sorry.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6268-0
00:49:32.946 --> 00:49:34.866
Oh, Mark Draper. OK, my apologies.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6275-0
00:49:33.236 --> 00:49:35.876
Well,
there's a lot of marks on this call I
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6275-1
00:49:35.876 --> 00:49:36.356
noticed.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6282-0
00:49:36.386 --> 00:49:37.786
We're we're talking about EV batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6277-0
00:49:36.496 --> 00:49:36.816
Yeah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6289-0
00:49:37.786 --> 00:49:39.426
So that's why I thought it was me.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6292-0
00:49:38.846 --> 00:49:39.246
Yeah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6291-0
00:49:39.176 --> 00:49:39.376
Hello.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6293-0
00:49:39.466 --> 00:49:39.826
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6299-0
00:49:41.096 --> 00:49:42.336
No. Yep. Thank you, Brian.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6305-0
00:49:42.336 --> 00:49:43.456
I'm mark Draper.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6311-0
00:49:43.456 --> 00:49:45.336
I'm with Aroostic waste solutions.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6358-0
00:49:45.616 --> 00:49:52.101
Run municipal solid waste landfill and A
and a transfer station a recycling center.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6358-1
00:49:52.101 --> 00:49:55.807
I mean,
obviously I think what has brought this
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6358-2
00:49:55.807 --> 00:50:00.054
issue to the forefront has been lithium
ion batteries,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6358-3
00:50:00.054 --> 00:50:05.921
particularly from our standpoint.
Just anecdotally last Week 2 fires in the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6358-4
00:50:05.921 --> 00:50:06.616
landfill.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6361-0
00:50:07.736 --> 00:50:08.576
One of which?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6375-0
00:50:09.166 --> 00:50:12.406
Determine specifically from a lithium ion
battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6382-0
00:50:12.406 --> 00:50:15.886
The other one we were never able to
determine the cause of, but.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6399-0
00:50:18.056 --> 00:50:21.357
And my only comment on that was and
listening to some of the other
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6399-1
00:50:21.357 --> 00:50:22.736
conversations I've heard is.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6435-0
00:50:24.456 --> 00:50:27.729
You know,
I think from the standpoint that we can
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6435-1
00:50:27.729 --> 00:50:33.096
implement or when I say we the state can
implement a program that gets as many of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6435-2
00:50:33.096 --> 00:50:38.398
these batteries out of the waste stream
as quickly as possible is what the least
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6435-3
00:50:38.398 --> 00:50:41.016
the first kind of the first goal around.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6464-0
00:50:41.086 --> 00:50:45.223
On the 1st priority should be.
I hate the thought of we're going to hold
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6464-1
00:50:45.223 --> 00:50:49.303
up an entire program for moving forward
because we have some, you know,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6464-2
00:50:49.303 --> 00:50:50.606
the embedded batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6469-0
00:50:50.606 --> 00:50:52.686
Obviously that's a problem.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6470-0
00:50:53.206 --> 00:50:55.726
EV batteries, obviously an issue.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6505-0
00:50:57.176 --> 00:50:59.884
But we may have to work on some of those.
You know,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6505-1
00:50:59.884 --> 00:51:04.205
a problem for a later day type of thing.
But I guess my suggestion would be to try
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6505-2
00:51:04.205 --> 00:51:08.319
to come up with a program that gets as
many of these lithium ion batteries out
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6505-3
00:51:08.319 --> 00:51:09.256
of the waste stre.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6509-0
00:51:09.256 --> 00:51:10.216
As quickly as possible.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6531-0
00:51:10.646 --> 00:51:16.726
And you know and and keep working on the
others obviously, but you know,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6531-1
00:51:16.726 --> 00:51:20.806
I'm again speaking from my sector of this
issue.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6537-0
00:51:22.216 --> 00:51:24.056
Literally, the trash is full of batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6564-0
00:51:25.856 --> 00:51:29.458
While while just again anecdotally,
of course these fires never happened
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6564-1
00:51:29.458 --> 00:51:32.073
during the day,
one of them were out in the dark and
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6564-2
00:51:32.073 --> 00:51:34.096
literally while we're fighting this fire.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6581-0
00:51:35.736 --> 00:51:38.993
One of the firefighters points to a
flashing light in the trash in a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6581-1
00:51:38.993 --> 00:51:40.456
different part of the landfill.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6600-0
00:51:40.766 --> 00:51:45.566
And I walked over and there's a kids toy
flashing away with batteries in it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6615-0
00:51:45.606 --> 00:51:50.035
So our joke then was, well,
there's a next fire. We were gonna have.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6615-1
00:51:50.035 --> 00:51:51.126
So, so I'll just.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6618-0
00:51:51.126 --> 00:51:51.966
I'll leave it at that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6638-0
00:51:51.966 --> 00:51:55.054
That's I think there is from least my
perspective,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6638-1
00:51:55.054 --> 00:51:58.566
A level of urgency to move as quickly as
we can on these.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6639-0
00:51:58.726 --> 00:51:59.686
So appreciate that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6641-0
00:51:59.686 --> 00:52:00.206
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6642-0
00:52:00.726 --> 00:52:01.726
Sure. Thanks mark.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6644-0
00:52:12.446 --> 00:52:13.046
Jennifer.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6678-0
00:52:17.426 --> 00:52:25.040
So my two cents is both a consumer and as
a state regulator. If I had to pick one,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6678-1
00:52:25.040 --> 00:52:31.186
it it would be lithium ion batteries,
specifically vaping devices.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6689-0
00:52:32.656 --> 00:52:37.696
That is maybe #1 on our problem list
right now.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6702-0
00:52:39.416 --> 00:52:44.776
As far as not having any good solutions
as far as our management program goes.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6727-0
00:52:46.326 --> 00:52:51.406
I would love to see some extended
producer responsibility for that,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6727-1
00:52:51.406 --> 00:52:56.336
and I would also like to see
manufacturers in general moving back
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6727-2
00:52:56.336 --> 00:52:58.726
toward removable battery design.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6732-0
00:53:00.096 --> 00:53:01.376
Rather than embedded batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6734-0
00:53:08.836 --> 00:53:08.996
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6736-0
00:53:11.936 --> 00:53:12.856
Mark Miller.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6762-0
00:53:14.066 --> 00:53:16.725
Yes,
coming back to the the vehicle battery
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6762-1
00:53:16.725 --> 00:53:19.928
discussion,
the heavy truck market's a bit different
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6762-2
00:53:19.928 --> 00:53:24.944
than than the light duty market for sure.
We do have customers that have their own
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6762-3
00:53:24.944 --> 00:53:25.306
shops.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6791-0
00:53:26.776 --> 00:53:30.506
And if those customers were to get
certified through us to work on our
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6791-1
00:53:30.506 --> 00:53:33.343
electric vehicles,
we would have no problem with them
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6791-2
00:53:33.343 --> 00:53:34.656
removing those batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6799-0
00:53:34.856 --> 00:53:39.176
So I not necessarily like to see that
have to go through a dealership.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6811-0
00:53:40.896 --> 00:53:44.336
If the customer calls us directly and and
we arrange for.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6822-0
00:53:44.606 --> 00:53:48.326
Shipment of that battery to our recycler
or refurbisher.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6828-0
00:53:50.096 --> 00:53:52.216
It's a possibility of of what?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6836-0
00:53:52.216 --> 00:53:55.456
Our battery management plan will look
like in the future.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6855-0
00:53:57.376 --> 00:54:00.075
So again,
I'd like to not see it be specific to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6855-1
00:54:00.075 --> 00:54:03.616
requiring that these batteries go back
through the dealership.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6859-0
00:54:08.216 --> 00:54:10.416
All right. That's one in the room.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6870-0
00:54:12.316 --> 00:54:16.356
Logan. Anthony Scott,
I have a question for Jennifer.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6884-0
00:54:16.436 --> 00:54:19.996
She seems pretty in tune with the
hazardous waste material.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6891-0
00:54:20.316 --> 00:54:23.556
Just wondering if she has any like types
of solutions.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6897-0
00:54:23.596 --> 00:54:26.996
She seems to zone in on vapes,
specifically.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6915-0
00:54:28.856 --> 00:54:33.164
Is there a way to like incinerate these
products that contain the nicotine in a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6915-1
00:54:33.164 --> 00:54:34.456
device within the state?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6917-0
00:54:36.136 --> 00:54:36.856
No.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6929-0
00:54:39.526 --> 00:54:43.366
We don't have anywhere that I can think
of in the state that can handle these.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6942-0
00:54:43.486 --> 00:54:48.326
We're looking at out West down South and
we are again,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6942-1
00:54:48.326 --> 00:54:50.966
we're running into the issues.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6957-0
00:54:52.376 --> 00:54:55.656
Of if they're going to take the batteries,
they don't want to deal with the nicotine.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6971-0
00:54:57.186 --> 00:55:00.466
As the waste facilities that don't want
to take them.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6975-0
00:54:59.036 --> 00:55:00.156
That's the waste facility.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6984-0
00:55:00.156 --> 00:55:04.196
So if if it's, if you can't.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6986-0
00:55:02.666 --> 00:55:03.506
Can you nod him?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/6987-0
00:55:04.196 --> 00:55:06.036
If you can't take the vape apart.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7023-0
00:55:07.456 --> 00:55:12.406
I don't know of any universal waste
recycling facility that wants to take
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7023-1
00:55:12.406 --> 00:55:17.690
them because they don't want to receive
the acute hazardous waste and they may
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7023-2
00:55:17.690 --> 00:55:19.696
not be licensed for it either.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7042-0
00:55:19.976 --> 00:55:23.306
You know,
I I don't know how familiar you are with
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7042-1
00:55:23.306 --> 00:55:26.896
management method codes on a hazardous
waste manifest.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7046-0
00:55:28.656 --> 00:55:29.536
Receiving facilities.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7082-0
00:55:30.126 --> 00:55:36.303
Are granted authorization to deal with
hazardous waste using certain treatment
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7082-1
00:55:36.303 --> 00:55:40.135
methods,
and if that facility isn't licensed for
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7082-2
00:55:40.135 --> 00:55:45.686
that particular management method code,
they cannot accept that waste.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7105-0
00:55:46.286 --> 00:55:50.893
So if that universal waste that battery
recycling facility is not also licensed
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7105-1
00:55:50.893 --> 00:55:54.981
to accept nicotine and treat it,
they're not going to want to take the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7105-2
00:55:54.981 --> 00:55:55.326
vapes.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7108-0
00:55:56.516 --> 00:55:58.036
Same thing with any cannabis.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7135-0
00:56:01.086 --> 00:56:06.670
For the real problem lies in the devices
that are embedded and can't be separated
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7135-1
00:56:06.670 --> 00:56:10.006
from cannabis or nicotine.
And it's countrywide.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7152-0
00:56:07.516 --> 00:56:10.447
Right,
we need to be able to separate the waste
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7152-1
00:56:10.447 --> 00:56:15.455
streams since there are very few, if any,
facilities that are willing and able to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7152-2
00:56:15.455 --> 00:56:16.676
deal with all three.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7167-0
00:56:17.466 --> 00:56:20.688
And in the state of Maine,
you're not allowed to like,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7167-1
00:56:20.688 --> 00:56:23.266
we want to be able to incinerate them
here.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7188-0
00:56:24.716 --> 00:56:27.244
No,
you'd you'd if you're incinerating
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7188-1
00:56:27.244 --> 00:56:30.615
nicotine,
you'd have to get licensed as a hazardous
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7188-2
00:56:30.615 --> 00:56:32.236
waste receiving facility.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7190-0
00:56:40.586 --> 00:56:41.106
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7195-0
00:56:42.536 --> 00:56:44.616
Well, Henryk was first. Henrik first,
yeah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7199-0
00:56:48.786 --> 00:56:50.026
Yeah. Hi. So.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7221-0
00:56:52.016 --> 00:56:58.109
Representing the Motorcycle Industry
Council and I just want to highlight,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7221-1
00:56:58.109 --> 00:57:02.496
as Mark Miller comment about the have
heavy industry.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7231-0
00:57:05.096 --> 00:57:09.056
The motorcycle industry and a motor
sports also.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7240-0
00:57:10.696 --> 00:57:15.096
It's very different than the the auto
industry.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7249-0
00:57:17.686 --> 00:57:21.766
The the clean energy is at really early
stage.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7279-0
00:57:24.656 --> 00:57:28.472
Motorcycles, Motor Sports Z bikes.
As you know,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7279-1
00:57:28.472 --> 00:57:33.879
they're currently not getting,
they're not eligible for getting any
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7279-2
00:57:33.879 --> 00:57:37.456
scientific,
any subsidies or tax incentives.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7288-0
00:57:38.976 --> 00:57:43.096
So if they are included in any EPR.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7292-0
00:57:44.896 --> 00:57:45.776
Program right now.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7302-0
00:57:47.856 --> 00:57:51.976
This will probably just 'cause most of
these companies to just.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7312-0
00:57:54.606 --> 00:58:00.406
Decide to leave the US or or or or,
you know close close business.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7322-0
00:58:01.936 --> 00:58:04.376
The volumes, especially for motorcycles.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7327-0
00:58:06.856 --> 00:58:08.096
And and motor sports.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7367-0
00:58:09.936 --> 00:58:14.497
EVs are extremely low,
so and and most of several of the these
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7367-1
00:58:14.497 --> 00:58:18.624
manufacturers,
they have their own stewardship programs.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7367-2
00:58:18.624 --> 00:58:22.389
They they're coming from Europe,
from other places,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7367-3
00:58:22.389 --> 00:58:24.416
but the burden of having to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7411-0
00:58:25.006 --> 00:58:30.572
You follow a specific programs with
specific reports and and maybe different
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7411-1
00:58:30.572 --> 00:58:34.331
states having different falling different
programs.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7411-2
00:58:34.331 --> 00:58:39.825
At this time I think it will be more
counter productive thinking about like
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7411-3
00:58:39.825 --> 00:58:43.006
you know long term to promote clean
energy.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7414-0
00:58:44.496 --> 00:58:44.656
Then.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7420-0
00:58:46.576 --> 00:58:48.736
If they're included in this purse,
so we we are.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7422-0
00:58:50.376 --> 00:58:50.856
Purging.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7430-0
00:58:52.616 --> 00:58:55.016
This group to at this time.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7453-0
00:58:56.206 --> 00:59:02.902
To exclude motorcycles and and and and
motor sports vehicles and and hopefully
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7453-1
00:59:02.902 --> 00:59:08.326
you know at a later time when when the
industry is more stable.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7456-0
00:59:09.776 --> 00:59:10.416
Then come back to that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7468-0
00:59:12.096 --> 00:59:15.176
So this is more like thinking long term
in in, in.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7474-0
00:59:17.816 --> 00:59:20.456
Clean mobility and and the environment.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7477-0
00:59:25.266 --> 00:59:25.826
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7480-0
00:59:25.906 --> 00:59:27.306
Alright, thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7481-0
00:59:27.586 --> 00:59:28.466
Back to the room.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7484-0
00:59:29.936 --> 00:59:31.536
It says hang up goes first. Yep.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7486-0
00:59:34.876 --> 00:59:36.116
Good. What?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7500-0
00:59:38.016 --> 00:59:41.856
I want to see what other things would
this three hour meeting, right?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7503-0
00:59:41.856 --> 00:59:43.376
We're getting started. Let's go.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7508-0
00:59:43.376 --> 00:59:45.696
OK, Mark, Mark Miller.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7511-0
00:59:46.286 --> 00:59:46.886
Yeah. Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7521-0
00:59:46.886 --> 00:59:50.745
I'd just like to piggyback something on
that. Enrique just mentioned, you know,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7521-1
00:59:50.745 --> 00:59:51.806
with with heavy truck.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7529-0
00:59:53.296 --> 00:59:55.336
This is a very early stage market.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7546-0
00:59:55.336 --> 00:59:59.746
It's still in its infancy for electric
vehicles, so there are very few out there.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7546-1
00:59:59.746 --> 01:00:03.456
When you look at the the total number of
vehicles in in circulation.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7555-0
01:00:05.096 --> 01:00:07.216
And the volumes sales volumes are very
low.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7566-0
01:00:07.656 --> 01:00:11.375
The cost parity is not there yet between
an electric vehicle and a diesel,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7566-1
01:00:11.375 --> 01:00:12.416
even with incentives.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7573-0
01:00:12.416 --> 01:00:15.576
So the numbers of these batteries that
are in circulation.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7596-0
01:00:15.886 --> 01:00:20.382
Or will be in circulation within the next
you know 5 to 10 years is well,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7596-1
01:00:20.382 --> 01:00:25.364
I'll say five years is is fairly low and
I think that's something good to keep in
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7596-2
01:00:25.364 --> 01:00:28.766
mind with respect to the vehicle
batteries, that's all.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7598-0
01:00:28.766 --> 01:00:29.486
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7603-0
01:00:31.856 --> 01:00:32.896
Thank you, mark.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7628-0
01:00:33.056 --> 01:00:39.308
I I will just kind of throw out a general
question because like Maine's law is
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7628-1
01:00:39.308 --> 01:00:44.056
specific to rechargeable batteries.
I am assuming there is.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7640-0
01:00:46.596 --> 01:00:52.516
A desire to expand that to what we would
refer to as primary batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7642-0
01:00:54.176 --> 01:00:54.216
I.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7647-0
01:00:55.326 --> 01:00:57.006
The the one use batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7654-0
01:00:58.456 --> 01:01:00.936
Does anybody have any comments about?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7659-0
01:01:05.776 --> 01:01:08.296
Including primary batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7667-0
01:01:10.056 --> 01:01:13.496
To Maine's program,
since they're no longer part of it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7671-0
01:01:16.836 --> 01:01:18.796
Not no longer,
but since they are not part of it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7676-0
01:01:20.376 --> 01:01:21.056
Thank you, mark.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7679-0
01:01:21.216 --> 01:01:25.216
Yeah. Owen and the mark question.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7681-0
01:01:27.176 --> 01:01:27.256
On.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7696-0
01:01:28.496 --> 01:01:32.046
So when I think about what you're
describing with the primary battery,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7696-1
01:01:32.046 --> 01:01:32.696
one use only.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7716-0
01:01:33.176 --> 01:01:40.174
That to me sounds or feels more like an
embedded or integrated battery that was
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7716-1
01:01:40.174 --> 01:01:42.536
not designed to be removed.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7732-0
01:01:42.976 --> 01:01:48.093
And the reason that I say that is
typically these rechargeable batteries
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7732-1
01:01:48.093 --> 01:01:50.616
that are used in a consumer product.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7741-0
01:01:52.216 --> 01:01:56.176
They they're buying hundreds if not
thousands of batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7771-0
01:01:56.916 --> 01:02:01.347
And they're buying them from the same
manufacturer that then packages
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7771-1
01:02:01.347 --> 01:02:06.410
themselves them in the store as just a
recycle battery so that the batteries on
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7771-2
01:02:06.410 --> 01:02:07.676
the inside of these.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7785-0
01:02:09.136 --> 01:02:11.297
Where we're debating the integrated
aspect of it,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7785-1
01:02:11.297 --> 01:02:12.896
it seems like rechargeable batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7795-0
01:02:14.696 --> 01:02:17.816
With much less fit,
the definition of an integrated battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7811-0
01:02:17.816 --> 01:02:23.596
But that's just I'm wondering if you view
the same primary would be might not
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7811-1
01:02:23.596 --> 01:02:24.856
easily removable.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7813-0
01:02:24.856 --> 01:02:26.776
No, no, I'm not talking about.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7854-0
01:02:27.346 --> 01:02:34.360
We I'm talking about your your basic D's.
Your C's, your AAA, those batteries,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7854-1
01:02:34.360 --> 01:02:41.640
the batteries you buy as a consumer to
put into your device, your remote control,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7854-2
01:02:41.640 --> 01:02:46.523
your remote control,
your that those batteries are not
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7854-3
01:02:46.523 --> 01:02:49.186
currently part of the program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7863-0
01:02:49.186 --> 01:02:52.586
That's, that's and that's the question is,
is.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7870-0
01:02:53.296 --> 01:02:56.416
Is there input into yes yes.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7877-0
01:02:56.846 --> 01:03:00.126
Should we include primary batteries?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7891-0
01:03:00.126 --> 01:03:04.067
For reference,
our battery laws came out in 91,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7891-1
01:03:04.067 --> 01:03:06.366
so please keep that in mind.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7898-0
01:03:06.606 --> 01:03:08.366
Right. Could I?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7907-0
01:03:08.366 --> 01:03:12.206
Could we so nickel,
cadmium and is it SSDL?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7911-0
01:03:12.206 --> 01:03:13.206
Is that the acronym?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7917-0
01:03:13.206 --> 01:03:15.086
Those are the batteries that are
currently covered.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7922-0
01:03:15.406 --> 01:03:17.006
What are those batteries?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7926-0
01:03:17.206 --> 01:03:18.366
I just assumed.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7936-0
01:03:18.966 --> 01:03:22.486
I guess I never really thought about it,
but they are the old.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7951-0
01:03:22.486 --> 01:03:29.938
They are the old school rechargeable for
the old tools that just kinda shows how
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7951-1
01:03:29.938 --> 01:03:31.686
old our our law is.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7971-0
01:03:31.966 --> 01:03:38.768
And so and like for example like so the
collection system that's currently in
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/7971-1
01:03:38.768 --> 01:03:41.646
place for rechargeable batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8017-0
01:03:43.096 --> 01:03:48.788
A lot of primary batteries get put into
those boxes because the consumer doesn't
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8017-1
01:03:48.788 --> 01:03:53.214
know or doesn't want to know that it's
only for rechargeables,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8017-2
01:03:53.214 --> 01:03:58.906
and then they they they join the system
and what's kind of referred to as like a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8017-3
01:03:58.906 --> 01:04:01.576
free rider because the current system.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8021-0
01:04:02.086 --> 01:04:03.766
Is paid for by.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8033-0
01:04:05.336 --> 01:04:10.286
Rechargeable producers.
And so when there's batteries that get
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8033-1
01:04:10.286 --> 01:04:11.936
into the system that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8040-0
01:04:13.536 --> 01:04:15.256
Aren't being from a producer.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8048-0
01:04:15.416 --> 01:04:18.416
They they they call to recycle doesn't
pull them.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8063-0
01:04:19.376 --> 01:04:24.153
They still have to process them so they
they get into the system and are treated
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8063-1
01:04:24.153 --> 01:04:25.096
as a free rider.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8069-0
01:04:25.616 --> 01:04:28.456
So I would definitely point people to the.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8075-0
01:04:30.136 --> 01:04:31.736
This year's product Stewardship report
because.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8100-0
01:04:32.006 --> 01:04:35.889
There was a pretty good write up about
that situation,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8100-1
01:04:35.889 --> 01:04:41.397
so and so now we're gonna move to the
Internet world and I'll start with Mark
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8100-2
01:04:41.397 --> 01:04:42.526
and then Amanda.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8116-0
01:04:44.926 --> 01:04:47.086
Yeah.
And maybe this is probably a mixture of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8116-1
01:04:47.086 --> 01:04:48.166
questions and comments.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8127-0
01:04:48.926 --> 01:04:52.582
So typically, yeah,
maybe we shouldn't use the word primary
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8127-1
01:04:52.582 --> 01:04:52.886
here.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8173-0
01:04:52.886 --> 01:04:56.992
Primary normally in some discussions
means a non rechargeable battery,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8173-1
01:04:56.992 --> 01:05:00.809
so I'll I'll start saying non
rechargeable as opposed to primary.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8173-2
01:05:00.809 --> 01:05:04.452
So I can just speak.
I can speak to what the model that I that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8154-0
01:05:01.736 --> 01:05:02.616
512.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8173-3
01:05:04.452 --> 01:05:07.286
I mentioned and what the other states
have done.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8193-0
01:05:08.856 --> 01:05:13.114
The the model bill and then the laws that
have been passed, they cover all types,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8193-1
01:05:13.114 --> 01:05:14.256
essentially all types.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8198-0
01:05:14.256 --> 01:05:15.776
Like I said, there are some exemptions.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8224-0
01:05:17.256 --> 01:05:21.687
So they would cover your AA's,
your you know your lithium ion type.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8224-1
01:05:21.687 --> 01:05:26.313
So it would cover all types non
rechargeable and rechargeable that are
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8224-2
01:05:26.313 --> 01:05:27.616
considered portable.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8249-0
01:05:29.096 --> 01:05:33.031
And then it, but it as I mentioned,
it does exclude the embedded batteries
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8249-1
01:05:33.031 --> 01:05:36.336
and again embedded means they're not
easily removable without.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8263-0
01:05:37.976 --> 01:05:40.002
You know,
they're not intended to be removed from
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8263-1
01:05:40.002 --> 01:05:41.096
the device by the consumer.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8270-0
01:05:46.946 --> 01:05:48.186
That's a big difference.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8277-0
01:05:48.666 --> 01:05:53.146
Easily removable, intended to be removed,
or very different things.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8278-0
01:05:53.746 --> 01:05:54.186
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8282-0
01:05:54.826 --> 01:05:56.546
Thank you, mark. Amanda.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8286-0
01:05:59.656 --> 01:06:01.176
Hi, good afternoon everybody.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8287-0
01:06:01.176 --> 01:06:01.936
Can you hear me?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8293-0
01:06:02.416 --> 01:06:03.256
Yes.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8346-0
01:06:03.576 --> 01:06:06.300
Great.
I'm Amanda Campbell from The Maine
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8346-1
01:06:06.300 --> 01:06:10.061
Municipal Association,
and I'm just my thoughts along the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8346-2
01:06:10.061 --> 01:06:14.924
primary batteries would be because we
already have a system to collect the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8346-3
01:06:14.924 --> 01:06:20.176
rechargeable ones at a transfer stations
through the municipal collection sites.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8346-4
01:06:20.176 --> 01:06:24.456
And since clearly people are already
bringing the batteries that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8353-0
01:06:24.456 --> 01:06:27.376
Don't qualify to those collection sites
as well.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8395-0
01:06:28.016 --> 01:06:33.750
It seems like a natural progression that
you could add that in and based on the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8395-1
01:06:33.750 --> 01:06:39.556
little chart in the background document
in the the eight years that you have for
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8395-2
01:06:39.556 --> 01:06:44.286
data here, that was just over 63,
000 primary batteries that were
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8395-3
01:06:44.286 --> 01:06:47.296
accidentally recycled. And so think about.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8412-0
01:06:47.296 --> 01:06:50.399
How many that could be if people actually
knew that they were doing taking the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8412-1
01:06:50.399 --> 01:06:51.656
right things to the right place?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8422-0
01:06:52.776 --> 01:06:56.536
MY1 caveat to that, of course,
is because this is municipal operations.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8442-0
01:06:57.926 --> 01:07:03.446
That additional recycling effort cannot
be paid for by the taxpayers.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8469-0
01:07:03.486 --> 01:07:07.294
So you know, yes,
transfer stations and municipal officials
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8469-1
01:07:07.294 --> 01:07:11.418
want to do their part,
but it it just can't be funded, you know,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8469-2
01:07:11.418 --> 01:07:13.766
on the on the backs of the taxpayers.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8488-0
01:07:16.486 --> 01:07:20.095
For for any of these programs that we're
talking about, you know,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8488-1
01:07:20.095 --> 01:07:24.086
again we want to do our part,
but not we don't want to pay for our part.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8490-0
01:07:24.086 --> 01:07:24.526
You know what I mean?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8494-0
01:07:25.246 --> 01:07:28.206
Right. OK. OK. Thanks, Amanda.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8496-0
01:07:33.326 --> 01:07:33.486
Nope.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8505-0
01:07:34.726 --> 01:07:37.646
So so how come not like a pay to play
type?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8526-0
01:07:39.136 --> 01:07:43.337
Program where you're going,
you pay an increase and then you get a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8526-1
01:07:43.337 --> 01:07:46.096
redemption or something at the end of
life.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8572-0
01:07:48.096 --> 01:07:52.289
Like all batteries across the board,
so if you go to Best Buy and you get an
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8572-1
01:07:52.289 --> 01:07:55.066
embedded laptop,
there's like a hazardous or not a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8572-2
01:07:55.066 --> 01:07:58.061
hazardous waste.
But there's like an environmental fee
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8572-3
01:07:58.061 --> 01:08:01.056
that's attached to it,
same as like any other product.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8582-0
01:08:01.456 --> 01:08:04.572
I mean,
you can kind of like set it up as kind of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8582-1
01:08:04.572 --> 01:08:04.696
a?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8610-0
01:08:05.726 --> 01:08:10.020
Retailers or whatnot could set it up as
some sort of like a sales tax.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8610-1
01:08:10.020 --> 01:08:14.132
We already are used to doing that,
you know, in the state of Maine,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8610-2
01:08:14.132 --> 01:08:16.006
but it can be certain products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8630-0
01:08:16.006 --> 01:08:21.726
You can categorize it pretty quickly in a
lot of POS systems that just run it as a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8630-1
01:08:21.726 --> 01:08:22.966
environmental fee.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8633-0
01:08:23.486 --> 01:08:25.046
So and then not even.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8647-0
01:08:25.046 --> 01:08:27.930
I mean,
you don't have to give a redemption just
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8647-1
01:08:27.930 --> 01:08:30.166
that way. If this guy over here, he's.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8656-0
01:08:30.896 --> 01:08:32.456
A connoisseur of every type of battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8657-0
01:08:32.456 --> 01:08:33.656
But he's paying.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8659-0
01:08:33.776 --> 01:08:34.656
That's what he wants to do.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8673-0
01:08:35.166 --> 01:08:39.966
He pays for it and it all down the road,
and he barely uses any battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8686-0
01:08:39.966 --> 01:08:44.650
See the rechargeable type of guide.
He only has to buy one set of batteries
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8686-1
01:08:44.650 --> 01:08:46.006
every year, sales tax.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8699-0
01:08:47.976 --> 01:08:51.187
So.
So that would be a system of a point of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8699-1
01:08:51.187 --> 01:08:53.376
sale. Yeah. Fee as opposed to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8725-0
01:08:55.576 --> 01:08:59.584
More of a producer run where the
producers kind of pay into the system
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8725-1
01:08:59.584 --> 01:09:04.042
based on what their sales are and what
what the what the retailers handle with
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8725-2
01:09:04.042 --> 01:09:04.776
the consumer.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8727-0
01:09:05.956 --> 01:09:06.836
And work it out.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8763-0
01:09:09.606 --> 01:09:13.880
Give one more still behind one of the
comments I make is that like coming from
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8763-1
01:09:13.880 --> 01:09:18.262
a more fragmented industry like the the
vape and tobacco industry and stuff that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8763-2
01:09:18.262 --> 01:09:22.482
a lot of these producers are not these
big companies that we think of when we
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8763-3
01:09:22.482 --> 01:09:23.456
think of you know.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8772-0
01:09:23.456 --> 01:09:24.326
A company that makes batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8804-0
01:09:24.326 --> 01:09:27.100
So my concern is that the enforcement
across state lines,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8804-1
01:09:27.100 --> 01:09:29.251
I understand seeing those products in
shops,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8804-2
01:09:29.251 --> 01:09:32.837
but I question if the enforcement is
going to be consistent enough whereas
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8804-3
01:09:32.837 --> 01:09:36.806
that's why I was kind of mention earlier
like there's different sales tax rate on.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8811-0
01:09:37.536 --> 01:09:39.136
These that process is already being
audited.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8839-0
01:09:39.486 --> 01:09:43.922
It's on the retailer and I as a retailer
would rather see that then see a lot of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8839-1
01:09:43.922 --> 01:09:47.646
people skirting the rules and not
actually partaking as a producer.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8858-0
01:09:47.646 --> 01:09:50.021
Like say when you go to like a big
national company like,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8858-1
01:09:50.021 --> 01:09:52.886
it's easy to regulate them and they're
going to automatically comply.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8902-0
01:09:52.886 --> 01:09:55.108
My concern is when you get into these
smaller,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8902-1
01:09:55.108 --> 01:09:58.039
fragmented industries and it's not just
the tobacco and vape,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8902-2
01:09:58.039 --> 01:10:00.733
it's just smaller industry in general,
when there's not,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8902-3
01:10:00.733 --> 01:10:03.806
it's not clear that that producer fee has
necessarily been paid.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8908-0
01:10:03.806 --> 01:10:07.246
It's not clear that they're reporting the
correct numbers coming into the state.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8940-0
01:10:07.566 --> 01:10:11.540
Whereas I've been through the sales tax
audit process and I can show you that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8940-1
01:10:11.540 --> 01:10:15.819
process is extremely robust and all those
tools are already there to make sure that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8940-2
01:10:15.819 --> 01:10:17.806
things are being categorized correctly.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8948-0
01:10:17.806 --> 01:10:19.286
And that's why I kinda mentioned that
earlier.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8951-0
01:10:19.286 --> 01:10:22.406
So just fragmented industries is a
concern to me, OK?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8959-0
01:10:27.176 --> 01:10:29.096
If we can get Katie real quick, yeah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8962-0
01:10:32.466 --> 01:10:32.906
Hi all.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8971-0
01:10:32.906 --> 01:10:36.386
Thanks. Just wanted to, well,
I have two comments.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8985-0
01:10:36.386 --> 01:10:41.635
The first is to address the comment
around like a deposit system or sales tax
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/8985-1
01:10:41.635 --> 01:10:42.106
or fee.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9029-0
01:10:43.576 --> 01:10:48.794
That has not been adopted anywhere else
for products outside of the state of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9029-1
01:10:48.794 --> 01:10:52.182
California,
and I would highly suggest that folks
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9029-2
01:10:52.182 --> 01:10:57.874
connect in with Maine retailers for their
viewpoints on how they view those kind of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9029-3
01:10:57.874 --> 01:11:01.736
fees and systems.
It has been met with heavy opposition.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9042-0
01:11:02.406 --> 01:11:06.223
Everywhere outside of the state of
California just wanted to make folks
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9042-1
01:11:06.223 --> 01:11:06.806
aware that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9059-0
01:11:08.496 --> 01:11:12.816
On the other point, I wanted to make,
I wanted to echo what Mark Draper said.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9104-0
01:11:13.136 --> 01:11:16.196
I think we can work on battery embedded
products,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9104-1
01:11:16.196 --> 01:11:20.970
but I think we need a more thoughtful
dialogue and discussion that's specific
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9104-2
01:11:20.970 --> 01:11:24.458
to battery embedded products as we've
been hearing here.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9104-3
01:11:24.458 --> 01:11:28.253
Products range from vapes to cell phones
to toys to vehicles.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9104-4
01:11:28.253 --> 01:11:30.456
We have a program in place for some.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9108-0
01:11:30.456 --> 01:11:31.616
Products like the electronics.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9115-0
01:11:32.006 --> 01:11:33.646
EPR program here, right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9161-0
01:11:33.646 --> 01:11:38.282
You can return your laptop doesn't matter
if it's an embedded battery or a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9161-1
01:11:38.282 --> 01:11:41.557
removable battery,
but not all product types will be
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9161-2
01:11:41.557 --> 01:11:46.193
compatible with the same recycling system.
So I think we need to be really
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9161-3
01:11:46.193 --> 01:11:50.828
thoughtful on exploring separate programs
for separate products where it's
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9161-4
01:11:50.828 --> 01:11:51.446
warranted.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9175-0
01:11:53.296 --> 01:11:57.776
And so I guess the point I was echoing
from Mark is you know, take the kind of.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9184-0
01:11:59.736 --> 01:12:02.736
The you know, don't hold up a program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9206-0
01:12:03.086 --> 01:12:08.428
That you could have for loose batteries
by the complexity of how to handle very
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9206-1
01:12:08.428 --> 01:12:11.966
very different product types that contain
batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9217-0
01:12:12.166 --> 01:12:16.151
OK.
So I mean just to summarize what phased
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9217-1
01:12:16.151 --> 01:12:16.966
approach?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9223-0
01:12:19.576 --> 01:12:20.096
That the what?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9252-0
01:12:20.496 --> 01:12:27.531
I'll say go go for the low hanging fruit,
so to speak with the recharge removables
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9252-1
01:12:27.531 --> 01:12:33.973
and primaries and and spend more time
talking about how to address embedded
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9252-2
01:12:33.973 --> 01:12:34.736
products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9262-0
01:12:36.606 --> 01:12:38.366
That's probably a good way to rephrase it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9268-0
01:12:38.366 --> 01:12:40.086
I don't know that I'd say low hanging
fruit.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9303-0
01:12:40.086 --> 01:12:43.942
I don't know if that loose battery
industry would necessarily agree with
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9303-1
01:12:43.942 --> 01:12:46.319
that or not, but I would say it's,
you know,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9281-0
01:12:45.326 --> 01:12:45.406
Oh.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9303-2
01:12:46.319 --> 01:12:50.386
there are systems that are in place,
laws that have been passed around loose
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9303-3
01:12:50.386 --> 01:12:52.446
batteries throughout the United States.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9338-0
01:12:52.686 --> 01:12:56.973
We're looking at discussing something
very new here with battery,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9338-1
01:12:56.973 --> 01:13:00.740
embedded products,
and so it may just be a longer kind of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9338-2
01:13:00.740 --> 01:13:05.806
runway or ramp in how to address the
complexity of battery embedded products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9356-0
01:13:06.006 --> 01:13:11.312
And the wide range of product types that
fit within you know that battery embedded
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9356-1
01:13:11.312 --> 01:13:12.526
product definition.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9359-0
01:13:14.136 --> 01:13:14.296
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9364-0
01:13:15.976 --> 01:13:16.856
Thanks, Katie. Right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9370-0
01:13:16.856 --> 01:13:17.576
Anyone in the room?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9372-0
01:13:17.656 --> 01:13:20.256
Yeah, excellent pushback on that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9375-0
01:13:20.256 --> 01:13:22.176
Just a little bit first.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9394-0
01:13:23.656 --> 01:13:26.686
If it's all being discussed now,
it's probably the right time to discuss
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9394-1
01:13:26.686 --> 01:13:26.976
it all.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9403-0
01:13:26.976 --> 01:13:29.999
Granted,
there are some products that are going to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9403-1
01:13:29.999 --> 01:13:31.896
be more complicated than others.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9427-0
01:13:33.576 --> 01:13:38.091
But also if the program becomes some
variation of a stewardship program,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9427-1
01:13:38.091 --> 01:13:43.038
there's the more products and companies
and industries probably is a better way
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9427-2
01:13:43.038 --> 01:13:43.656
to say it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9454-0
01:13:44.446 --> 01:13:49.308
That are included means it's a.
It's going to be a larger stewardship pot
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9454-1
01:13:49.308 --> 01:13:54.104
of money to pay for all of this.
That mene is dealing with and I guess I
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9454-2
01:13:54.104 --> 01:13:58.046
think if I'm thinking about it from a
political standpoint.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9495-0
01:14:00.576 --> 01:14:04.790
But you start one place and then the
opposition kind of goes on and on and on,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9495-1
01:14:04.790 --> 01:14:09.110
and it gets a lot more complicated to get
the other products that are ultimately
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9495-2
01:14:09.110 --> 01:14:11.776
should be a part of the program into the
program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9499-0
01:14:11.776 --> 01:14:14.216
So I understand the complications.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9504-0
01:14:15.486 --> 01:14:18.246
Become embedded and removable.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9514-0
01:14:19.206 --> 01:14:24.335
But it would be my.
It's my thought that it's with all that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9514-1
01:14:24.335 --> 01:14:25.446
complication.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9522-0
01:14:25.446 --> 01:14:27.806
It's probably still better to do it all
at once. Mm-hmm. OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9527-0
01:14:27.806 --> 01:14:29.206
Thank you for all of those reasons.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9552-0
01:14:29.286 --> 01:14:34.476
I mean as as as kind of mark was saying
too that I mean he and looking at that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9552-1
01:14:34.476 --> 01:14:37.366
one fire there was an embedded ready to
go.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9554-0
01:14:37.406 --> 01:14:39.446
So yeah, OK, so.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9564-0
01:14:40.296 --> 01:14:44.056
And it was kids toy, not a vape device,
so.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9601-0
01:14:45.866 --> 01:14:50.687
I kinda wanted to to to build on that and
then build on something that Brett said
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9601-1
01:14:50.687 --> 01:14:55.097
with the product stewardship for
packaging that was recently gone through.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9601-2
01:14:55.097 --> 01:14:59.860
I think it and correct me if I'm wrong
because I didn't really follow that super
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9601-3
01:14:59.860 --> 01:15:01.976
closely, but it seemed more similar.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9607-0
01:15:02.026 --> 01:15:02.386
To what?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9620-0
01:15:02.386 --> 01:15:10.146
He was describing which was this is for
packaging and then individuals had to go.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9627-0
01:15:10.856 --> 01:15:13.016
And lobby and say why they should be
exempt.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9657-0
01:15:14.526 --> 01:15:19.583
Right. So if this is for batteries,
then you will get an engender the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9657-1
01:15:19.583 --> 01:15:24.206
industry to come and try to tell you why
they should be exempt.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9688-0
01:15:24.206 --> 01:15:29.374
But I believe we should start at a place
that covers all batteries and then not
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9688-1
01:15:29.374 --> 01:15:34.477
kind of like start at a place where we're
just grabbing these segments that we
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9688-2
01:15:34.477 --> 01:15:38.740
think are low hanging fruit and maybe
they are in certain senses.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9688-3
01:15:38.740 --> 01:15:40.936
But instead of looking at the the.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9693-0
01:15:40.936 --> 01:15:43.046
Grander total. And then what?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9695-0
01:15:43.736 --> 01:15:44.056
Brett was saying.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9713-0
01:15:46.206 --> 01:15:51.346
More specifically to enforcement,
and I am kind of curious how the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9713-1
01:15:51.346 --> 01:15:55.566
stewardship programs and the style you
construct them.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9722-0
01:15:57.096 --> 01:16:00.536
Lends itself well or not for enforcement
and so.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9745-0
01:16:02.456 --> 01:16:06.327
In last session we had that product
stewardship for electronic smoking
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9745-1
01:16:06.327 --> 01:16:08.616
devices and DEP was going to enforce that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9755-0
01:16:09.176 --> 01:16:13.674
So that what was there was a high level
of confidence that you all were ready to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9755-1
01:16:13.674 --> 01:16:14.896
roll that program out.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9767-0
01:16:15.926 --> 01:16:19.846
Do the program and have the enforcement
under your purview?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9784-0
01:16:20.326 --> 01:16:23.644
So I'm just kind of curious as it relates
to this program,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9784-1
01:16:23.644 --> 01:16:27.806
what is your methodology for ensuring
that you actually have enforcement?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9822-0
01:16:27.806 --> 01:16:31.809
Because I do think it ties into the
trackability and metrics and things,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9822-1
01:16:31.809 --> 01:16:36.142
and I assume that you've spent some time
putting that enforcement arm together
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9822-2
01:16:36.142 --> 01:16:40.364
because, like, without enforcement,
all of this is kind of pointless, right?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9822-3
01:16:40.364 --> 01:16:41.406
Right. Well, I see.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9827-0
01:16:41.406 --> 01:16:44.246
I mean enforcement for for a lot of fire
stewardship products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9832-0
01:16:45.016 --> 01:16:46.216
Is that is that?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9848-0
01:16:46.646 --> 01:16:52.451
The enforcement is #1 issue is if the
product is not participating then it's
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9848-1
01:16:52.451 --> 01:16:54.486
can't be sold in the state.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9850-0
01:16:54.726 --> 01:16:58.366
So again paint packaging.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9858-0
01:17:00.296 --> 01:17:05.407
You know,
there's a certain there's a requirement
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9858-1
01:17:05.407 --> 01:17:05.816
for.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9872-0
01:17:07.616 --> 01:17:14.554
For covered electronic devices to report
their sales and be part of the program,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9872-1
01:17:14.554 --> 01:17:16.096
and if they don't.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9880-0
01:17:16.366 --> 01:17:18.606
Then they're on a do not sell list.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9894-0
01:17:19.526 --> 01:17:26.992
So that's and then it's just up to the
department to have the staff to do that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9894-1
01:17:26.992 --> 01:17:28.126
enforcement.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9899-0
01:17:31.286 --> 01:17:32.926
Let's hear from Katie real quick.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9902-0
01:17:32.926 --> 01:17:33.846
Yeah. OK, Katie.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9906-0
01:17:35.426 --> 01:17:36.426
Yeah. Thanks.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9921-0
01:17:36.746 --> 01:17:40.946
I did just wanna respectfully push back a
little bit on the last two comments.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9937-0
01:17:41.026 --> 01:17:46.841
So we have a long history of electronic
product EPR here in the US,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9937-1
01:17:46.841 --> 01:17:48.466
including in Maine.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9970-0
01:17:48.826 --> 01:17:51.281
Again,
I just want to stress that loose
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9970-1
01:17:51.281 --> 01:17:55.885
batteries are a very different collection
system than collecting products,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9970-2
01:17:55.885 --> 01:17:59.506
so we don't want to lump in products with
a loose battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9984-0
01:18:00.296 --> 01:18:03.501
Collection system and program and then
again on products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9984-1
01:18:03.501 --> 01:18:05.656
Different products will have different.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9998-0
01:18:06.046 --> 01:18:08.522
Different needs,
I think as a first step we need to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/9998-1
01:18:08.522 --> 01:18:10.046
determine the scope of products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10006-0
01:18:10.046 --> 01:18:13.406
What all is captured in battery embedded
products?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10034-0
01:18:13.406 --> 01:18:18.740
Then we need to confirm what type of
recycling systems either exist for those
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10034-1
01:18:18.740 --> 01:18:23.526
products and or need to be developed and
built up for those products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10046-0
01:18:23.566 --> 01:18:28.766
We can't just lump all products into one
system getting a battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10064-0
01:18:28.766 --> 01:18:32.941
A battery that may be embedded in a
vehicle is very different than recovering
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10064-1
01:18:32.941 --> 01:18:36.046
a battery from a laptop that has an
existing electronics.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10075-0
01:18:36.166 --> 01:18:39.486
Cycling system active here in the United
States.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10076-0
01:18:39.486 --> 01:18:40.246
So I just.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10094-0
01:18:40.366 --> 01:18:46.156
I really want to stress that that a above
all approach for all products is probably
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10094-1
01:18:46.156 --> 01:18:48.086
not the path that should be.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10097-0
01:18:48.086 --> 01:18:49.486
We should be looking at going down.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10099-0
01:18:53.336 --> 01:18:53.496
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10101-0
01:18:53.736 --> 01:18:54.336
We have the room.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10111-0
01:18:56.136 --> 01:18:57.976
Thanks for your comments, Katie.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10146-0
01:18:58.736 --> 01:19:02.921
I I'm agreeing with you that you know,
I think it's gonna be difficult to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10146-1
01:19:02.921 --> 01:19:07.332
encompass one huge like it sounds good,
but you're gonna have a lot of people
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10146-2
01:19:07.332 --> 01:19:10.386
lobbying against why their products
should be exempt,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10146-3
01:19:10.386 --> 01:19:11.856
just like the packing law.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10168-0
01:19:11.976 --> 01:19:15.396
You're gonna have some industries that
are gonna get wiped out like Brian's
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10168-1
01:19:15.396 --> 01:19:18.096
saying here, like, oh,
it's a prohibition on that products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10173-0
01:19:18.096 --> 01:19:20.736
Well, why do you wanna prohibit profit?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10182-0
01:19:21.616 --> 01:19:24.696
Products as opposed to like figuring out
a way where we're here sitting.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10195-0
01:19:24.846 --> 01:19:29.246
At the table trying to figure out a way
to be able to recycle these products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10205-0
01:19:30.776 --> 01:19:31.816
I think that's the way to do it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10236-0
01:19:31.816 --> 01:19:36.067
I mean we we can now, you know,
Jennifer made it clear that obviously
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10236-1
01:19:36.067 --> 01:19:40.803
like the vapes are like one problem that
the state needs to figure out how to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10236-2
01:19:40.803 --> 01:19:45.296
create a solution for and they don't
really fall into any other category.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10258-0
01:19:45.296 --> 01:19:49.418
So it's a separate discussion really on
how we can get rid of those,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10258-1
01:19:49.418 --> 01:19:54.376
whether that's like a retailer assisted
program or you know it's like a different.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10273-0
01:19:54.566 --> 01:19:57.749
Conversation and these other batteries
that you're talking about because they're
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10273-1
01:19:57.749 --> 01:19:59.006
not gonna be in the same wastre.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10275-0
01:20:00.616 --> 01:20:00.656
F.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10299-0
01:20:00.656 --> 01:20:05.824
If I may interject one thing,
one of our biggest issues when it comes
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10299-1
01:20:05.824 --> 01:20:11.878
to figuring out how we're going to handle
this product stewardship program in the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10299-2
01:20:11.878 --> 01:20:12.616
future is.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10308-0
01:20:14.256 --> 01:20:16.576
Really comes down to who's going to pay
for it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10330-0
01:20:16.576 --> 01:20:20.574
Is it going to come down to the
manufacturer or is it going to come down
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10330-1
01:20:20.574 --> 01:20:23.969
to basically the consumer?
So This is why we are having these
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10330-2
01:20:23.969 --> 01:20:24.736
conversations.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10345-0
01:20:25.046 --> 01:20:29.570
To try and figure out what even kind of
product stewardship program we want to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10345-1
01:20:29.570 --> 01:20:30.486
create for this.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10350-0
01:20:30.486 --> 01:20:32.326
Can that be different for different
industries?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10355-0
01:20:34.296 --> 01:20:35.456
It would be tricky.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10365-0
01:20:36.096 --> 01:20:38.496
Yeah, I mean, I mean,
why I don't see why not.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10387-0
01:20:38.616 --> 01:20:43.458
We have VP Rs on the books for that would
be the issue of and how many eprs per
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10387-1
01:20:43.458 --> 01:20:45.576
batteries are we already going for?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10402-0
01:20:45.576 --> 01:20:50.496
We already have an issue where let's go
back to our vaping pens if that is.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10406-0
01:20:50.496 --> 01:20:52.376
Is that considered an embedded battery?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10413-0
01:20:52.376 --> 01:20:54.536
Is that considered just a primary battery?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10433-0
01:20:54.846 --> 01:21:00.445
Is that going into electronics so we can
divide as much as we can,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10433-1
01:21:00.445 --> 01:21:03.286
but it can get exceedingly tricky.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10437-0
01:21:03.316 --> 01:21:05.556
Let's hear from Katie real quick.
Then we'll come back to the room.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10445-0
01:21:07.056 --> 01:21:08.896
Yeah, but I I understand.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10460-0
01:21:08.896 --> 01:21:12.645
You know,
we maybe don't want 100 different
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10460-1
01:21:12.645 --> 01:21:15.456
producer responsibility programs.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10469-0
01:21:15.496 --> 01:21:17.176
But again, I think it's going back.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10477-0
01:21:17.176 --> 01:21:21.096
We've had industry specific EPR across
the board.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10480-0
01:21:21.096 --> 01:21:21.856
There's one for paint.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10486-0
01:21:21.856 --> 01:21:22.856
There's one for mattresses.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10499-0
01:21:22.856 --> 01:21:27.456
There's one for electronics,
and again I would strongly push back.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10522-0
01:21:27.456 --> 01:21:31.892
Vapes are not an electronic device in the
sense of being compatible with the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10522-1
01:21:31.892 --> 01:21:36.155
recycling stream for electronics.
So I think we need to view this through
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10522-2
01:21:36.155 --> 01:21:36.846
the lens of.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10573-0
01:21:37.076 --> 01:21:42.178
Is what is the downstream recycling
options that are compatible for the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10573-1
01:21:42.178 --> 01:21:47.421
products that are included in that
program and making sure we're building
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10573-2
01:21:47.421 --> 01:21:51.318
something holistically.
It's not just who pays for it,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10573-3
01:21:51.318 --> 01:21:54.435
although that is obviously a big
component,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10573-4
01:21:54.435 --> 01:21:57.836
but it's how you build a system that is
effect.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10585-0
01:21:58.036 --> 01:22:01.570
And efficient.
And if we have an above all approach,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10585-1
01:22:01.570 --> 01:22:03.236
we lose that opportunity.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10596-0
01:22:03.806 --> 01:22:05.957
For a system to be effective and
efficient,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10596-1
01:22:05.957 --> 01:22:08.206
that if we're talking about EPR producers
or.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10602-0
01:22:08.796 --> 01:22:10.916
Obviously, financially, on the hook for.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10606-0
01:22:14.806 --> 01:22:15.126
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10614-0
01:22:15.126 --> 01:22:18.646
Let's do one more comment with this
before we move on to our next comment, OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10619-0
01:22:18.686 --> 01:22:19.806
So go ahead, great.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10643-0
01:22:19.886 --> 01:22:24.046
And I just wanted to like Anthony agree
with Katie,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10643-1
01:22:24.046 --> 01:22:30.046
as far as her perspective on like the
complexity and that misunderstanding
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10643-2
01:22:30.046 --> 01:22:32.366
about what one-size-fits-all.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10665-0
01:22:33.886 --> 01:22:40.842
Like I want to see the state have
legislation that addresses all batteries
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10665-1
01:22:40.842 --> 01:22:44.366
and that within that there have to be.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10679-0
01:22:44.676 --> 01:22:48.213
Nuances.
Everything is different and you wanna be
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10679-1
01:22:48.213 --> 01:22:50.476
efficient within these segments.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10719-0
01:22:50.556 --> 01:22:57.481
Full agreement on that and I think the
main point that I've been trying to get
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10719-1
01:22:57.481 --> 01:23:02.214
across is that I think there are handling
ways there.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10719-2
01:23:02.214 --> 01:23:08.876
People can get licensure so that they can
dismantle these devices and then.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10730-0
01:23:09.686 --> 01:23:13.766
Put those batteries into this existing,
separate loose.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10739-0
01:23:14.076 --> 01:23:17.636
Battery stream that is doing its own
thing.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10753-0
01:23:17.636 --> 01:23:22.460
It has its own how do we get the
batteries out of the vapes and into that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10753-1
01:23:22.460 --> 01:23:22.916
stream?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10791-0
01:23:23.036 --> 01:23:28.359
Just batteries into that stream and we'll
work on some of the other nicotine and
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10791-1
01:23:28.359 --> 01:23:32.105
hazardous waste.
But once you bifurcate that and you can
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10791-2
01:23:32.105 --> 01:23:37.165
get those large valuable lithium ions
into the general recycling stream with
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10791-3
01:23:37.165 --> 01:23:39.596
the other lithium ions, I think that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10804-0
01:23:40.286 --> 01:23:45.326
'S That's maybe where I've been trying to
go and misunderstood as far as.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10822-0
01:23:45.476 --> 01:23:50.647
How it integrates is to try to like get
it and put it onto that other river of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10822-1
01:23:50.647 --> 01:23:53.396
batteries that are going and is efficient.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10838-0
01:23:55.396 --> 01:23:59.594
Because you're right, electronic,
those devices are not efficient and can't
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10838-1
01:23:59.594 --> 01:24:02.356
just flow with everything else.
Absolutely agree.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10842-0
01:24:08.616 --> 01:24:10.736
Next point, Katie, when you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10851-0
01:24:11.716 --> 01:24:14.836
No, just thank you for that clarification.
Appreciate that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10878-0
01:24:15.636 --> 01:24:19.147
I think maybe one thing to note as we
think about products,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10878-1
01:24:19.147 --> 01:24:23.243
making sure to your point right,
batteries are going to flow from the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10878-2
01:24:23.243 --> 01:24:26.636
products once they're dismantled into the
battery system.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10922-0
01:24:26.636 --> 01:24:30.269
So make sure we're avoiding any
duplication of paying into multiple
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10922-1
01:24:30.269 --> 01:24:34.063
systems on behalf of a product.
When we look through it via that lens.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10922-2
01:24:34.063 --> 01:24:36.681
And you know in the electronics recycling
world,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10922-3
01:24:36.681 --> 01:24:41.009
you know our vendors have certification
programs or recyclers have certification
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10922-4
01:24:41.009 --> 01:24:41.436
program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10946-0
01:24:41.636 --> 01:24:46.017
That ensure batteries from electronics,
whether embedded or otherwise,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10946-1
01:24:46.017 --> 01:24:50.768
end up at the appropriate downstream
authorized vendors for that material as
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10946-2
01:24:50.768 --> 01:24:51.076
well.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10950-0
01:24:51.356 --> 01:24:51.876
So we do.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/10956-0
01:24:51.876 --> 01:24:52.396
Kind of.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11003-0
01:24:52.396 --> 01:24:56.744
We address batteries as part of obviously
of the output of commodities coming out
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11003-1
01:24:56.744 --> 01:25:00.773
of the electronics recycling process.
But with that lens of let's just make
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11003-2
01:25:00.773 --> 01:25:04.378
sure we're not double counting or
requiring double payment when the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11003-3
01:25:04.378 --> 01:25:08.036
products that contain that have batteries
in them are being managed.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11007-0
01:25:08.766 --> 01:25:09.646
Via separate system.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11009-0
01:25:12.076 --> 01:25:12.516
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11012-0
01:25:12.516 --> 01:25:13.756
Thank you, Katie.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11018-0
01:25:13.756 --> 01:25:15.556
Should we move on to our next point?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11025-0
01:25:15.556 --> 01:25:17.876
Yeah, I guess also from here I'll move on.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11027-0
01:25:17.876 --> 01:25:18.716
We kind of covered.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11033-0
01:25:20.686 --> 01:25:22.846
We've covered covered products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11039-0
01:25:23.166 --> 01:25:25.566
I guess I'll move on to collection and
convenience.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11041-0
01:25:27.286 --> 01:25:27.926
Something.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11054-0
01:25:29.726 --> 01:25:33.086
What, so I'll say what in terms of a,
So what?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11066-0
01:25:33.086 --> 01:25:39.719
So what programs have convenience
standards and so for batteries or these
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11066-1
01:25:39.719 --> 01:25:40.526
products?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11068-0
01:25:43.126 --> 01:25:43.846
Where?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11076-0
01:25:44.356 --> 01:25:48.796
Where would be the best collection
locations for these products?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11083-0
01:25:50.326 --> 01:25:51.966
Would it be transfer stations?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11088-0
01:25:51.966 --> 01:25:53.686
Would it be retailers?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11093-0
01:25:53.686 --> 01:25:55.686
Would it be specific collection sites?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11101-0
01:25:58.686 --> 01:26:03.406
What are people's thoughts for collection
locations?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11106-0
01:26:04.926 --> 01:26:06.486
And convenience standards.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11111-0
01:26:13.216 --> 01:26:15.176
Hey, Mark Draper want to go ahead?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11116-0
01:26:17.226 --> 01:26:18.306
Hey, thanks again.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11125-0
01:26:19.186 --> 01:26:20.706
So yeah, I thought about this a lot.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11143-0
01:26:20.706 --> 01:26:23.499
Actually,
we've been trying to do some work in our
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11143-1
01:26:23.499 --> 01:26:27.550
region to increase the number of
collection locations specific to some of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11143-2
01:26:27.550 --> 01:26:28.426
these batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11155-0
01:26:29.926 --> 01:26:35.886
Now obviously solid waste facilities like
transfer stations are are an obvious.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11164-0
01:26:38.086 --> 01:26:39.852
Option,
but certainly in our case here in
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11164-1
01:26:39.852 --> 01:26:40.566
Aroostook County.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11176-0
01:26:42.406 --> 01:26:45.642
You know one one of the things that
you'll find in a lot of cases is your
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11176-1
01:26:45.642 --> 01:26:46.166
solid waste.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11195-0
01:26:46.436 --> 01:26:49.797
Facilities aren't particularly
conveniently located,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11195-1
01:26:49.797 --> 01:26:51.636
and that's usually by design.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11241-0
01:26:51.636 --> 01:26:56.735
You don't want them near people because
people don't like them for particularly
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11241-1
01:26:56.735 --> 01:27:01.834
so I know retailers I think is another
obvious one that's similar to what we've
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11241-2
01:27:01.834 --> 01:27:06.933
seen in the programs like Paint Care,
where the retailers are obviously heavily
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11241-3
01:27:06.933 --> 01:27:10.056
involved.
And I think those have been relatively
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11241-4
01:27:10.056 --> 01:27:10.566
success.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11243-0
01:27:10.716 --> 01:27:10.996
So.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11258-0
01:27:11.766 --> 01:27:15.634
One of the other things that we've looked
at up here specifically would be fire
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11258-1
01:27:15.634 --> 01:27:16.166
department.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11272-0
01:27:16.836 --> 01:27:21.456
And fire stations specifically because
you know who has a vested interest in
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11272-1
01:27:21.456 --> 01:27:22.476
preventing fires.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11279-0
01:27:22.476 --> 01:27:26.076
And again, I know I'm focused on fires,
but that's the issue that we're having.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11303-0
01:27:27.566 --> 01:27:32.486
And so it'd be interesting to see what
interest there is from from fire stations
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11303-1
01:27:32.486 --> 01:27:34.126
to be collection locations.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11322-0
01:27:34.166 --> 01:27:39.233
Well trained people have a vested
interest in not having the fires and a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11322-1
01:27:39.233 --> 01:27:41.246
lot of them are man 24/7 365.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11333-0
01:27:41.366 --> 01:27:45.886
So that's my thought on that. And I think,
Brian, correct me if I'm wrong.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11336-0
01:27:45.886 --> 01:27:47.646
I think the paint care program had
actually.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11361-0
01:27:47.956 --> 01:27:53.679
Actually a standard in it that you know
the collection locations had to be within
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11361-1
01:27:53.679 --> 01:27:57.796
a certain distance of a certain segment
of the population.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11371-0
01:27:57.796 --> 01:28:00.516
I think that might already exist in one
of the other ones.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11377-0
01:28:00.516 --> 01:28:02.916
I think in pink hair,
but I might be wrong.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11382-0
01:28:03.476 --> 01:28:04.756
Yeah. No, that is correct.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11392-0
01:28:04.756 --> 01:28:08.676
There is a paint care convenience
standard about about that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11413-0
01:28:09.236 --> 01:28:12.171
I I can't rattle it off top my head,
but yes,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11413-1
01:28:12.171 --> 01:28:16.636
it's like like 90% of the population must
be within 10 miles of a 15.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11446-0
01:28:16.996 --> 01:28:21.149
So but one of course,
one of the interesting things that brings
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11416-0
01:28:17.016 --> 01:28:17.416
Yeah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11446-1
01:28:21.149 --> 01:28:24.198
up is that with the case of transfer
stations,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11446-2
01:28:24.198 --> 01:28:28.156
so a lot of transfer stations are only
available to use for.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11454-0
01:28:28.886 --> 01:28:31.766
The residents of a particular
municipality, so.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11491-0
01:28:34.356 --> 01:28:38.429
So that that Even so,
even though if you look at a map that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11491-1
01:28:38.429 --> 01:28:43.927
shows and I'll kind of say this and then
we'll move on to some other people that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11491-2
01:28:43.927 --> 01:28:48.815
shows that there are a lot of quote
collection points because there are
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11491-3
01:28:48.815 --> 01:28:51.326
located in transfer station you know.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11513-0
01:28:51.326 --> 01:28:55.870
That's specific to a residence and a lot
of the surrounding community can't
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11513-1
01:28:55.870 --> 01:28:59.876
actually use that particular transfer
station because they're not.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11516-0
01:29:00.606 --> 01:29:01.246
In that community.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11525-0
01:29:01.876 --> 01:29:07.076
And kind of talks about how how retail
locations may be.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11536-0
01:29:08.686 --> 01:29:11.806
Or other locations that are more
available to the general public.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11552-0
01:29:13.526 --> 01:29:17.885
Would need to play a part in this,
particularly in if we're talking about
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11552-1
01:29:17.885 --> 01:29:18.886
devices that are.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11562-0
01:29:20.196 --> 01:29:24.156
Relatively common and somebody will need
to get rid of.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11564-0
01:29:24.856 --> 01:29:25.296
Right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11578-0
01:29:25.846 --> 01:29:29.966
And not be able to not be anywhere near
there local transportation.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11582-0
01:29:30.166 --> 01:29:34.006
So I'll we'll move on to Ashley.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11575-0
01:29:30.596 --> 01:29:31.076
Right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11600-0
01:29:36.886 --> 01:29:42.343
Hi all I have a couple thoughts on this
point and I'll follow up in the written
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11600-1
01:29:42.343 --> 01:29:44.526
comment after this meeting. But.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11645-0
01:29:46.006 --> 01:29:48.401
For collection points and convenience
standards,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11645-1
01:29:48.401 --> 01:29:51.920
the first comment I wanted to make
quickly and I I had to leave the the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11645-2
01:29:51.920 --> 01:29:54.608
meeting briefly,
so apologies if this was talked about
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11645-3
01:29:54.608 --> 01:29:56.856
before,
but I just wanted to make the comment
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11645-4
01:29:56.856 --> 01:29:59.886
that large format batteries such as
batteries found in elect.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11660-0
01:29:59.886 --> 01:30:02.294
Vehicles.
Those are managed by licensed
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11660-1
01:30:02.294 --> 01:30:06.086
professionals and it's not not the case
that just the average.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11682-0
01:30:06.676 --> 01:30:13.544
Consumer owner of an electric vehicle is
taking that battery to a collection point
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11682-1
01:30:13.544 --> 01:30:15.116
or recycling point.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11686-0
01:30:15.116 --> 01:30:16.396
That's that's not the case.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11694-0
01:30:16.396 --> 01:30:17.756
They weigh hundreds of pounds.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11704-0
01:30:17.756 --> 01:30:20.764
It requires a professional to take out
that battery,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11704-1
01:30:20.764 --> 01:30:22.636
so just wanted to make sure that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11717-0
01:30:24.686 --> 01:30:28.166
Folks were aware of that.
The rest of my comment quickly.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11735-0
01:30:28.166 --> 01:30:32.923
I just want to keep it tailored to small
format and medium format batteries
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11735-1
01:30:32.923 --> 01:30:34.926
because those can definitely be.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11743-0
01:30:35.876 --> 01:30:38.676
Handled by a consumer taken to a
collection point.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11745-0
01:30:40.206 --> 01:30:41.046
The.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11757-0
01:30:43.166 --> 01:30:45.406
At Redwood Materials,
I'm commenting on Redwood.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11771-0
01:30:45.446 --> 01:30:49.251
At Redwood Materials,
we offer free collection opportunities
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11771-1
01:30:49.251 --> 01:30:50.686
all across the country.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11780-0
01:30:50.686 --> 01:30:52.766
We do hundreds of events across the
country.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11810-0
01:30:52.766 --> 01:30:57.506
We have a bin that that we roll out and
partner with retailers across the country
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11810-1
01:30:57.506 --> 01:31:02.303
and we do it all on our own dime because
we believe the batteries are valuable and
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11810-2
01:31:02.303 --> 01:31:04.846
they are what we use to power our
business.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11820-0
01:31:05.196 --> 01:31:06.516
And it's not just us.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11825-0
01:31:06.586 --> 01:31:09.386
Batteries are valuable in the marketplace.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11840-0
01:31:09.386 --> 01:31:12.906
There's a whole marketplace for their
buying and selling of them downstream.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11835-0
01:31:11.456 --> 01:31:11.616
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11871-0
01:31:14.436 --> 01:31:19.210
So I just wanted to make sure you all are
aware that there are collectors such as
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11871-1
01:31:19.210 --> 01:31:23.111
us who are better recyclers,
offer independent collection and when
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11871-2
01:31:23.111 --> 01:31:25.556
thinking about legislation for collection.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11893-0
01:31:27.236 --> 01:31:33.784
Some of the legislation to date has just
not it hasn't allowed for or included
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11893-1
01:31:33.784 --> 01:31:36.436
recyclers into the conversation.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11931-0
01:31:36.786 --> 01:31:40.939
So it's some of the legislation to date
has been quite limiting actually in
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11931-1
01:31:40.939 --> 01:31:45.147
allowing recyclers to continue what we're
already doing offering independent
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11931-2
01:31:45.147 --> 01:31:47.661
collection,
everything that I just mentioned.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11931-3
01:31:47.661 --> 01:31:50.229
So just when you're thinking about
collection,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11931-4
01:31:50.229 --> 01:31:53.836
I would hope that you would continue to
include as you are doing.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11954-0
01:31:53.836 --> 01:31:58.400
Now all stakeholders in the conversation
and allow for as many collection points
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11954-1
01:31:58.400 --> 01:32:02.626
as possible and not just limit them to a
battery stewardship organization.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/11962-0
01:32:03.316 --> 01:32:06.076
And the last point I wanted to make
really, really quickly.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12013-0
01:32:07.126 --> 01:32:11.429
One other evolving point in this
conversation with Battery EPR for small
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12013-1
01:32:11.429 --> 01:32:15.908
and medium format is the concept of not
just having one battery stewardship
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12013-2
01:32:15.908 --> 01:32:19.091
organization,
but having multiple battery stewardship
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12013-3
01:32:19.091 --> 01:32:23.806
organizations that can collectively work
together to meet convenient standards.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12037-0
01:32:24.406 --> 01:32:29.011
This just allows for greater amount of
folks to be participating,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12037-1
01:32:29.011 --> 01:32:32.708
not having it be limited to just a
nonprofit entity,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12037-2
01:32:32.708 --> 01:32:36.196
but for allowing for more market players
to come.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12052-0
01:32:36.386 --> 01:32:41.106
And participate and therefore aid and
increase collection and recovery rates.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12060-0
01:32:41.146 --> 01:32:46.173
So I'll provide more detail in my comment,
but those are my points for right now.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12060-1
01:32:46.173 --> 01:32:46.786
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12062-0
01:32:47.326 --> 01:32:48.006
Great. Great.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12064-0
01:32:48.366 --> 01:32:49.246
Thank you, Ashley.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12068-0
01:32:50.716 --> 01:32:51.556
Moving on to Abby.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12072-0
01:32:53.976 --> 01:32:54.576
Hi, guys.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12079-0
01:32:55.216 --> 01:32:56.456
Oh, can you see me?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12100-0
01:32:57.296 --> 01:33:01.393
I'm also with the hazardous waste
management unit and I just wanted to talk
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12083-0
01:32:57.946 --> 01:32:58.186
Listen.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12100-1
01:33:01.393 --> 01:33:04.896
about in terms of being able to drop
batteries at retail spaces.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12142-0
01:33:06.316 --> 01:33:11.352
We would be concerned there with storage
requirements as well as safe storage if
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12142-1
01:33:11.352 --> 01:33:15.020
they were storing batteries that maybe
one caught on fire,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12142-2
01:33:15.020 --> 01:33:19.682
whatever we would want them to have
training on how to be able to properly
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12142-3
01:33:19.682 --> 01:33:21.236
store and ship batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12145-0
01:33:22.996 --> 01:33:23.636
As universal way.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12174-0
01:33:23.906 --> 01:33:27.010
So that's just something to think about
with retail locations,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12174-1
01:33:27.010 --> 01:33:31.050
because a lot of those retail locations,
they might not train employees on how to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12174-2
01:33:31.050 --> 01:33:32.626
handle universal waste properly.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12176-0
01:33:34.896 --> 01:33:35.216
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12179-0
01:33:35.216 --> 01:33:36.856
Thank you, Abby. Jennifer.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12188-0
01:33:40.516 --> 01:33:41.596
Good point, Abby.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12204-0
01:33:42.236 --> 01:33:46.959
I also wanted to give some additional
consideration when it comes to transfer
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12204-1
01:33:46.959 --> 01:33:48.836
stations as a collection point.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12237-0
01:33:50.356 --> 01:33:53.994
Here in Maine,
if a transfer station accepts universal
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12237-1
01:33:53.994 --> 01:33:58.028
waste from businesses,
they need to notify our unit and they
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12237-2
01:33:58.028 --> 01:34:02.989
need to send us quarterly reports
indicating everything they bring in from
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12237-3
01:34:02.989 --> 01:34:03.716
businesses.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12251-0
01:34:05.956 --> 01:34:10.076
That is the decision of the municipality
whether they want to accept from business.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12262-0
01:34:10.666 --> 01:34:13.666
Or not.
We don't have any control over that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12267-0
01:34:13.666 --> 01:34:16.386
We just enforce the requirements if they
choose to do so.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12302-0
01:34:17.876 --> 01:34:22.397
On the business end,
we have something called the log system
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12302-1
01:34:22.397 --> 01:34:26.028
in place,
which small universal waste generators
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12302-2
01:34:26.028 --> 01:34:29.956
can use to move universal waste
downstream in state.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12328-0
01:34:31.716 --> 01:34:36.636
That allows a business to move universal
waste downstream in state without using a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12328-1
01:34:36.636 --> 01:34:39.836
hazardous waste manifest or a uniform
bill of lading.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12357-0
01:34:41.186 --> 01:34:44.548
However,
if they're generating over 200 items per
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12357-1
01:34:44.548 --> 01:34:47.842
month,
or they accumulate over 200 items on site
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12357-2
01:34:47.842 --> 01:34:51.203
at any time,
they cannot bring their items to the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12357-3
01:34:51.203 --> 01:34:52.346
transfer station.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12384-0
01:34:53.756 --> 01:34:57.328
So they would have to ship them off
directly to a consolidation facility or
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12384-1
01:34:57.328 --> 01:35:00.476
recycling facility on a main uniform bill
of lading or a manifest.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12395-0
01:35:01.666 --> 01:35:05.266
So that is an additional consideration
when it comes to transfer stations.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12408-0
01:35:06.136 --> 01:35:10.456
That's for businesses.
Resident residential has like.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12432-0
01:35:09.016 --> 01:35:12.196
Right, right.
Residents that are exempt from all that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12432-1
01:35:12.196 --> 01:35:15.666
It would just be batteries being
collected from businesses.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12415-0
01:35:12.526 --> 01:35:13.086
Yes.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12432-2
01:35:15.666 --> 01:35:19.656
You would have some additional
restrictions when it came to transfer
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12432-3
01:35:19.656 --> 01:35:20.176
stations.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12437-0
01:35:23.256 --> 01:35:25.096
Alright, thank you, Jennifer Stewart.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12440-0
01:35:27.676 --> 01:35:28.676
Hi, yes.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12449-0
01:35:28.676 --> 01:35:30.676
So I'm Karen Stewart.
I'm with cauldre cycle.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12469-0
01:35:30.676 --> 01:35:35.872
So we are the battery organization that
has been operating throughout the United
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12469-1
01:35:35.872 --> 01:35:37.476
States for over 30 years.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12475-0
01:35:37.956 --> 01:35:39.116
And so I just wanted to give.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12495-0
01:35:39.116 --> 01:35:42.796
I pulled up on my other screen some
information on because we are actively
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12495-1
01:35:42.796 --> 01:35:45.396
collecting in Maine,
we have been for over 30 years.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12504-0
01:35:46.316 --> 01:35:49.036
I would not when we talk about portable.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12519-0
01:35:49.036 --> 01:35:52.357
So I'm gonna have just as Jennifer
pointed out before and I forget the the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12519-1
01:35:52.357 --> 01:35:53.596
woman who right before that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12530-0
01:35:54.316 --> 01:35:57.253
There are some nuanced differences when
you talk about portable versus medium
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12530-1
01:35:57.253 --> 01:35:57.516
format.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12567-0
01:35:58.246 --> 01:36:02.133
And for those that I don't know that
we've actually defined that how it's
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12567-1
01:36:02.133 --> 01:36:06.283
typically been defined in the laws that
have passed the 300 Watt hours is your
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12567-2
01:36:06.283 --> 01:36:07.806
kind of tipping point, right?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12577-0
01:36:07.806 --> 01:36:11.526
So that's due to the transport regs under
300 waters.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12580-0
01:36:11.526 --> 01:36:12.046
We'll talk.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12592-0
01:36:12.046 --> 01:36:16.190
We'll call it smaller portable.
I would not limit you know who's eligible
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12592-1
01:36:16.190 --> 01:36:17.086
to collect that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12615-0
01:36:18.596 --> 01:36:21.835
Our closest your one of your neighbors in
Vermont.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12615-1
01:36:21.835 --> 01:36:25.773
We've been operating a program there for
almost a decade now,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12615-2
01:36:25.773 --> 01:36:27.996
and we work with transfer stations.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12621-0
01:36:28.426 --> 01:36:29.186
Work with retailers.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12622-0
01:36:29.186 --> 01:36:30.506
We work with libraries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12667-0
01:36:30.506 --> 01:36:32.757
We work with hospitals,
we work with everybody 'cause.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12667-1
01:36:32.757 --> 01:36:35.089
Our intent is to get as many batteries
back as possible,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12667-2
01:36:35.089 --> 01:36:37.994
so I wouldn't limit it because the the
size of those batteries and our
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12667-3
01:36:37.994 --> 01:36:41.186
collection kits that we have with the
patented liner and the training and all
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12667-4
01:36:41.186 --> 01:36:41.636
the safety.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12672-0
01:36:41.636 --> 01:36:42.506
That we do.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12682-0
01:36:42.706 --> 01:36:46.711
Our our intent is really to get the most
that we can when we talk about medium
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12682-1
01:36:46.711 --> 01:36:47.066
format.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12697-0
01:36:47.066 --> 01:36:51.386
Now you're going 300 to 2000 Watt hours.
As was mentioned before.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12698-0
01:36:51.386 --> 01:36:52.786
That's that's different.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12705-0
01:36:52.866 --> 01:36:55.546
And so in these various states, we do.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12709-0
01:36:56.276 --> 01:36:57.476
Have we have limited it to?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12738-0
01:36:58.026 --> 01:37:01.584
Household hazardous waste,
or sites that are trained to handle that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12738-1
01:37:01.584 --> 01:37:04.828
type of material. Again,
you're talking just about a lot more
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12738-2
01:37:04.828 --> 01:37:09.066
energy density if something goes wrong,
there's just a lot more that can happen.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12775-0
01:37:09.346 --> 01:37:13.282
So it's typically the limitation happens
when you get that medium format category
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12775-1
01:37:13.282 --> 01:37:17.122
to make sure that you have people that
are trained that are there day after day
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12775-2
01:37:17.122 --> 01:37:20.146
that know what to do and how to safely
handle these batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12779-0
01:37:20.146 --> 01:37:22.106
So just wanted to kind of give that
information.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12796-0
01:37:22.916 --> 01:37:27.068
Within Maine, the the two,
the by far the biggest collection sites
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12796-1
01:37:27.068 --> 01:37:27.316
are.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12798-0
01:37:27.986 --> 01:37:28.866
The retailers.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12810-0
01:37:30.396 --> 01:37:32.036
But people go to transfer sites on a
weekly basis.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12815-0
01:37:32.036 --> 01:37:33.836
So you don't want to take that away from
them either.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12818-0
01:37:38.066 --> 01:37:38.466
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12821-0
01:37:38.466 --> 01:37:39.746
Thank you, Katie.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12829-0
01:37:41.226 --> 01:37:42.626
Yeah. Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12840-0
01:37:42.906 --> 01:37:46.571
One in distress,
I think convenience to consumers is
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12840-1
01:37:46.571 --> 01:37:47.746
really important.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12891-0
01:37:47.786 --> 01:37:52.441
But I do think we need to think about
who's best equipped to properly and
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12891-1
01:37:52.441 --> 01:37:56.844
safely handle the material,
and specifically when we get into kind of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12891-2
01:37:56.844 --> 01:38:01.625
the product conversation. You know,
CTA has retail members that have set up
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12891-3
01:38:01.625 --> 01:38:03.826
voluntary programs for electronics.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12912-0
01:38:04.026 --> 01:38:06.986
It is very involved.
They'll tell you that there's significant
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12912-1
01:38:06.986 --> 01:38:09.664
employee training.
You have to make sure you have enough
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12912-2
01:38:09.664 --> 01:38:11.026
space in your retail setting.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12963-0
01:38:11.146 --> 01:38:14.082
To properly take back the products
themselves,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12963-1
01:38:14.082 --> 01:38:18.393
there's obviously all of the
considerations around what the specific
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12963-2
01:38:18.393 --> 01:38:22.954
states handling requirements are.
Just kind of heard DEP. Refer to that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12963-3
01:38:22.954 --> 01:38:28.014
I would just say not all retailers may be
equipped to properly and safely manage
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12963-4
01:38:28.014 --> 01:38:29.826
the take back of products or.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12970-0
01:38:29.826 --> 01:38:33.586
Potentially have the space to do so.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12985-0
01:38:33.666 --> 01:38:37.052
You can buy battery embedded products at
a gas station.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12985-1
01:38:37.052 --> 01:38:38.866
I don't necessarily represent.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/12994-0
01:38:39.596 --> 01:38:41.756
Those products that you can buy at a gas
station.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13020-0
01:38:42.506 --> 01:38:47.305
But something to think about, you know,
do we want a product take back program
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13020-1
01:38:47.305 --> 01:38:51.740
happening at a gas station that is in
fact serving as a retailer in that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13020-2
01:38:51.740 --> 01:38:52.226
setting?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13067-0
01:38:52.226 --> 01:38:56.616
So I think you know there needs to be
some consideration around convenience as
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13067-1
01:38:56.616 --> 01:39:01.005
well as like who's properly equipped to
actually handle this material and make
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13067-2
01:39:01.005 --> 01:39:05.450
sure there's a set of collectors sort of
standards or best management practices
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13067-3
01:39:05.450 --> 01:39:08.506
that go along,
goes along with operating as a collect.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13069-0
01:39:08.866 --> 01:39:09.666
Of battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13071-0
01:39:10.356 --> 01:39:10.676
Embedded products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13073-0
01:39:13.896 --> 01:39:14.216
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13078-0
01:39:14.216 --> 01:39:14.896
Thank you, Katie.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13090-0
01:39:14.896 --> 01:39:19.525
We'll go to the room. I think that was.
That was a really great point and and we
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13090-1
01:39:19.525 --> 01:39:21.296
just want to put out also that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13111-0
01:39:22.756 --> 01:39:28.596
For smaller retailers that are handling
certain types of products that could be
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13111-1
01:39:28.596 --> 01:39:32.756
insurance implications.
So there may be other financial.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13124-0
01:39:34.516 --> 01:39:40.914
Implications, obstacles,
or obligations that that retail is going
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13124-1
01:39:40.914 --> 01:39:42.756
to have to take on.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13128-0
01:39:43.306 --> 01:39:44.146
Not in state should.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13130-0
01:39:44.146 --> 01:39:45.666
The state should be thoughtful of.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13135-0
01:39:47.196 --> 01:39:48.116
Putting on the shelf this.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13137-0
01:39:49.956 --> 01:39:50.116
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13141-0
01:39:50.316 --> 01:39:51.836
Thank you. OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13143-0
01:39:51.836 --> 01:39:52.396
Another one from the room.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13182-0
01:39:54.196 --> 01:39:59.842
My question is like maybe for Katie or
someone that is more experienced in
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13182-1
01:39:59.842 --> 01:40:04.735
implementation on this.
Like I would make an assumption that you
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13182-2
01:40:04.735 --> 01:40:10.907
have a a retail or you have a a store or
a collection site that the storage space
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13182-3
01:40:10.907 --> 01:40:13.316
that you may have to accept bat.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13203-0
01:40:14.016 --> 01:40:20.395
The level of training and the type of
training would more than likely be tied
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13203-1
01:40:20.395 --> 01:40:25.056
to the products of which you sell at that
same location.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13208-0
01:40:26.266 --> 01:40:28.386
And and I just wonder.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13250-0
01:40:30.116 --> 01:40:37.265
How do they do that in that if it's like
a cell phone company but they come with a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13250-1
01:40:37.265 --> 01:40:43.982
large tractor battery or the 200 Watt,
300 Watt and those type of things like
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13250-2
01:40:43.982 --> 01:40:49.236
and I bring it up because you have a lot
of folks that want.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13274-0
01:40:49.236 --> 01:40:52.928
To engage in these type programs,
they want it to be successful and it
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13274-1
01:40:52.928 --> 01:40:55.996
seems reasonable that they would want to
set up for their.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13316-0
01:40:56.346 --> 01:41:00.931
Catchment their customers things that
they process and be really great at that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13316-1
01:41:00.931 --> 01:41:05.632
and how do you support and cultivate that
without like beating it out of them by
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13316-2
01:41:05.632 --> 01:41:09.230
saying now you're gonna have to take
other people's products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13316-3
01:41:09.230 --> 01:41:12.306
You're gonna have to store other.
You never sold it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13330-0
01:41:12.376 --> 01:41:15.014
Your store,
but it's gonna take your employees time
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13330-1
01:41:15.014 --> 01:41:16.536
and all of this type of stuff.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13337-0
01:41:16.816 --> 01:41:20.936
Or is it might make pretending a scenario
that doesn't actually exist in reality.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13368-0
01:41:23.316 --> 01:41:26.986
I think you're hitting the nail on the
head actually. I mean,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13368-1
01:41:26.986 --> 01:41:31.248
I think that a lot of retailers build
their programs around the type of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13368-2
01:41:31.248 --> 01:41:33.556
products they sell within their stores.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13380-0
01:41:33.556 --> 01:41:36.909
So if they're offering a voluntary
program for, say,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13380-1
01:41:36.909 --> 01:41:38.996
traditional consumer electronics.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13397-0
01:41:40.466 --> 01:41:44.066
You know they're only going to take back
those types of products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13403-0
01:41:44.146 --> 01:41:46.066
That's what they know how to handle.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13421-0
01:41:46.066 --> 01:41:50.495
That's what they are equipped to handle.
You know someone who sells a consumer
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13421-1
01:41:50.495 --> 01:41:53.186
electronics isn't going to take back that
easy.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13435-0
01:41:53.736 --> 01:41:58.016
Battery or that battery from a tractor
trailer.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13497-0
01:41:58.086 --> 01:42:03.479
It's not really compatible with their
world in which they operate and function,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13497-1
01:42:03.479 --> 01:42:07.457
so I think again that goes back to kind
of considerations,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13497-2
01:42:07.457 --> 01:42:12.378
you know placing mandates on retailers to
take back products. And again,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13497-3
01:42:12.378 --> 01:42:17.165
I'm only speaking from the product
perspective, not the least battery,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13497-4
01:42:17.165 --> 01:42:17.906
but to dig.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13506-0
01:42:17.896 --> 01:42:20.206
Back battery containing products one.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13522-0
01:42:20.206 --> 01:42:24.982
We don't see any retail mandates in terms
of retailer mandated take back for at
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13522-1
01:42:24.982 --> 01:42:28.086
least electronic devices here in the
United States.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13543-0
01:42:30.646 --> 01:42:34.183
And I you know,
there's there's a reason for why that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13543-1
01:42:34.183 --> 01:42:38.245
hasn't happened to date,
but I think you're perfectly I think
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13543-2
01:42:38.245 --> 01:42:40.406
you're going down the right path.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13544-0
01:42:40.406 --> 01:42:41.126
I have.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13567-0
01:42:41.126 --> 01:42:43.595
You know,
not placing a mandate on retailers to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13567-1
01:42:43.595 --> 01:42:47.298
take back all types of batteries,
I'm including from products that they
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13567-2
01:42:47.298 --> 01:42:47.966
haven't sold.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13569-0
01:42:50.216 --> 01:42:50.656
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13572-0
01:42:50.656 --> 01:42:52.376
Thank you, Katie. Amanda.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13613-0
01:42:56.356 --> 01:42:59.781
Thanks. Yeah,
I just wanted to build on a comment that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13613-1
01:42:59.781 --> 01:43:04.264
one of the other gentlemen in the room
just mentioned about the smaller
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13613-2
01:43:04.264 --> 01:43:09.245
retailers having to take on increased
costs potentially in insurance for safety
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13613-3
01:43:09.245 --> 01:43:13.977
reasons and those kinds of things and
that municipalities could eventually,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13613-4
01:43:13.977 --> 01:43:14.786
you know end.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13631-0
01:43:14.786 --> 01:43:18.203
Up in that same boat that if they're,
you know, for example,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13631-1
01:43:18.203 --> 01:43:21.396
our risk management,
if they were to go through and and.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13642-0
01:43:22.066 --> 01:43:26.146
Check off that now at this transfer
station is accepting different or larger.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13656-0
01:43:26.416 --> 01:43:31.952
Or or whatever sorts of hazardous things
that could impact their insurance
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13656-1
01:43:31.952 --> 01:43:32.616
premiums.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13693-0
01:43:32.616 --> 01:43:37.499
So it's not just the smaller retailers,
it's it's anybody potentially who is
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13693-1
01:43:37.499 --> 01:43:41.494
going to be handling these materials.
But in addition to that,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13693-2
01:43:41.494 --> 01:43:46.060
you're looking at if you're going to
expand the kinds of materials that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13693-3
01:43:46.060 --> 01:43:51.386
transfer stations may not necessarily be
expected, but could be expected to handle.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13703-0
01:43:52.186 --> 01:43:55.626
You're looking at space increases those
floor plans, so to speak.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13723-0
01:43:55.776 --> 01:43:59.791
Of the transfer stations have to be
approved by the department and lots of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13723-1
01:43:59.791 --> 01:44:03.056
them are already crowded and don't have
that room to expand.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13740-0
01:44:03.056 --> 01:44:06.670
And so there's there's just lots of other
considerations that you know to be
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13740-1
01:44:06.670 --> 01:44:10.096
included in the conversation as far as
those transfer stations would go.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13744-0
01:44:14.016 --> 01:44:16.176
Thank you, Amanda. Karen.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13762-0
01:44:17.886 --> 01:44:19.802
Yeah,
I'm gonna jump back to the retail
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13762-1
01:44:19.802 --> 01:44:21.526
question that was asked in the room.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13783-0
01:44:21.526 --> 01:44:25.191
So color cycle,
we have a great partnership with four
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13783-1
01:44:25.191 --> 01:44:29.806
national retail partners, Best Buy,
Staples, Home Depot and Lowe's.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13816-0
01:44:30.006 --> 01:44:32.306
Those national foot,
that national footprint,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13816-1
01:44:32.306 --> 01:44:36.106
that partnership has come from those
retailers see a value because a lot of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13816-2
01:44:36.106 --> 01:44:39.806
their products as you just said,
they know that they're they're selling a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13816-3
01:44:39.806 --> 01:44:43.206
lot of the products with batteries that
are going on to the market.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13827-0
01:44:43.206 --> 01:44:47.706
So it is their corporate stewardship or
sustainability programs that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13860-0
01:44:47.816 --> 01:44:52.228
They have voluntarily said on a national
basis we're gonna partner with clutter
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13860-1
01:44:52.228 --> 01:44:54.710
cycle and we will take those batteries
back.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13860-2
01:44:54.710 --> 01:44:59.233
By far the largest category that we still
get are power tool batteries and by far
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13860-3
01:44:59.233 --> 01:45:02.376
the largest collections come from Home
Depot and Lowe's.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13887-0
01:45:02.496 --> 01:45:05.134
It just kind of goes hand in hand from a
retailer perspective.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13887-1
01:45:05.134 --> 01:45:08.483
They want to take the battery back to
where they got it from and that's where a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13887-2
01:45:08.483 --> 01:45:11.706
lot of these national retail partners
realize that in in their kind of doing
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13887-3
01:45:11.706 --> 01:45:12.376
the right thing.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13903-0
01:45:13.146 --> 01:45:15.831
I think as we're starting to emerge,
I think as we mentioned,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13903-1
01:45:15.831 --> 01:45:17.866
there's only a handful of states that
require.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13912-0
01:45:18.296 --> 01:45:21.096
Air primary or single use batteries to be
collected.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13925-0
01:45:21.656 --> 01:45:26.594
Those are traditionally sold at different
stores and we are now getting into that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13925-1
01:45:26.594 --> 01:45:27.256
area often.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13959-0
01:45:27.256 --> 01:45:31.289
It's a grocery store and so we are
emerging into that footprint because
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13959-1
01:45:31.289 --> 01:45:33.865
again,
consumers want to take their AA or AAA
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13959-2
01:45:33.865 --> 01:45:37.618
batteries from, you know,
they're going to take it back from where
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13959-3
01:45:37.618 --> 01:45:40.810
they bought it from,
so that that kind of mental thought
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13959-4
01:45:40.810 --> 01:45:41.986
definitely goes hand.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13968-0
01:45:41.986 --> 01:45:44.736
In hand with which retailers want to
partner with us?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13978-0
01:45:45.466 --> 01:45:48.666
The only two states that have a retailer
mandate to serve as a collection point.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/13987-0
01:45:49.016 --> 01:45:51.496
If they sell it or New York and shortly
California.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14001-0
01:45:54.456 --> 01:45:58.456
And Karen, just I try not to that,
but that's for loose batteries, correct?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14012-0
01:45:58.366 --> 01:46:00.686
That's everything I'm saying is loose
batteries, yes.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14009-0
01:45:58.496 --> 01:45:59.296
Not for.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14013-0
01:46:00.256 --> 01:46:01.256
Which data is?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14014-0
01:46:00.776 --> 01:46:01.256
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14021-0
01:46:08.826 --> 01:46:12.746
Any more feedback on convenience and
locations?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14028-0
01:46:15.146 --> 01:46:17.186
If not, we can go to our next point.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14034-0
01:46:20.396 --> 01:46:22.196
And again, I'll just reiterate.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14062-0
01:46:24.426 --> 01:46:31.262
If people do not feel like wanna if they
have thoughts on any of these topics,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14062-1
01:46:31.262 --> 01:46:37.146
this is feel free to submit written
comments at any time to us. So.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14068-0
01:46:43.316 --> 01:46:44.716
I guess one of the questions.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14077-0
01:46:46.546 --> 01:46:48.466
In terms of collection,
convenience is outreach.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14085-0
01:46:53.106 --> 01:46:58.026
How what type of requirements would?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14102-0
01:47:00.626 --> 01:47:06.465
Do to would people anticipate or like to
see regarding if we went with a product
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14102-1
01:47:06.465 --> 01:47:07.906
stewardship program?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14110-0
01:47:09.426 --> 01:47:12.546
Or product stewardship organization. How?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14123-0
01:47:13.016 --> 01:47:18.896
What kind of requirements would there be
for education and outreach to get?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14126-0
01:47:20.306 --> 01:47:20.946
Make sure that the public.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14131-0
01:47:22.666 --> 01:47:24.146
Knows how and where.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14134-0
01:47:25.866 --> 01:47:26.706
To return.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14137-0
01:47:28.306 --> 01:47:28.826
The batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14170-0
01:47:36.296 --> 01:47:40.324
From the real Oh yeah,
I would love to hear from the call to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14170-1
01:47:40.324 --> 01:47:45.541
recycling folks because of what I read
about their engagement in Vermont about
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14170-2
01:47:45.541 --> 01:47:48.776
that being a requirement of their
participation.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14182-0
01:47:50.266 --> 01:47:55.097
Because like I for some reason this
conversation's super confusing for me
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14182-1
01:47:55.097 --> 01:47:55.946
because like.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14218-0
01:47:57.776 --> 01:48:03.471
If if we're doing all batteries, you know,
then some sort of interconnected
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14218-1
01:48:03.471 --> 01:48:08.116
stewardship ecosystem with one
stewardship person at the top,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14218-2
01:48:08.116 --> 01:48:13.736
it would be reasonable for them to, like,
do a certain amount of outreach.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14250-0
01:48:13.936 --> 01:48:17.019
But like,
how do you get outreach of the large
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14250-1
01:48:17.019 --> 01:48:22.266
tractor battery people to them without
getting into all these other people that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14250-2
01:48:22.266 --> 01:48:27.514
don't seem to care and it kind of just
gets me back to being like I I feel like
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14250-3
01:48:27.514 --> 01:48:27.776
the.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14267-0
01:48:27.936 --> 01:48:32.162
To define that in the state should take
care of that and the state should
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14267-1
01:48:32.162 --> 01:48:35.416
advertise that they have approved the
recycling program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14273-0
01:48:35.456 --> 01:48:39.056
This is what it looks like,
but I don't anyway.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14302-0
01:48:39.056 --> 01:48:43.976
I just like this this whole public
outreach thing is what makes or breaks
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14302-1
01:48:43.976 --> 01:48:48.164
these things and call to recycle and
their Vermont experience.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14302-2
01:48:48.164 --> 01:48:53.017
What I read about it seemed like an
interesting case study worth talking
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14302-3
01:48:53.017 --> 01:48:53.416
about.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14309-0
01:48:54.186 --> 01:48:57.668
I mean,
I'll just just let Erin go on for just to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14309-1
01:48:57.668 --> 01:48:57.946
say.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14330-0
01:48:58.456 --> 01:49:01.218
I mean,
education outreach is the difference
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14330-1
01:49:01.218 --> 01:49:05.392
between a product getting,
getting collected and and getting thrown
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14330-2
01:49:05.392 --> 01:49:09.136
away and winding up in Mark's landfill
and catching on fire.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14335-0
01:49:10.616 --> 01:49:11.296
Yeah, right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14365-0
01:49:11.296 --> 01:49:14.689
And so, you know,
it's interesting if you talk to different
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14365-1
01:49:14.689 --> 01:49:17.234
states,
like if you talk to Washington or in
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14365-2
01:49:17.234 --> 01:49:20.062
Colorado,
the two biggest pieces that they see is
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14365-3
01:49:20.062 --> 01:49:24.416
most important to these state laws are
accessibility and education outreach.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14391-0
01:49:24.416 --> 01:49:27.941
Because if they're,
if people are aware of it and they have
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14391-1
01:49:27.941 --> 01:49:30.995
the ability,
they will generally do the right thing
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14391-2
01:49:30.995 --> 01:49:34.696
from education outreach.
Every state law has this requirement.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14389-0
01:49:32.826 --> 01:49:33.586
Good evening.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14403-0
01:49:35.506 --> 01:49:39.917
The requirement is generally that the
battery search of organization proposed
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14403-1
01:49:39.917 --> 01:49:40.426
in their.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14430-0
01:49:40.896 --> 01:49:43.676
In their plan to the state that must be
approved,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14430-1
01:49:43.676 --> 01:49:47.847
what they will do and how they will
measure that metric and then what that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14430-2
01:49:47.847 --> 01:49:51.016
metric will look like for the first three
to five years?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14431-0
01:49:51.176 --> 01:49:53.616
So from our perspective.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14445-0
01:49:54.986 --> 01:49:59.506
We survey the residents every year and we
understand primarily 2 questions.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14453-0
01:49:59.546 --> 01:50:01.558
One,
were you aware that you needed to recycle
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14453-1
01:50:01.558 --> 01:50:01.986
batteries?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14459-0
01:50:01.986 --> 01:50:03.666
And two, did you actually do it?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14472-0
01:50:03.666 --> 01:50:07.090
And those are the two metrics we are
trying to get at every single year and
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14472-1
01:50:07.090 --> 01:50:08.666
trying to move that needle upwards.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14482-0
01:50:09.376 --> 01:50:11.216
And so we use different tactics, right?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14501-0
01:50:11.216 --> 01:50:14.635
So and and what's interesting is,
so we operate in Washington,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14501-1
01:50:14.635 --> 01:50:17.674
DC and in Vermont,
you couldn't find two more different
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14501-2
01:50:17.674 --> 01:50:19.736
places with the exact same population.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14515-0
01:50:19.736 --> 01:50:23.056
So in Vermont, we try tactics,
a lot of it is social media.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14517-0
01:50:23.056 --> 01:50:24.336
It's front porch forum.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14523-0
01:50:24.336 --> 01:50:25.776
I don't know if that's in Maine as well.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14529-0
01:50:25.776 --> 01:50:28.136
It's kind of like your local where you
get news.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14537-0
01:50:28.576 --> 01:50:31.416
We do a lot of outreach through schools,
middle schools.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14555-0
01:50:32.906 --> 01:50:37.058
We are starting now to partnership with
grocery stores to get people when they
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14555-1
01:50:37.058 --> 01:50:38.266
get to a point of sale.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14563-0
01:50:38.536 --> 01:50:39.576
They're aware of it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14569-0
01:50:40.096 --> 01:50:42.496
We've tried a number of different tactics.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14579-0
01:50:42.496 --> 01:50:44.962
Another big one is actually working with
the hauler,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14579-1
01:50:44.962 --> 01:50:46.776
so I know there's haulers on this call.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14607-0
01:50:48.226 --> 01:50:51.922
Often people say that they want to learn
what to do with their battery from the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14607-1
01:50:51.922 --> 01:50:54.231
hauler.
Who is the one that is taking their their
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14607-2
01:50:54.231 --> 01:50:55.386
materials away from them?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14615-0
01:50:55.546 --> 01:50:57.506
So we'll partner with them to get that
message out.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14639-0
01:50:57.506 --> 01:51:01.991
We'll partner with the local government.
It's really kind of a. However,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14639-1
01:51:01.991 --> 01:51:05.309
we're getting the feedback annually from
that survey.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14639-2
01:51:05.309 --> 01:51:08.626
We we adjust our our outreach to to meet
what people.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14647-0
01:51:08.976 --> 01:51:11.896
People are saying to us to keep moving
that number upwards.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14650-0
01:51:16.296 --> 01:51:16.936
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14652-0
01:51:19.086 --> 01:51:19.566
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14671-0
01:51:21.926 --> 01:51:25.258
I mean,
I can feed into my own experience into
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14671-1
01:51:25.258 --> 01:51:29.086
outreach because I do it a lot for my
other programs.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14677-0
01:51:30.576 --> 01:51:31.856
Me. Turn this towards me a little bit.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14714-0
01:51:35.456 --> 01:51:40.645
So I help facilitate the paint program.
The Mercury lights program and the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14714-1
01:51:40.645 --> 01:51:45.558
Mercury thermostats program,
and one of the things that I do is that I
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14714-2
01:51:45.558 --> 01:51:50.816
make sure these store locations along
with our product stewardship program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14738-0
01:51:52.696 --> 01:51:58.409
Advisor make sure that emails are sent
out and that they have actual literature
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14738-1
01:51:58.409 --> 01:52:03.336
to be able to give to people.
I personally visit each location that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14764-0
01:52:05.646 --> 01:52:10.624
Does this recycling now this can be
tricky endeavor for some parts,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14764-1
01:52:10.624 --> 01:52:16.480
because for me I have 180 locations to
visit in a year and I do that alone this
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14764-2
01:52:16.480 --> 01:52:16.846
year.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14772-0
01:52:16.846 --> 01:52:20.166
I'm actually getting some help so along
with our.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14802-0
01:52:22.256 --> 01:52:27.130
Product Stewardship Advisors they're
taking on sixty of those locations for me,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14802-1
01:52:27.130 --> 01:52:30.176
that's still 120 that I have to do by
myself, so.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14813-0
01:52:31.696 --> 01:52:34.816
I know for us in the department how much
we can do.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14854-0
01:52:35.206 --> 01:52:39.240
We can send out emails and we can send
out material,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14854-1
01:52:39.240 --> 01:52:45.786
but physically visiting every single site,
especially for this program that we might,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14854-2
01:52:45.786 --> 01:52:50.657
you know create it depends on how much
staff is allotted to us.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14854-3
01:52:50.657 --> 01:52:55.376
If we have one person,
but we have 300 retailers slash trans.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14859-0
01:52:55.376 --> 01:52:57.766
Stations wanna work with this?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14868-0
01:52:59.296 --> 01:53:01.136
It could be very it could be very tricky.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14876-0
01:53:01.136 --> 01:53:04.097
So for our end,
that's what we can do and we're just
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14876-1
01:53:04.097 --> 01:53:04.656
trying to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14890-0
01:53:04.926 --> 01:53:12.206
To figure out how best to help everyone
else in this case is literature enough.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14898-0
01:53:12.206 --> 01:53:15.646
Do we need ads in places on websites?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14899-0
01:53:15.846 --> 01:53:17.566
Where do we see?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14908-0
01:53:18.566 --> 01:53:20.566
Can we get the word out to people?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14916-0
01:53:20.566 --> 01:53:22.806
And we just want to see for other people.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14933-0
01:53:22.806 --> 01:53:25.986
What have you seen to that?
You can get the word out, you know,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14933-1
01:53:25.986 --> 01:53:27.526
especially in this day and age.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14938-0
01:53:27.526 --> 01:53:30.126
We know Internet's always a source,
but where exactly?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14942-0
01:53:32.926 --> 01:53:34.286
Ashley, I believe.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14951-0
01:53:35.916 --> 01:53:38.476
Yes, hi,
this is Ashley from Redwood again.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14998-0
01:53:38.876 --> 01:53:43.541
I just wanted to comment once more on the
events that I'd mentioned before that we
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14998-1
01:53:43.541 --> 01:53:47.418
do events all across the country.
And one thing that we found really
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14998-2
01:53:47.418 --> 01:53:51.689
successful with doing our collection
events for lithium ion batteries is we
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/14998-3
01:53:51.689 --> 01:53:54.836
partner with local Rotary clubs across
the country and.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15012-0
01:53:55.196 --> 01:53:59.904
We give them all the the tools and
resources they need to host a collection
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15012-1
01:53:59.904 --> 01:54:00.276
event.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15027-0
01:54:00.976 --> 01:54:05.092
And and like the the social media
materials and how to advertise the event
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15027-1
01:54:05.092 --> 01:54:05.696
beforehand.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15051-0
01:54:06.726 --> 01:54:10.513
But we really try and just engage and
connect with the community in that way,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15051-1
01:54:10.513 --> 01:54:12.406
but that's one way that we're doing it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15060-0
01:54:13.466 --> 01:54:16.986
So. So just to kind of build on that,
in addition to having.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15087-0
01:54:18.416 --> 01:54:25.033
Permanent collection locations also have
kind of like the way that a lot of places
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15087-1
01:54:25.033 --> 01:54:29.736
have ewes collection collection days.
It's the same thing.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15094-0
01:54:29.736 --> 01:54:35.296
You'll have specific collection events
that you team up with.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15098-0
01:54:41.536 --> 01:54:42.536
Is that a question for me?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15104-0
01:54:43.256 --> 01:54:44.736
Yeah, I'm just just clarifying.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15108-0
01:54:44.736 --> 01:54:45.576
So so you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15121-0
01:54:45.576 --> 01:54:51.776
So you're in addition to collection
points, you're also saying to consider.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15126-0
01:54:55.236 --> 01:54:57.276
Collection events as well.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15134-0
01:54:57.676 --> 01:54:59.996
Yeah. So at Redwood, we have our own.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15132-0
01:54:58.566 --> 01:54:59.046
Yeah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15182-0
01:55:01.696 --> 01:55:07.473
Logistics network transportation.
UL tested packaging this bin that we'll
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15182-1
01:55:07.473 --> 01:55:11.143
do that.
We'll a permanent bin that we have at
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15182-2
01:55:11.143 --> 01:55:15.280
retail locations and retailers that we
partner with,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15182-3
01:55:15.280 --> 01:55:21.057
but we also do events and our our
collection program is is still growing,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15182-4
01:55:21.057 --> 01:55:24.336
but it's growing more and more every year.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15191-0
01:55:24.496 --> 01:55:26.576
So yeah, we do events and permanent bends.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15194-0
01:55:27.896 --> 01:55:28.056
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15195-0
01:55:28.056 --> 01:55:29.296
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15197-0
01:55:29.296 --> 01:55:30.216
Thank you, Abby.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15230-0
01:55:32.926 --> 01:55:37.243
Waste management unit. Again,
the one thing we get calls all the time
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15230-1
01:55:37.243 --> 01:55:42.362
for asking for our town hosted collection
event days and a lot of towns just don't
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15230-2
01:55:42.362 --> 01:55:45.446
have the budget to have their own
collection day.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15266-0
01:55:45.446 --> 01:55:49.081
So they'll band a few towns will band
together and and pay for it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15266-1
01:55:49.081 --> 01:55:52.825
If we could have collection days
specifically for battery recycling,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15266-2
01:55:52.825 --> 01:55:56.406
I think that would be great and people
would really utilize that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15269-0
01:56:00.246 --> 01:56:00.406
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15279-0
01:56:00.406 --> 01:56:03.966
I think it would even be helpful if we
could have.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15273-0
01:56:01.716 --> 01:56:01.956
Thank.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15310-0
01:56:05.496 --> 01:56:09.371
If retailers are not necessarily being
asked to collect,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15310-1
01:56:09.371 --> 01:56:14.469
maybe even just having the literature to
be like I bought this thing here,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15310-2
01:56:14.469 --> 01:56:15.896
what do I do with it?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15323-0
01:56:15.896 --> 01:56:20.592
Here's a nifty little card that says this
is where you can take it or sticker
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15323-1
01:56:20.592 --> 01:56:21.736
stickers are great.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15329-0
01:56:23.936 --> 01:56:26.216
Lot of retailers use stickers on their
windows.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15335-0
01:56:28.686 --> 01:56:30.206
OK, Ashley, real quick.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15345-0
01:56:30.636 --> 01:56:32.992
And sorry,
I just wanted to add on quickly to Abby's
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15345-1
01:56:32.992 --> 01:56:33.436
point too.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15363-0
01:56:33.436 --> 01:56:35.860
Is that,
that's another thing in working with the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15363-1
01:56:35.860 --> 01:56:38.430
Rotary clubs.
We also encourage them to partner with
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15363-2
01:56:38.430 --> 01:56:39.836
local waste management folks.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15393-0
01:56:41.336 --> 01:56:44.854
And local governments to do the events.
And again we we do it on our own dime
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15393-1
01:56:44.854 --> 01:56:48.056
because we want to increase collection
and batteries power a business.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15395-0
01:56:48.056 --> 01:56:49.776
So we'll pay for it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15400-0
01:56:51.026 --> 01:56:52.586
Do you actually a question?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15420-0
01:56:52.586 --> 01:56:57.476
Do you when you do those battery events?
Are they specific to batteries only or do
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15420-1
01:56:57.476 --> 01:57:01.306
you also team with and do like other
electronic devices as well?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15462-0
01:57:02.606 --> 01:57:05.613
Yeah.
So if we're partnering or were sponsoring
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15462-1
01:57:05.613 --> 01:57:10.186
and the it's the Rotary Club on the
ground and they're partnering with a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15462-2
01:57:10.186 --> 01:57:14.759
municipality or local waste management,
multiple items can be collected.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15462-3
01:57:14.759 --> 01:57:19.707
But usually our our traditional events we
advertise for lithium ion batteries,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15462-4
01:57:19.707 --> 01:57:21.336
but we do not turn anyone.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15489-0
01:57:21.336 --> 01:57:23.704
Away.
If somebody comes with a bag of alkaline
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15489-1
01:57:23.704 --> 01:57:26.173
batteries,
we accept it because we don't want to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15489-2
01:57:26.173 --> 01:57:29.246
cause any confusion or lessen the
convenience for consumers.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15497-0
01:57:30.016 --> 01:57:32.176
We just make sure that those other types
of materials.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15508-0
01:57:32.526 --> 01:57:37.726
Get to the proper and safe hands
downstream, so yeah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15507-0
01:57:36.476 --> 01:57:36.996
Right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15513-0
01:57:38.676 --> 01:57:40.476
OK. We have a question from the room.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15522-0
01:57:42.016 --> 01:57:43.256
I think it's also important.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15545-0
01:57:43.256 --> 01:57:46.207
I mean,
if you in a way you're trying to market
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15545-1
01:57:46.207 --> 01:57:49.589
your program,
so you need to have branding surrounding
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15545-2
01:57:49.589 --> 01:57:49.896
that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15571-0
01:57:49.896 --> 01:57:54.189
So whether that be like some type of logo
or something that's recognizable like,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15571-1
01:57:54.189 --> 01:57:56.627
hey,
there's a program in Maine and then it's
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15571-2
01:57:56.627 --> 01:57:58.376
it's like a multi prong approach.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15575-0
01:57:58.376 --> 01:58:00.336
You're like pushing that information out
there.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15595-0
01:58:00.336 --> 01:58:05.182
Let main residents know like, hey,
there's a recycling program for batteries
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15595-1
01:58:05.182 --> 01:58:09.776
and when you know when you see,
like maybe it on a product or something.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15603-0
01:58:10.166 --> 01:58:13.926
Thing or retailer has something that hey,
these products are recyclable.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15613-0
01:58:15.416 --> 01:58:19.216
There's an awareness around like this.
That's what that program meant.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15627-0
01:58:19.216 --> 01:58:22.909
Like when you see a sign like, Oh yeah,
it's manage recycling program for
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15627-1
01:58:22.909 --> 01:58:24.256
batteries like the bilocal.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15631-0
01:58:25.056 --> 01:58:26.256
Yeah, whatever it is.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15641-0
01:58:26.256 --> 01:58:28.593
I mean,
you got a brand around what you're trying
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15641-1
01:58:28.593 --> 01:58:30.696
to do,
so people know and they recognize it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15646-0
01:58:32.496 --> 01:58:33.936
And it's notable, OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15649-0
01:58:33.936 --> 01:58:34.856
Yep, one more for the room.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15697-0
01:58:37.206 --> 01:58:43.309
This this seems like like a so the
Vermont case I've referenced it a couple
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15697-1
01:58:43.309 --> 01:58:46.762
of times,
but one thing that I thought was
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15697-2
01:58:46.762 --> 01:58:53.186
interesting was that Vermont put a take
rate basically in increasing escalating
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15697-3
01:58:53.186 --> 01:58:58.566
scale that call to recycle had to kind of
like meet and they didn.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15717-0
01:58:58.606 --> 01:59:03.780
Meet that escalation and like what's
interesting to me is now thinking about
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15717-1
01:59:03.780 --> 01:59:07.206
it is like,
I wonder if maybe one of the compound.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15749-0
01:59:07.486 --> 01:59:13.107
Reasons was an amazing organization like
Redwood coming in and doing a program and
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15749-1
01:59:13.107 --> 01:59:18.119
now what were batteries that were
supposed to go to the state stewardship
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15749-2
01:59:18.119 --> 01:59:21.166
program is actually everything's right
here.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15756-0
01:59:21.166 --> 01:59:22.926
It's going into the waste stream.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15761-0
01:59:22.926 --> 01:59:25.766
It's being recycled.
Redwoods doing great things.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15788-0
01:59:27.216 --> 01:59:32.806
So maybe it's a suggestion for lessons
learned that whatever the state of Maine
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15788-1
01:59:32.806 --> 01:59:36.369
comes up with,
that we don't dictate very specific
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15788-2
01:59:36.369 --> 01:59:37.696
organizations like.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15817-0
01:59:38.166 --> 01:59:41.578
Increase their effectiveness through
advertising,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15817-1
01:59:41.578 --> 01:59:46.559
outreach and marketing that they're
penalized if they don't achieve that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15817-2
01:59:46.559 --> 01:59:50.926
because another associated group is still
doing something good.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15823-0
01:59:50.926 --> 01:59:52.366
I don't know if that makes any.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15827-0
01:59:52.366 --> 01:59:53.766
Does that make sense, right?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15841-0
01:59:53.766 --> 01:59:56.406
Because they did. They they were like,
hey, call to recycle.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15859-0
01:59:56.446 --> 02:00:01.336
You have to do this so much in 21 and
then this much increase in 22 and this
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15859-1
02:00:01.336 --> 02:00:02.606
much increase in 23.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15871-0
02:00:03.376 --> 02:00:06.816
And like if you have other good people
coming in, how was that accounted for?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15884-0
02:00:07.486 --> 02:00:09.861
Said that,
those other folks are not penalized
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15884-1
02:00:09.861 --> 02:00:12.286
because things were taken out of the
community.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15888-0
02:00:12.286 --> 02:00:16.406
It was all processed properly, absolutely,
Jennifer.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15890-0
02:00:20.866 --> 02:00:21.546
Hello again.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15939-0
02:00:23.016 --> 02:00:28.526
Circling back to education,
and when it comes to collection events,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15939-1
02:00:28.526 --> 02:00:35.089
I want to reiterate that homeowners have
a lot of exemptions from the rules when
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15939-2
02:00:35.089 --> 02:00:41.976
it comes to universal waste and hazardous
waste disposal that businesses don't have.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15950-0
02:00:42.296 --> 02:00:46.685
So for these collection events,
for example, put on by Redwood,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15950-1
02:00:46.685 --> 02:00:48.536
you know called to recycle.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15989-0
02:00:50.566 --> 02:00:53.591
If businesses are bringing their
batteries in,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15989-1
02:00:53.591 --> 02:00:58.159
they need to be tracking them,
even if they're a small universal waste
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15989-2
02:00:58.159 --> 02:01:02.342
generator and they don't have to ship on
a U ball or a manifest,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/15989-3
02:01:02.342 --> 02:01:06.846
they still need to be tracking their
universal waste cradle to grave.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16007-0
02:01:06.886 --> 02:01:10.684
They need to be keeping a receiving log.
They need to provide that log to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16007-1
02:01:10.684 --> 02:01:12.686
whoever's holding the collection event.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16014-0
02:01:13.436 --> 02:01:17.236
The entity holding the collection event
has to keep a log.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16050-0
02:01:18.726 --> 02:01:23.394
These are rules that we have in place for
businesses that homeowners are exempt
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16050-1
02:01:23.394 --> 02:01:26.136
from,
so that would also need to be a piece of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16050-2
02:01:26.136 --> 02:01:29.462
the education.
I believe when it comes to any businesses
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16050-3
02:01:29.462 --> 02:01:31.446
utilizing these collection events.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16053-0
02:01:34.626 --> 02:01:34.946
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16057-0
02:01:34.946 --> 02:01:37.226
Thank you, Jennifer. Karen.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16060-0
02:01:38.806 --> 02:01:39.566
Yeah. Thanks.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16068-0
02:01:39.886 --> 02:01:42.366
So I just wanted to respond to the
gentleman in the room.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16084-0
02:01:42.366 --> 02:01:45.799
So you hit the nail on the head there
with Vermont and it's not,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16084-1
02:01:45.799 --> 02:01:47.806
it's not Redwood. It's not one entity.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16090-0
02:01:49.246 --> 02:01:51.086
There in many states, almost every state.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16122-0
02:01:52.846 --> 02:01:56.425
Batteries do not have to go through the
batteries to organization,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16122-1
02:01:56.425 --> 02:02:00.699
but we are held to a standard that says
we have to ever increase the collection
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16122-2
02:02:00.699 --> 02:02:00.966
rate.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16148-0
02:02:01.166 --> 02:02:04.142
So for instance, hospitals,
they typically use a hazardous waste
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16148-1
02:02:04.142 --> 02:02:07.897
hauler that takes all their batteries out
of the hospital and puts them somewhere
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16148-2
02:02:07.897 --> 02:02:08.126
else.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16165-0
02:02:08.516 --> 02:02:13.558
A lot of these batteries were, you know,
are part of our steward members that are
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16165-1
02:02:13.558 --> 02:02:15.156
entering into our program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16173-0
02:02:15.196 --> 02:02:18.676
Retailers often have, you know,
AUS ecology or clean harbors.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16190-0
02:02:18.676 --> 02:02:22.965
They're all taking batteries out and
there's no there's no requirement that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16190-1
02:02:22.965 --> 02:02:24.996
they have to go through our program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16204-0
02:02:25.036 --> 02:02:29.607
So there are these kind of issues that
are these when you get to these grainy
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16204-1
02:02:29.607 --> 02:02:30.076
details.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16212-0
02:02:31.526 --> 02:02:33.526
That you have to account for and so
you're right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16219-0
02:02:33.526 --> 02:02:36.526
That's one of the issues is batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16226-0
02:02:36.526 --> 02:02:39.446
You'll have to go through us,
but we have to act on behalf of.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16229-0
02:02:39.796 --> 02:02:40.996
The industry legally.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16248-0
02:02:42.486 --> 02:02:45.592
So that they can continue to sell and
retailers can continue to place those
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16248-1
02:02:45.592 --> 02:02:46.246
items on market.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16250-0
02:02:50.036 --> 02:02:50.196
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16252-0
02:02:50.636 --> 02:02:52.676
Thanks, Karen. Ashley.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16264-0
02:02:53.756 --> 02:02:57.098
Yeah.
And thank you for those comments before.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16264-1
02:02:57.098 --> 02:02:58.236
I appreciate it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16313-0
02:03:00.086 --> 02:03:04.825
The one thing about this so looking at
other states that have passed similar
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16313-1
02:03:04.825 --> 02:03:09.071
legislation, Colorado, Illinois,
they both have very clear dedicated
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16313-2
02:03:09.071 --> 02:03:13.686
sections that talk about independent
collection and it states that anybody
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16313-3
02:03:13.686 --> 02:03:17.686
that's collecting outside of a battery
stewardship organization,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16313-4
02:03:17.686 --> 02:03:20.086
they can collect, but they have to for.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16325-0
02:03:20.086 --> 02:03:22.726
Any batteries they collect to a battery
stewardship organization?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16374-0
02:03:23.676 --> 02:03:28.953
And from what my experience in this is
that the purpose of that is for data
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16374-1
02:03:28.953 --> 02:03:34.299
tracking and just making sure the state
is reaching its goals and we want to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16374-2
02:03:34.299 --> 02:03:37.840
assist with that.
We want to be able to reach that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16374-3
02:03:37.840 --> 02:03:40.686
collection rate if not over reach it and.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16379-0
02:03:40.686 --> 02:03:41.396
Go above and beyond.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16399-0
02:03:41.396 --> 02:03:45.629
So that's one thing that we've been
coming to the table is saying, hey, like,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16399-1
02:03:45.629 --> 02:03:47.636
you know, we're not just some random.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16410-0
02:03:48.366 --> 02:03:49.966
Organization collecting batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16413-0
02:03:49.966 --> 02:03:52.446
We specialize in lithium ion batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16418-0
02:03:52.876 --> 02:03:53.916
We do this every day.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16420-0
02:03:53.916 --> 02:03:55.036
It's our bread and butter.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16460-0
02:03:56.566 --> 02:04:00.542
And we are more than happy to provide any
data to the battery stewardship
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16460-1
02:04:00.542 --> 02:04:04.088
organizations or the state,
whatever's required to make sure that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16460-2
02:04:04.088 --> 02:04:07.526
that transparency is there and
everybody's meeting their goals.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16489-0
02:04:07.526 --> 02:04:11.586
But we just want to be able to collect as
well because it's a, you know,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16489-1
02:04:11.586 --> 02:04:16.203
it's a big piece of our business and it's
just a way that we can come to the table
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16489-2
02:04:16.203 --> 02:04:19.206
to assist and have a win win situation
for everybody.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16490-0
02:04:23.756 --> 02:04:24.076
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16492-0
02:04:24.076 --> 02:04:24.796
Thank you, Ashley.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16502-0
02:04:26.286 --> 02:04:27.808
Oh yeah,
I guess that'll kind of lead that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16502-1
02:04:27.808 --> 02:04:28.126
actually.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16547-0
02:04:28.126 --> 02:04:32.668
Kind of leads into just the one of the
one of our questions in the stewardship
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16547-1
02:04:32.668 --> 02:04:35.485
in the,
in the background document was what type
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16547-2
02:04:35.485 --> 02:04:39.739
of reporting requirements should be
required of the producers and and and
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16547-3
02:04:39.739 --> 02:04:41.406
made available to the public.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16555-0
02:04:41.406 --> 02:04:42.846
So I'll say is there is there.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16560-0
02:04:42.846 --> 02:04:46.726
Is there any particular reporting
requirements that?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16569-0
02:04:48.366 --> 02:04:52.446
Folks are particularly interested in that
should be.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16574-0
02:04:53.806 --> 02:04:56.566
Specified in in the program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16576-0
02:05:01.406 --> 02:05:02.086
Got one in the room.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16625-0
02:05:03.606 --> 02:05:07.021
I was still spraying my hesitation in
terms of going all the way back to the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16625-1
02:05:07.021 --> 02:05:09.682
producer because, again,
in the more fragmented industries,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16625-2
02:05:09.682 --> 02:05:12.165
you already,
if you're gonna put this across, you know,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16625-3
02:05:12.165 --> 02:05:15.181
3000 retailers in this state,
if you're then trying to reach across
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16625-4
02:05:15.181 --> 02:05:15.846
state lines to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16664-0
02:05:15.846 --> 02:05:20.144
Get reporting from producers that opens
it up to places you know throughout the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16664-1
02:05:20.144 --> 02:05:22.777
world.
It could be a producer bringing something
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16664-2
02:05:22.777 --> 02:05:25.033
in.
I think there should be some level of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16664-3
02:05:25.033 --> 02:05:29.224
accountability of what can actually be
tracked so that the execution of it is
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16664-4
02:05:29.224 --> 02:05:30.406
well within the state.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16670-0
02:05:33.566 --> 02:05:34.206
I guess too.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16689-0
02:05:34.206 --> 02:05:36.418
I was gonna say also not just the
producers,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16689-1
02:05:36.418 --> 02:05:40.400
but of the organizations themselves that
are doing the collections and that that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16689-2
02:05:40.400 --> 02:05:42.366
type of thing. OK, one more in the room.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16697-0
02:05:42.366 --> 02:05:45.119
Yeah,
just that that was also like a a kind of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16697-1
02:05:45.119 --> 02:05:45.646
question.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16724-0
02:05:45.646 --> 02:05:51.245
It was very clear how what producers were
in what legislation has gone through the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16724-1
02:05:51.245 --> 02:05:55.023
state of Maine here,
but the clarity provided this this
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16724-2
02:05:55.023 --> 02:05:58.126
gradient from the person that actually
makes.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16740-0
02:05:58.806 --> 02:06:02.444
It to the person that distributes it to
the person that sells it and that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16740-1
02:06:02.444 --> 02:06:02.886
gradient.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16751-0
02:06:03.766 --> 02:06:08.286
Like the reporting requirements that each
of those echelons have.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16785-0
02:06:08.366 --> 02:06:13.182
Like I to try to like figure out my silly
comment was just gonna be I think they
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16785-1
02:06:13.182 --> 02:06:17.463
should use pre-existing reporting
requirements and then if you can make
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16785-2
02:06:17.463 --> 02:06:22.100
sense of something they already have to
report anyway and great you still get
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16785-3
02:06:22.100 --> 02:06:23.646
your own goal but like it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16802-0
02:06:23.646 --> 02:06:27.794
Just such a complicated thing if you
don't take the actual producers away from
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16802-1
02:06:27.794 --> 02:06:28.686
the conversation.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16817-0
02:06:29.366 --> 02:06:34.086
This is a conversation about distributors
in the electronic smoking instance.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16835-0
02:06:34.356 --> 02:06:39.225
Like it becomes really complicated.
How to give input that that department
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16835-1
02:06:39.225 --> 02:06:42.796
can actually action if that makes sense.
Alright mark.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16840-0
02:06:45.506 --> 02:06:47.106
Oops, sorry I didn't have my mic down.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16857-0
02:06:48.606 --> 02:06:51.326
So the the model that I mentioned before,
I mean there is a hierarchy.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16860-0
02:06:51.326 --> 02:06:52.246
It walks through.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16867-0
02:06:52.246 --> 02:06:53.926
What is the definition of a producer?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16871-0
02:06:53.926 --> 02:06:56.006
Because you're right exactly that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16891-0
02:06:56.006 --> 02:07:00.683
You know who is the producer can be very
complicated in some ways because of the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16891-1
02:07:00.683 --> 02:07:02.646
way the products enter the market.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16906-0
02:07:02.646 --> 02:07:05.986
So there is definitely a hierarchy in
there that defines that and that is
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16906-1
02:07:05.986 --> 02:07:09.326
something that's been vetted across a
number of different states already.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16916-0
02:07:11.086 --> 02:07:14.366
And it seemed that we haven't had a lot
of comments on it recently.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16927-0
02:07:14.756 --> 02:07:18.516
So I think we've probably gotten to the
point where it's where it needs to be.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16935-0
02:07:20.046 --> 02:07:22.406
And obviously happy to provide that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16937-0
02:07:24.206 --> 02:07:24.326
And.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16945-0
02:07:25.156 --> 02:07:27.116
I believe you do have our model.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16952-0
02:07:27.116 --> 02:07:28.676
If you don't, I certainly can supply it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16960-0
02:07:28.676 --> 02:07:31.276
I thought I did, but if if not,
I I can certainly do that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16966-0
02:07:35.786 --> 02:07:37.186
Yeah, that would be.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16969-0
02:07:37.666 --> 02:07:38.626
That would be great, mark.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16978-0
02:07:38.626 --> 02:07:41.706
I I can't remember off the top of my head
if I have that or not.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16980-0
02:07:44.166 --> 02:07:44.606
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16982-0
02:07:45.576 --> 02:07:45.896
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16986-0
02:07:45.896 --> 02:07:47.456
Thank you, Katie.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/16987-0
02:07:46.516 --> 02:07:47.156
I'll double check.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17033-0
02:07:49.446 --> 02:07:51.940
Yeah. On the,
I just wanted to chime in on the product
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17033-1
02:07:51.940 --> 02:07:54.072
side,
maybe a little less complicated than the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17033-2
02:07:54.072 --> 02:07:56.884
battery side of things.
If you're talking about potential for
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17033-3
02:07:56.884 --> 02:08:00.648
removable batteries that are in products
versus a manufacturer of loose batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17033-4
02:08:00.648 --> 02:08:03.006
But from their product perspective under
our elect.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17039-0
02:08:03.126 --> 02:08:04.166
EPR systems.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17083-0
02:08:04.166 --> 02:08:08.777
We also have a pretty widely accepted
definition of what a manufacturer is,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17083-1
02:08:08.777 --> 02:08:11.508
and again,
sort of that tiered based on its,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17083-2
02:08:11.508 --> 02:08:14.480
you know,
the brand owner label and then kind of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17083-3
02:08:14.480 --> 02:08:18.606
falling under that if that brand owner
isn't able to be identified.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17093-0
02:08:19.176 --> 02:08:22.416
So there's a working structure and
definition out there for products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17095-0
02:08:27.416 --> 02:08:27.736
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17097-0
02:08:27.736 --> 02:08:28.736
Thank you, Katie.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17101-0
02:08:30.286 --> 02:08:32.766
Any other comments?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17114-0
02:08:40.616 --> 02:08:43.856
All right.
I think I'll move on to just the general
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17114-1
02:08:43.856 --> 02:08:44.416
question.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17120-0
02:08:44.416 --> 02:08:46.216
I was kind of.
I mentioned in the beginning.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17128-0
02:08:46.216 --> 02:08:49.856
I'll mention again in terms of
harmonizing with other jurisdictions.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17142-0
02:08:52.166 --> 02:08:55.766
Again, are there any particular? I mean,
I think there was.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17148-0
02:08:55.806 --> 02:08:59.166
I think it's the universe is still rather
small from.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17167-0
02:09:01.806 --> 02:09:06.048
The math we saw earlier,
but are there any any jurisdictions that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17167-1
02:09:06.048 --> 02:09:09.326
anyone would would point out as having
particular?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17172-0
02:09:09.636 --> 02:09:12.796
I'll say successful.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17186-0
02:09:16.326 --> 02:09:21.486
Programs or ideas that we might wanna
work harder at harmonizing with?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17188-0
02:09:27.416 --> 02:09:28.256
Flee. Go ahead.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17191-0
02:09:30.076 --> 02:09:30.676
Hi again.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17206-0
02:09:31.236 --> 02:09:35.148
I'll just say that if I have my list
correct, it's seven states,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17206-1
02:09:35.148 --> 02:09:37.676
including Washington, DC that have passed.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17224-0
02:09:39.166 --> 02:09:43.061
Laws for portable in medium format
battery, EPR.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17224-1
02:09:43.061 --> 02:09:45.366
So we're still early innings.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17259-0
02:09:45.886 --> 02:09:51.030
There's only a handful of those states
that have gone into implementation or
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17259-1
02:09:51.030 --> 02:09:54.437
have been live,
Vermont being one of those states,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17259-2
02:09:54.437 --> 02:09:59.246
but a lot of states are in multi year
rule makings trying to implement.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17265-0
02:09:59.556 --> 02:10:00.516
And and get this.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17268-0
02:10:01.116 --> 02:10:02.676
Get these programs live.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17291-0
02:10:03.036 --> 02:10:07.596
So we're just, we're early stages,
there was 15 states I worked in this year
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17291-1
02:10:07.596 --> 02:10:12.274
that was considering similar legislation
and every state that does consider is
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17291-2
02:10:12.274 --> 02:10:13.636
evolving and improving.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17313-0
02:10:13.636 --> 02:10:18.423
So I think whatever we get to hear from
Maine is going to be the best version,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17313-1
02:10:18.423 --> 02:10:21.876
hopefully of all the lessons learned from
states so far.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17339-0
02:10:23.366 --> 02:10:26.127
But with that being said,
I don't think there's a state necessarily
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17339-1
02:10:26.127 --> 02:10:28.726
that is totally hit the nail on this from
redwoods perspective.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17381-0
02:10:29.716 --> 02:10:32.611
I will say as well that the Recycled
Materials Association,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17381-1
02:10:32.611 --> 02:10:36.470
the Trade Association, were a part of.
I don't believe they're here on the call
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17381-2
02:10:36.470 --> 02:10:39.268
today and I'll encourage them to attend
the next meeting.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17381-3
02:10:39.268 --> 02:10:42.596
But they do have their own model
legislation for portable and medium
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17381-4
02:10:42.596 --> 02:10:43.416
format battery E.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17383-0
02:10:43.406 --> 02:10:43.676
As well.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17391-0
02:10:45.286 --> 02:10:49.286
And the last thing I will say here.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17411-0
02:10:51.206 --> 02:10:56.990
Was noting once more that Colorado and
Illinois have those forfeiture provisions
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17411-1
02:10:56.990 --> 02:10:58.846
that we do not agree with.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17421-0
02:10:59.156 --> 02:11:02.436
And don't eat in a in a more fruitful
program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17429-0
02:11:03.036 --> 02:11:05.218
But yeah,
we look forward to being a partner with
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17429-1
02:11:05.218 --> 02:11:05.916
you all on this.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17434-0
02:11:09.636 --> 02:11:09.916
Katie.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17441-0
02:11:11.656 --> 02:11:14.016
Yeah, I know.
I've kind of stated this before.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17462-0
02:11:14.246 --> 02:11:19.202
So we have 24 states here in the US,
plus the District of Columbia that have
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17462-1
02:11:19.202 --> 02:11:22.806
electronics EPR programs,
including the state of Maine.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17488-0
02:11:24.456 --> 02:11:27.485
There is only one state with a law on
battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17488-1
02:11:27.485 --> 02:11:31.867
Embedded products is like its own
category and that is the state of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17488-2
02:11:31.867 --> 02:11:32.576
California.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17511-0
02:11:32.616 --> 02:11:35.156
Again,
that's the fee charged to consumers that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17511-1
02:11:35.156 --> 02:11:39.179
will fund the collection and recycling
system for battery embedded products
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17511-2
02:11:39.179 --> 02:11:42.407
there in California.
And that program officially launches on
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17511-3
02:11:42.407 --> 02:11:42.936
January 1.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17543-0
02:11:43.606 --> 02:11:47.997
Right now I think what is actually
happening is a broader conversation at a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17543-1
02:11:47.997 --> 02:11:52.446
lot of different levels around the best
system for handling battery embedded
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17543-2
02:11:52.446 --> 02:11:52.966
products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17548-0
02:11:53.006 --> 02:11:56.126
Those conversations are happening among
industry groups.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17556-0
02:11:56.126 --> 02:11:57.806
They're happening with the US EPA.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17563-0
02:11:58.726 --> 02:12:00.926
They're happening with the state of
Minnesota.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17568-0
02:12:01.566 --> 02:12:04.766
So again,
it's an evolving discussion there.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17582-0
02:12:04.766 --> 02:12:09.486
I don't anyone has an answer right now on
what the best path forward is.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17595-0
02:12:10.216 --> 02:12:12.776
More stakeholder dialogue kind of
understanding the complexity.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17613-0
02:12:13.126 --> 02:12:17.315
City around the broad scope of what is
battery, embedded products,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17613-1
02:12:17.315 --> 02:12:19.566
and the complexity that that brings.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17618-0
02:12:19.806 --> 02:12:22.006
So I just want to provide that background
info.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17620-0
02:12:24.446 --> 02:12:24.606
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17622-0
02:12:24.886 --> 02:12:25.686
Thank you, Katie.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17624-0
02:12:27.886 --> 02:12:28.766
And mark?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17632-0
02:12:32.446 --> 02:12:34.166
Sorry, I had myself double muted there.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17640-0
02:12:34.166 --> 02:12:36.846
I'm not even sure how I did that,
and I apparently raised my hand twice.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17666-0
02:12:37.846 --> 02:12:41.900
I just wanted to address,
you know that we were the comment about
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17666-1
02:12:41.900 --> 02:12:46.875
you know where the materials go and who
who gets the materials or the forfeiture
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17666-2
02:12:46.875 --> 02:12:47.366
comment.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17670-0
02:12:47.766 --> 02:12:49.846
So in the in the states.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17677-0
02:12:49.846 --> 02:12:51.286
So I'll start with the model build.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17699-0
02:12:51.286 --> 02:12:55.960
The model build does not exclude having
multiple stewardship organizations.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17699-1
02:12:55.960 --> 02:12:59.036
However,
what it does do is that it requires that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17699-2
02:12:59.036 --> 02:13:01.926
in order to collect batteries,
you have to be.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17707-0
02:13:02.046 --> 02:13:05.166
Be a an approved plan in the state.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17708-0
02:13:05.326 --> 02:13:05.886
So what?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17720-0
02:13:05.886 --> 02:13:10.301
That does it prevents other organizations
from coming in and just doing whatever
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17720-1
02:13:10.301 --> 02:13:10.846
they want.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17744-0
02:13:11.366 --> 02:13:14.453
So a stewardship,
organization or organizations has to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17744-1
02:13:14.453 --> 02:13:17.372
submit a plan,
and then that has to be approved and
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17744-2
02:13:17.372 --> 02:13:20.964
overseen by the state,
both from the initial plan and then with
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17744-3
02:13:20.964 --> 02:13:21.806
annual reports.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17761-0
02:13:22.006 --> 02:13:24.957
So if anybody else can come in and do
something,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17761-1
02:13:24.957 --> 02:13:27.246
then there's no state oversight on it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17770-0
02:13:28.016 --> 02:13:30.096
Another part of that is with the plan.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17774-0
02:13:30.416 --> 02:13:32.096
The plan has to submit.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17810-0
02:13:32.526 --> 02:13:36.635
Metrics on how that plan will perform
year on year and in order for a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17810-1
02:13:36.635 --> 02:13:39.217
stewardship,
organization or organizations.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17810-2
02:13:39.217 --> 02:13:43.972
I'll keep saying that in the plural sense
in order for them to be able to report
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17810-3
02:13:43.972 --> 02:13:48.256
what batteries are coming back in and
being able to report to the state.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17831-0
02:13:48.366 --> 02:13:52.263
They need to know what the batteries are
that are actually being recovered,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17831-1
02:13:52.263 --> 02:13:54.006
so that is part of that provision.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17850-0
02:13:54.046 --> 02:13:58.936
So that's the reason why it's saying it's
like the stewardship organization has to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17850-1
02:13:58.936 --> 02:14:00.526
know what the numerator is.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17853-0
02:14:01.256 --> 02:14:01.576
On the batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17881-0
02:14:01.926 --> 02:14:05.564
Being collected versus the denominator of
the batteries that are placed on the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17881-1
02:14:05.564 --> 02:14:08.741
market and unless they do,
the number with a being being reported is
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17881-2
02:14:08.741 --> 02:14:09.846
essentially meaningless.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17888-0
02:14:16.566 --> 02:14:19.326
Yeah, that's my choice. That's yeah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17892-0
02:14:19.326 --> 02:14:19.766
Thanks mark.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17911-0
02:14:19.766 --> 02:14:22.920
I mean,
that's kind of similar with bottle
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17911-1
02:14:22.920 --> 02:14:28.126
redemption just determining redemption
rates being a redemption state.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17913-0
02:14:32.236 --> 02:14:33.396
Ashley.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17916-0
02:14:34.996 --> 02:14:35.636
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17923-0
02:14:37.536 --> 02:14:38.176
And thank you, Mark.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17928-0
02:14:38.176 --> 02:14:40.656
I know we talk about this frequently, so.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17960-0
02:14:42.656 --> 02:14:47.776
The the one thing I wanted to add on to
that is that reminder again that you know
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17960-1
02:14:47.776 --> 02:14:51.834
organizations like ours,
businesses like ours have no issue with
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17960-2
02:14:51.834 --> 02:14:54.456
reporting data on what has been collected.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17983-0
02:14:54.536 --> 02:14:59.822
I think the the the intention of that
provision and not just allowing anybody
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17983-1
02:14:59.822 --> 02:15:04.972
to be able to collect and not having
oversight and transparency into what's
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/17983-2
02:15:04.972 --> 02:15:06.056
being collected.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18008-0
02:15:06.406 --> 02:15:09.994
It is is valid,
but it it falls short in that it
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18008-1
02:15:09.994 --> 02:15:15.560
shortsighted in that it's cutting out
recyclers that are already doing this
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18008-2
02:15:15.560 --> 02:15:15.926
work.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18018-0
02:15:17.536 --> 02:15:19.376
And you know,
we're qualified to do this work.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18050-0
02:15:19.376 --> 02:15:24.426
So whether it's just specifically stating
that recyclers can collect and are not
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18050-1
02:15:24.426 --> 02:15:28.415
having to act as a battery stewardship
organization themselves,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18050-2
02:15:28.415 --> 02:15:33.590
but are just doing the work they already
do day-to-day is kind of what we're we're
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18050-3
02:15:33.590 --> 02:15:35.896
looking after, so totally understand.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18082-0
02:15:36.206 --> 02:15:39.429
And the want for protection and
transparency and data,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18082-1
02:15:39.429 --> 02:15:44.118
and we're definitely willing to give that
as is others that we work with in the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18082-2
02:15:44.118 --> 02:15:46.286
recycled Materials Trade Association.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18086-0
02:15:46.286 --> 02:15:48.926
But yeah, it's unfortunately just.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18127-0
02:15:50.416 --> 02:15:53.807
Has been written in a way that makes it
very difficult and and for us moving
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18127-1
02:15:53.807 --> 02:15:56.052
forward,
like we're not going to be able to do our
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18127-2
02:15:56.052 --> 02:15:59.399
events and we can't have our bins in
Colorado or Illinois with the way that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18127-3
02:15:59.399 --> 02:16:00.896
those legislation are are written.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18129-0
02:16:08.686 --> 02:16:08.806
Yes.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18133-0
02:16:09.806 --> 02:16:10.966
Thank you, Ashley.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18138-0
02:16:14.926 --> 02:16:18.006
Anyone else on this subject?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18146-0
02:16:18.726 --> 02:16:21.006
Just so you know,
we're at our 45 minute mark.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18183-0
02:16:21.046 --> 02:16:24.405
Yeah, I'm actually.
So I've kind of I think most of the I've
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18183-1
02:16:24.405 --> 02:16:28.479
kind of hit most of the topics,
some of the questions kind of I didn't go
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18183-2
02:16:28.479 --> 02:16:30.406
to, I didn't ask all the questions.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18190-0
02:16:30.406 --> 02:16:33.046
We've kind of posed because I think some
of them had been answered.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18204-0
02:16:33.886 --> 02:16:39.406
So I think I'm think I'm gonna just go to
the freer and the free free form.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18211-0
02:16:40.256 --> 02:16:44.016
Section for the free roaming part of the
the meeting.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18226-0
02:16:44.206 --> 02:16:52.372
And does anyone have anything they wish
to bring up that hasn't been brought up
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18226-1
02:16:52.372 --> 02:16:53.086
so far?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18238-0
02:16:57.906 --> 02:17:01.345
For revisiting any other topics that
we've already spoke about, yeah,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18238-1
02:17:01.345 --> 02:17:02.426
our revisiting topics.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18243-0
02:17:07.426 --> 02:17:08.266
From the Roo.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18245-0
02:17:09.776 --> 02:17:09.856
Ft.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18251-0
02:17:11.976 --> 02:17:19.976
OPS held to,
but like when you and I talked, Brian.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18299-0
02:17:21.616 --> 02:17:25.721
The expectation that I felt our group
gave to the environment and Natural
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18299-1
02:17:25.721 --> 02:17:29.937
Resources Committee that we would come
into their next session with not all
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18299-2
02:17:29.937 --> 02:17:33.542
their problems solved,
but good information that they could make
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18299-3
02:17:33.542 --> 02:17:37.536
progress on stewardship program specific
to electronic smoking devices.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18311-0
02:17:38.606 --> 02:17:41.646
And so that's like a commitment I feel
I've made.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18345-0
02:17:41.646 --> 02:17:47.234
I want to do it alongside industry and
the state and I just want to know like
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18345-1
02:17:47.234 --> 02:17:51.103
how that maybe fits within this general
conversation.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18345-2
02:17:51.103 --> 02:17:56.620
Your pathway forward for the upcoming
session and actually honestly now with
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18345-3
02:17:56.620 --> 02:17:57.766
even more input.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18362-0
02:17:57.806 --> 02:18:03.886
The reasonableness of what I had thought
might be a good potential getting some
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18362-1
02:18:03.886 --> 02:18:06.166
progress in this next session.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18366-0
02:18:06.896 --> 02:18:07.536
And I'm just like.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18389-0
02:18:08.556 --> 02:18:13.835
I'm curious if you also feel this is a
complex enough to where how do we
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18389-1
02:18:13.835 --> 02:18:17.956
approach the legislature in a successful
way? How do we?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18396-0
02:18:19.536 --> 02:18:20.496
What's the pathway look like?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18418-0
02:18:20.496 --> 02:18:23.975
Well,
my pathway looks to we're going to take
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18418-1
02:18:23.975 --> 02:18:30.024
what we've heard today and comments that
people submitted and I am committed to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18418-2
02:18:30.024 --> 02:18:30.856
putting in.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18421-0
02:18:34.176 --> 02:18:34.216
A.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18428-0
02:18:34.496 --> 02:18:37.376
A draft conceptual bill for battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18430-0
02:18:37.766 --> 02:18:38.406
Please.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18432-0
02:18:42.006 --> 02:18:42.886
For batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18444-0
02:18:44.416 --> 02:18:49.456
In this year's product stewardship report
for the legislature to consider.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18453-0
02:18:51.176 --> 02:18:53.976
And that's gonna be for batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18455-0
02:18:54.056 --> 02:18:55.856
I don't see.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18459-0
02:18:59.246 --> 02:19:00.606
I really don't see.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18464-0
02:19:03.056 --> 02:19:04.576
It'll it'll address.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18498-0
02:19:06.616 --> 02:19:10.090
And I'll say it'll address embedded
batteries,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18498-1
02:19:10.090 --> 02:19:16.002
including Bay pens and A and a fashion
that I'm not quite sure how it will work
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18498-2
02:19:16.002 --> 02:19:18.736
yet, because I do say there is still.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18504-0
02:19:19.856 --> 02:19:21.256
I can't remember the number.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18518-0
02:19:21.296 --> 02:19:27.376
LD whatever there is still the product
keyword ship Bill sitting on the 15191519.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18523-0
02:19:27.376 --> 02:19:27.896
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18527-0
02:19:27.896 --> 02:19:30.856
That was tabled until the next session so.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18532-0
02:19:31.776 --> 02:19:32.776
Yeah, Senator Ben Stiller.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18536-0
02:19:33.246 --> 02:19:34.206
Yeah, yeah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18574-0
02:19:34.646 --> 02:19:38.461
And we had talked like it's hard to,
I think I could interpret how Senator
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18574-1
02:19:38.461 --> 02:19:42.582
Bennett and representative Graham like
left their bills and what the intent was.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18574-2
02:19:42.582 --> 02:19:45.939
And I think that you could reasonably
interpret that differently.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18574-3
02:19:45.939 --> 02:19:48.686
I think kind of we discussed they left us
in a funny.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18589-0
02:19:48.686 --> 02:19:51.665
Spot where there's two bills don't
compete with each other,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18589-1
02:19:51.665 --> 02:19:53.006
but they don't necessarily.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18606-0
02:19:54.456 --> 02:19:59.972
Support each other fully well, I think.
I mean and and I could be remembering
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18606-1
02:19:59.972 --> 02:20:02.376
this wrong, but I believe Bennett.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18615-0
02:20:02.846 --> 02:20:07.766
Spill with vapes was more specific to
banning disposables.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18623-0
02:20:08.086 --> 02:20:13.406
And not actually and then and then
evaluating.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18626-0
02:20:17.236 --> 02:20:18.716
Evaluating.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18649-0
02:20:20.256 --> 02:20:26.316
Including other non covered batteries and
maybe battery devices into the current
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18649-1
02:20:26.316 --> 02:20:28.336
interpretable thing, right?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18662-0
02:20:28.336 --> 02:20:32.869
So, so again,
that's what I'm I'm I'm saying to myself,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18662-1
02:20:32.869 --> 02:20:35.216
I'm saying my thinking is we.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18682-0
02:20:37.416 --> 02:20:45.234
Grammix bill is there and tabled and I'm
concentrating on the battery portion of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18682-1
02:20:45.234 --> 02:20:46.296
Demix bill.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18687-0
02:20:49.836 --> 02:20:52.756
That's my goal.
What I'm working on right now.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18728-0
02:20:53.806 --> 02:20:58.615
Yes, for for this.
Basically what we're just trying to do is
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18728-1
02:20:58.615 --> 02:21:05.158
we are trying to revamp our battery bill
to encompass more different chemicals and
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18728-2
02:21:05.158 --> 02:21:08.942
varieties of batteries.
And before we give our,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18728-3
02:21:08.942 --> 02:21:12.726
it's not quite great,
but it's our rough draft.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18732-0
02:21:14.376 --> 02:21:14.896
Yeah, right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18745-0
02:21:14.896 --> 02:21:16.809
Right.
We're we're trying to come up with what
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18745-1
02:21:16.809 --> 02:21:19.616
we believe from holding these stakeholder
sessions is the desire to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18748-0
02:21:22.246 --> 02:21:24.966
To to include.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18760-0
02:21:28.036 --> 02:21:33.676
Batteries into the current program and I
support you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18768-0
02:21:33.676 --> 02:21:34.756
That's what. That's what we're doing.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18798-0
02:21:34.876 --> 02:21:39.398
So without prohibiting items that we can
find a way to dispose of them and that's
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18798-1
02:21:39.398 --> 02:21:43.533
why we're having these conversations,
because we need to hear and maybe my
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18798-2
02:21:43.533 --> 02:21:48.110
thing was in like you all need to go back
and talk about how do we feel about this
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18798-3
02:21:48.110 --> 02:21:48.716
before you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18821-0
02:21:48.716 --> 02:21:54.195
Can say this is our next step,
but I just I trying to understand how our
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18821-1
02:21:54.195 --> 02:21:56.896
next step in this narrower industry.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18839-0
02:21:58.086 --> 02:22:02.787
Fits alongside you all 'cause I. Again,
we want to be partners with with you all
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18839-1
02:22:02.787 --> 02:22:04.006
through this process.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18852-0
02:22:04.006 --> 02:22:10.479
Also stated that it's flowing through,
so it's kind of also the target of the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18852-1
02:22:10.479 --> 02:22:11.806
entire bill. OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18862-0
02:22:11.806 --> 02:22:14.846
So I think it's important to stop what
the battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18879-0
02:22:17.616 --> 02:22:21.976
Is like when I use the term low hanging
fruit and I'm I'm sorry, I may have been.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18884-0
02:22:22.096 --> 02:22:23.936
I may have misspoke.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18889-0
02:22:23.936 --> 02:22:25.816
I was talking about batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18898-0
02:22:26.446 --> 02:22:28.286
OK, I was not talking about vapes.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18912-0
02:22:28.286 --> 02:22:33.901
I was talking about rechargeable and
primary disposable that that to me was
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18912-1
02:22:33.901 --> 02:22:35.526
the low hanging fruit.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18924-0
02:22:36.366 --> 02:22:39.486
Yeah. And so your bill,
this would be a new bill.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18931-0
02:22:39.486 --> 02:22:43.006
This wouldn't be 7 LD 750.
This would be new.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18952-0
02:22:43.166 --> 02:22:46.861
Yeah,
this is under your authority would
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18952-1
02:22:46.861 --> 02:22:51.366
basically be a repeal and replace of the
battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18956-0
02:22:52.726 --> 02:22:54.806
13th whenever the battery.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18966-0
02:22:56.296 --> 02:22:58.586
Ryan,
are you looking to file that before your
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18966-1
02:22:58.586 --> 02:22:58.976
closure?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18978-0
02:22:58.976 --> 02:23:00.616
I mean,
you must have to get back to the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18978-1
02:23:00.616 --> 02:23:01.496
governor's office now.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18984-0
02:23:01.496 --> 02:23:03.576
There's no cloture we're already
clutching.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18988-0
02:23:03.576 --> 02:23:05.136
No, we agencies.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/18997-0
02:23:05.136 --> 02:23:06.896
You have to get your stuff to the
governor's office.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19004-0
02:23:06.896 --> 02:23:09.772
We,
the product ownership program we this
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19004-1
02:23:09.772 --> 02:23:10.936
month we can put.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19020-0
02:23:12.696 --> 02:23:17.609
Language for proposed bill into our
annual report and then comes out like mid
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19020-1
02:23:17.609 --> 02:23:18.176
February.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19021-0
02:23:18.176 --> 02:23:19.256
Yeah, comes out.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19026-0
02:23:19.256 --> 02:23:21.675
Well,
we put it out for public comment in
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19026-1
02:23:21.675 --> 02:23:22.136
January.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19037-0
02:23:22.726 --> 02:23:27.566
And then and then it's in February and
they can.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19058-0
02:23:27.686 --> 02:23:32.744
And then if we propose a language for a
bill, they can elect to take it,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19058-1
02:23:32.744 --> 02:23:35.446
that would probably likely be the next.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19069-0
02:23:35.446 --> 02:23:39.206
I mean it's a short session.
I can't imagine them taking. I can't.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19073-0
02:23:39.366 --> 02:23:40.646
That's up to them.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19086-0
02:23:40.646 --> 02:23:43.646
OK, that's up to.
But you're not putting in an agency bill?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19095-0
02:23:43.646 --> 02:23:47.966
We are not putting in an agency bill,
but we are doing it's reporting out.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19098-0
02:23:48.776 --> 02:23:49.576
A draft language.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19100-0
02:23:51.496 --> 02:23:51.936
For.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19111-0
02:23:52.606 --> 02:23:57.446
The battery program in the products to
ensure report and are you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19126-0
02:23:57.726 --> 02:24:00.916
This might be too far down the road,
but you have you have a couple lobbyists
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19126-1
02:24:00.916 --> 02:24:01.406
in the room.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19132-0
02:24:01.406 --> 02:24:03.086
We're gonna ask you questions on this one,
sure.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19137-0
02:24:03.086 --> 02:24:04.886
Are you looking to use 'cause?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19144-0
02:24:04.886 --> 02:24:07.775
Obviously,
Senator Bennett's bill is a potential
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19144-1
02:24:07.775 --> 02:24:08.246
vehicle.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19152-0
02:24:08.246 --> 02:24:10.406
It's sitting in that committee as a
carryover.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19153-0
02:24:10.406 --> 02:24:11.406
It is.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19157-0
02:24:11.486 --> 02:24:14.046
Do you anticipate were you?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19173-0
02:24:15.936 --> 02:24:18.907
I did a job as an agency person for a
dozen years,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19173-1
02:24:18.907 --> 02:24:21.296
so sometimes the committee would ask you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19181-0
02:24:21.726 --> 02:24:24.526
Even if you opposed a bill,
go work this out.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19201-0
02:24:24.526 --> 02:24:27.998
Come back to us, you know,
in the short session with some level of
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19201-1
02:24:27.998 --> 02:24:32.246
solution were you guys tasked to do that
at all? Like is this an element of that?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19206-0
02:24:32.246 --> 02:24:36.366
No. We were tasked to to come up with.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19231-0
02:24:37.936 --> 02:24:45.779
A proposal for I will call it looking at
adding additional battery products to the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19231-1
02:24:45.779 --> 02:24:49.936
product to the current battery program.
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19236-0
02:24:50.806 --> 02:24:52.286
And we've got some up here.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19238-0
02:24:52.286 --> 02:24:53.326
Ashley, go ahead.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19252-0
02:24:55.356 --> 02:24:57.916
I think you said it before,
but I just wanted to triple check.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19274-0
02:24:57.916 --> 02:25:01.600
Are you all leaning towards or just
thinking about umm uh?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19274-1
02:25:01.600 --> 02:25:06.532
A battery program for portable in medium
format batteries and not large format
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19274-2
02:25:06.532 --> 02:25:07.156
batteries?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19278-0
02:25:07.156 --> 02:25:08.116
Is that what I'm hearing?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19287-0
02:25:09.256 --> 02:25:12.776
I think we're still evaluating that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19293-0
02:25:13.466 --> 02:25:13.826
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19298-0
02:25:14.256 --> 02:25:15.856
That's what we're looking for comments on.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19301-0
02:25:16.846 --> 02:25:17.286
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19305-0
02:25:17.406 --> 02:25:18.006
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19306-0
02:25:17.576 --> 02:25:18.656
So all right, Sarah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19311-0
02:25:21.936 --> 02:25:23.416
Hi, good afternoon everybody.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19314-0
02:25:23.456 --> 02:25:24.816
Thank you for hosting this meeting.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19323-0
02:25:26.296 --> 02:25:27.136
It's really interesting.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19336-0
02:25:27.256 --> 02:25:33.896
I just wanted to chime in and clear up
questions about Senator Bennett's bill.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19351-0
02:25:33.976 --> 02:25:41.393
I'm actually here because he had asked me
to help develop the language for that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19351-1
02:25:41.393 --> 02:25:41.856
bill.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19375-0
02:25:42.256 --> 02:25:45.622
It was carried over and without a public
hearing,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19375-1
02:25:45.622 --> 02:25:51.008
and he had asked the committee to do that,
so we had time to to work to develop
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19375-2
02:25:51.008 --> 02:25:51.816
legislation.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19401-0
02:25:52.726 --> 02:25:56.855
And a lot of the reason for that was
after our visit with the Vapors
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19401-1
02:25:56.855 --> 02:26:00.206
Association and those fine gentlemen in
the room there.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19408-0
02:26:01.126 --> 02:26:04.326
He didn't want to move forward with his
bill as written, so.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19447-0
02:26:06.496 --> 02:26:09.640
I yeah.
I just wanted people to know that that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19447-1
02:26:09.640 --> 02:26:15.057
was his plan and I will report back to
him about this effort and I'm not sure if
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19447-2
02:26:15.057 --> 02:26:20.608
he'll want to just defer to the language
that the department intends to put in the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19447-3
02:26:20.608 --> 02:26:23.016
product storage ship report or appe.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19452-0
02:26:23.016 --> 02:26:24.016
He'll still want to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19458-0
02:26:25.086 --> 02:26:27.566
Put in his own language, but.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19460-0
02:26:28.886 --> 02:26:29.966
But I let everybody know.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19489-0
02:26:31.206 --> 02:26:37.056
Sarah, I get so did I. Will you,
would you say I was I correct or
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19489-1
02:26:37.056 --> 02:26:43.881
incorrect in my kind of understanding of
that were we were more specifically
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19489-2
02:26:43.881 --> 02:26:46.806
tasked with basically evaluating.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19502-0
02:26:48.256 --> 02:26:54.016
Additional battery products for our
stewardship program that exists.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19511-0
02:26:55.476 --> 02:26:57.596
Yeah, I think that was that section.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19521-0
02:26:57.596 --> 02:27:02.676
Second part of his bill is what you're
doing, but you know that wasn't passed.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19535-0
02:27:02.676 --> 02:27:05.660
That was just,
I think it maybe would have if you all
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19535-1
02:27:05.660 --> 02:27:09.196
hadn't said that you were going to be
doing it anyway, I guess.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19589-0
02:27:09.716 --> 02:27:13.464
Right.
And there was the 1st and the first part
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19540-0
02:27:10.656 --> 02:27:10.896
Right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19589-1
02:27:13.464 --> 02:27:16.899
of the,
the one that was specific to vapes,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19589-2
02:27:16.899 --> 02:27:23.380
that was a that was a ban on disposables,
non rechargeable single use, single use,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19589-3
02:27:23.380 --> 02:27:28.767
enlarged Miss Nichols said.
He said he could not support the bill as
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19582-0
02:27:23.766 --> 02:27:24.566
Yeah. Yep.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19589-4
02:27:28.767 --> 02:27:30.016
written when we.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19594-0
02:27:30.016 --> 02:27:30.596
Actually heard it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19614-0
02:27:30.596 --> 02:27:34.178
So my understanding,
Senator Bennett in no way supported what
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19614-1
02:27:34.178 --> 02:27:36.836
he had proposed in that first section,
right?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19618-0
02:27:36.836 --> 02:27:37.716
So that's right then.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19620-0
02:27:37.716 --> 02:27:39.156
That's why we're building on.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19650-0
02:27:39.606 --> 02:27:43.533
Concession,
which is up grading and and I'm hoping to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19650-1
02:27:43.533 --> 02:27:49.460
I'm I'm hoping to that's my understanding
and I'm hoping that Sarah is saying that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19650-2
02:27:49.460 --> 02:27:54.886
that was a correct understanding and I
didn't misinterpret Senator Bennett.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19658-0
02:27:56.046 --> 02:27:57.646
No, I think you guys are are right on it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19676-0
02:27:57.646 --> 02:27:59.878
It's really great that you're you're
doing all this,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19676-1
02:27:59.878 --> 02:28:03.078
because I certainly don't wanna be
hosting these meetings and figuring this
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19676-2
02:28:03.078 --> 02:28:03.246
out.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19681-0
02:28:05.216 --> 02:28:06.736
For him. So this is great.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19682-0
02:28:07.596 --> 02:28:07.956
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19684-0
02:28:11.306 --> 02:28:11.746
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19686-0
02:28:11.746 --> 02:28:12.506
Thank you, Sarah.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19698-0
02:28:15.036 --> 02:28:20.236
So it sounds like that's a live bill that
might include your draft.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19708-0
02:28:21.736 --> 02:28:25.609
And be in front of the committee in
January in January or it might not.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19708-1
02:28:25.609 --> 02:28:26.416
It's quite not.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19713-0
02:28:26.416 --> 02:28:29.136
Yeah, yeah, that's or maybe not.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19714-0
02:28:29.136 --> 02:28:30.056
Or maybe not.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19722-0
02:28:30.336 --> 02:28:35.096
So we are very in a rough draft right now.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19742-0
02:28:36.856 --> 02:28:42.216
We will have something in our product
stewardship report in January in January
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19742-1
02:28:42.216 --> 02:28:45.336
and what happens to it at that point of
time.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19744-0
02:28:45.846 --> 02:28:46.606
It's up to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19780-0
02:28:48.296 --> 02:28:52.700
The ENR committee and or senator,
but I think just to be just to clarify,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19780-1
02:28:52.700 --> 02:28:57.282
I think Senator Bennett did want a
pathway forward for those disposable base
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19780-2
02:28:57.282 --> 02:29:00.376
like to try to figure out a solution to
be able to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19795-0
02:29:02.856 --> 02:29:07.698
Recycle them with this program,
along with other batteries and I don't
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19795-1
02:29:07.698 --> 02:29:10.016
think his mission was prohibition.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19801-0
02:29:10.016 --> 02:29:12.536
He wasn't trying to prohibit these
products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19805-0
02:29:14.216 --> 02:29:15.176
Maybe the single use ones?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19826-0
02:29:15.406 --> 02:29:19.901
At first, and then once he realized,
kind of like the different nuances
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19826-1
02:29:19.901 --> 02:29:24.646
between the cannabis industry and the
tobacco industry, he kind of changed.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19845-0
02:29:25.486 --> 02:29:27.833
It's yeah,
and wanted to try to figure out a
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19845-1
02:29:27.833 --> 02:29:32.006
solution to be able to recycle these
products along with other products, right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19848-0
02:29:32.006 --> 02:29:33.526
I think I got that right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19850-0
02:29:33.526 --> 02:29:33.886
Is that right, Sarah?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19858-0
02:29:35.746 --> 02:29:38.466
Yeah,
I think that was his general take is that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19868-0
02:29:40.056 --> 02:29:43.616
There were.
So he had been contacted by a constituent.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19873-0
02:29:43.736 --> 02:29:45.456
People are having a hard time getting
insurance.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19882-0
02:29:45.456 --> 02:29:49.536
There were fires and it's really it was
really this risk of fires and.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19898-0
02:29:51.376 --> 02:29:56.161
I think he quickly learned that it really
wasn't just the vapes that were causing
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19898-1
02:29:56.161 --> 02:29:56.336
it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19912-0
02:29:56.336 --> 02:30:00.008
It really was a bigger,
larger issue and we have these other laws
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19912-1
02:30:00.008 --> 02:30:02.456
that really got complicated really
quickly.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19916-0
02:30:02.976 --> 02:30:04.456
So yeah, I think the idea was to not.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19922-0
02:30:05.006 --> 02:30:08.246
Single out vapes as the only problem.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19932-0
02:30:08.246 --> 02:30:11.117
And then of course,
we have the requirements here and a kind
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19932-1
02:30:11.117 --> 02:30:12.246
of a crazy busy session.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19942-0
02:30:12.246 --> 02:30:16.046
So I think that's that's kind of why we
kicked it to such a big issue.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19945-0
02:30:17.566 --> 02:30:18.526
OK, OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19973-0
02:30:18.526 --> 02:30:21.548
And again, just to clarify,
I want to make sure I'm clear.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19973-1
02:30:21.548 --> 02:30:25.390
When I use the term low hanging fruit I
was talking about the rechargeable
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19973-2
02:30:25.390 --> 02:30:26.926
batteries and those batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19992-0
02:30:26.926 --> 02:30:31.112
I was not talking about. No,
I was not talking about any embedded
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/19992-1
02:30:31.112 --> 02:30:34.726
embedded device because I know that's not
a low hanging.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20003-0
02:30:34.806 --> 02:30:39.631
I do that OK and just because we are
traveling a little bit,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20003-1
02:30:39.631 --> 02:30:41.846
we're sticking to batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20009-0
02:30:42.446 --> 02:30:42.646
Mm-hmm.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20014-0
02:30:42.656 --> 02:30:45.016
This is not necessarily just a vape
conversation right now.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20017-0
02:30:45.016 --> 02:30:46.576
We were trying to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20048-0
02:30:47.486 --> 02:30:53.712
This is a battery conversation with like
with embedded devices,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20048-1
02:30:53.712 --> 02:30:59.646
embedded battery voices is part of it
which include devices.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20050-0
02:30:59.646 --> 02:31:02.406
Yes, let's get Katie real quick.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20076-0
02:31:04.256 --> 02:31:06.925
Thanks.
I I feel like I'm hearing different
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20076-1
02:31:06.925 --> 02:31:11.776
things that could just be because I'm
online, but I want to kind of understand.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20092-0
02:31:11.776 --> 02:31:17.640
So as DEP is thinking about this,
it sounds like your recommendations or
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20092-1
02:31:17.640 --> 02:31:21.576
what may be included in the report will
address.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20094-0
02:31:22.046 --> 02:31:23.926
Loose batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20114-0
02:31:25.456 --> 02:31:31.257
But not battery embedded products.
Am I hearing that correct because of the
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20114-1
02:31:31.257 --> 02:31:32.096
complexity?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20118-0
02:31:31.766 --> 02:31:33.406
I think you're no.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20127-0
02:31:33.406 --> 02:31:37.326
I think what you're saying will still we
will still address.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20120-0
02:31:33.816 --> 02:31:33.976
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20132-0
02:31:38.736 --> 02:31:39.536
We're still looking for it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20151-0
02:31:39.696 --> 02:31:42.618
Let me put it this way.
We we will impress embedded batteries in
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20151-1
02:31:42.618 --> 02:31:43.696
some way, shape or form.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20156-0
02:31:43.696 --> 02:31:45.656
We don't know what that'll look like yet.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20166-0
02:31:45.656 --> 02:31:49.696
That could look like we need to do
further evaluation.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20173-0
02:31:49.696 --> 02:31:51.696
We look may look like we need to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20192-0
02:31:51.816 --> 02:31:56.907
We would like to include both,
but right now now we're we're still in
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20192-1
02:31:56.907 --> 02:32:00.253
the honestly,
we're still in the stakeholder.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20192-2
02:32:00.253 --> 02:32:01.416
Provide us with.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20198-0
02:32:01.766 --> 02:32:07.126
With your input and we will have an
unstable.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20238-0
02:32:08.506 --> 02:32:11.390
OK,
so more that battery embedded products
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20210-0
02:32:08.536 --> 02:32:10.696
OK. In the room. Oops. Sorry.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20238-1
02:32:11.390 --> 02:32:16.821
will be part of kind of the report out,
but it could be anything from we need an
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20238-2
02:32:16.821 --> 02:32:19.906
EPR system for all battery embedded
products.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20243-0
02:32:19.906 --> 02:32:21.146
And here's the language.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20251-0
02:32:21.186 --> 02:32:25.426
Or it's a. This issue is complex.
We need to look into it further.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20254-0
02:32:25.956 --> 02:32:26.956
Further correct.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20260-0
02:32:26.956 --> 02:32:29.276
Yes, correct. Yeah. OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20256-0
02:32:27.336 --> 02:32:27.496
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20264-0
02:32:29.276 --> 02:32:31.076
Let's go one more in the room.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20275-0
02:32:32.536 --> 02:32:36.936
As Reader's Digest as I can and
overlooking certain details.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20323-0
02:32:38.456 --> 02:32:41.623
Those bills,
specifically the one that was for
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20323-1
02:32:41.623 --> 02:32:44.588
electronic smoking devices and
stewardship,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20323-2
02:32:44.588 --> 02:32:48.631
the fiscal impact statement that was
generated around that,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20323-3
02:32:48.631 --> 02:32:53.820
I took some pretty substantive issue with.
And so all I wanna say is I would
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20323-4
02:32:53.820 --> 02:32:55.976
encourage everyone on this call.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20348-0
02:32:56.166 --> 02:33:01.507
And the department or just folks
generally to have as much participation
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20348-1
02:33:01.507 --> 02:33:07.286
in whatever public hearing we have in the
legislative process of this because.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20387-0
02:33:08.776 --> 02:33:14.568
The big take away was it was a pretty
constrained conversation that happened in
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20387-1
02:33:14.568 --> 02:33:19.998
the committee and that's what they build
their fiscal impact statement on.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20387-2
02:33:19.998 --> 02:33:23.762
And so knowing what the impacts,
real or perceived,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20387-3
02:33:23.762 --> 02:33:26.296
that everyone related to batteries.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20436-0
02:33:27.156 --> 02:33:30.643
Could have is gonna be good information
for us to craft.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20436-1
02:33:30.643 --> 02:33:35.537
I think a fiscal impact statement that is
actually reflective of the issue that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20436-2
02:33:35.537 --> 02:33:38.779
we're dealing with 'cause it just my
opinion anyway.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20436-3
02:33:38.779 --> 02:33:43.428
My personal opinion after putting a ton
of time into it was that the fiscal
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20436-4
02:33:43.428 --> 02:33:43.856
impact.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20446-0
02:33:43.856 --> 02:33:50.836
Statement of 1519 did not reflect the
actual fiscal impact to.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20455-0
02:33:52.296 --> 02:33:55.416
A substantive portion of what would
actually be impacted.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20459-0
02:33:55.726 --> 02:33:56.846
That it was not reflected.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20465-0
02:33:56.846 --> 02:33:58.406
I just don't see that again.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20474-0
02:33:58.406 --> 02:34:00.446
Do you think it was too big or too little?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20475-0
02:34:00.526 --> 02:34:02.366
Wildly miscalculated.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20488-0
02:34:02.366 --> 02:34:06.046
Too low?
It never took into account if things
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20488-1
02:34:06.046 --> 02:34:07.486
became prohibited.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20497-0
02:34:07.486 --> 02:34:10.606
And they were then no longer authorized
for sale.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20503-0
02:34:10.646 --> 02:34:14.006
There would be a negative revenue
statement.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20534-0
02:34:14.446 --> 02:34:17.534
Well, I mean, I think the,
I mean the fiscal impact that was
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20534-1
02:34:17.534 --> 02:34:21.482
generated from that was basically how
much would it cost to in the state that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20534-2
02:34:21.482 --> 02:34:22.646
to oversee the program.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20542-0
02:34:22.646 --> 02:34:24.446
But that's not what a fiscal impact
statement is.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20545-0
02:34:24.686 --> 02:34:26.086
Well, that's what.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20551-0
02:34:28.006 --> 02:34:30.486
That's a portion of the fiscal Penn State.
Yeah. OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20553-0
02:34:32.926 --> 02:34:33.086
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20563-0
02:34:38.226 --> 02:34:41.853
Any other thoughts or concerns that
anyone can think about from our
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20563-1
02:34:41.853 --> 02:34:43.346
conversation this afternoon?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20565-0
02:34:48.006 --> 02:34:48.686
All right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20579-0
02:34:49.046 --> 02:34:53.278
Well,
I want to thank everyone for attending.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20579-1
02:34:53.278 --> 02:34:55.486
I thought this was very.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20613-0
02:34:55.766 --> 02:35:03.066
I was a very good flow of information.
We will reach out by the end of the week,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20613-1
02:35:03.066 --> 02:35:10.366
but I think we are leaning towards to
accommodate our fellow state of Minnesota.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20615-0
02:35:10.366 --> 02:35:12.966
We'll probably just move our meeting.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20628-0
02:35:17.866 --> 02:35:22.266
Ahead to be after there,
since theirs is from 1:50.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20639-0
02:35:22.266 --> 02:35:25.626
So we'll probably have ours from 2:30 to
4:30.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20646-0
02:35:25.746 --> 02:35:28.046
Brian,
how do you what do you anticipate for
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20646-1
02:35:28.046 --> 02:35:29.426
that September 4th meeting?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20672-0
02:35:29.426 --> 02:35:33.214
Is it going to be the same thing just for
different group of people that weren't
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20672-1
02:35:33.214 --> 02:35:36.066
able to make this one?
Or is it a sort of stage two of this?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20707-0
02:35:36.066 --> 02:35:39.613
It's gonna be stage two at this meeting,
so it'd be for people who couldn't make
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20707-1
02:35:39.613 --> 02:35:41.671
this.
And actually we'd like if people can get
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20707-2
02:35:41.671 --> 02:35:44.473
us written comments.
We'll take what we got and we've actually,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20707-3
02:35:44.473 --> 02:35:47.056
even though it doesn't look like we
actually had a person.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20717-0
02:35:47.166 --> 02:35:49.526
Who was taking copious notes?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20725-0
02:35:49.606 --> 02:35:53.286
This is gonna be available for people to
watch.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20747-0
02:35:53.286 --> 02:35:59.708
There'll be a transcript of it,
and so we're hoping to actually maybe
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20747-1
02:35:59.708 --> 02:36:04.846
even have, dare I say,
a straw man conceptual proposal.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20761-0
02:36:04.926 --> 02:36:07.656
So well,
if there are questions that you want
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20761-1
02:36:07.656 --> 02:36:12.046
people in the school board the extended
group to contemplate before then.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20768-0
02:36:13.056 --> 02:36:14.096
And fire out some questions.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20770-0
02:36:14.096 --> 02:36:16.216
Questions. Yeah, just as a suggestion.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20774-0
02:36:16.766 --> 02:36:18.846
Yeah, we will. OK, great.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20778-0
02:36:20.816 --> 02:36:22.016
So if you get.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20814-0
02:36:23.816 --> 02:36:29.305
Make pretend it's just a huge flood of
comments from folks asking very
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20814-1
02:36:29.305 --> 02:36:34.948
specifically to have a embedded
integrated battery conversation separate
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20814-2
02:36:34.948 --> 02:36:37.576
from a loose battery conversation.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20817-0
02:36:37.576 --> 02:36:38.576
That's how you're doing it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20834-0
02:36:38.576 --> 02:36:42.220
Straw pulled metrics because we can get
you lots of comments that really
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20834-1
02:36:42.220 --> 02:36:44.416
encourage you have a very specific
meeting.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20837-0
02:36:44.416 --> 02:36:45.496
Or we could ask for it now.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20839-0
02:36:48.646 --> 02:36:48.966
I'm not.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20841-0
02:36:48.966 --> 02:36:50.926
I'm sorry, what did you say?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20867-0
02:36:53.096 --> 02:36:58.532
Would getting in excess of thousands of
comments on this specifically asking for
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20867-1
02:36:58.532 --> 02:37:02.760
an embedded conversation separate from a
regular conversation,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20867-2
02:37:02.760 --> 02:37:05.176
help the department have a separate?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20882-0
02:37:06.976 --> 02:37:12.696
More consumer product integrated device
battery conversation versus not.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20894-0
02:37:12.696 --> 02:37:14.804
Hey,
we'll make it more difficult for us to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20894-1
02:37:14.804 --> 02:37:16.336
get through all of the comments.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20897-0
02:37:16.336 --> 02:37:17.416
So that's what I'm saying.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20901-0
02:37:17.416 --> 02:37:18.936
Or can I just ask for it now?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20912-0
02:37:19.646 --> 02:37:24.686
Now you don't have to wade through 4000
comments asking for it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20915-0
02:37:24.686 --> 02:37:25.566
May I make a suggestion?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20951-0
02:37:25.606 --> 02:37:29.051
Yes, please,
if you have a constituency that has large
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20951-1
02:37:29.051 --> 02:37:32.119
number of them,
perhaps you can all agree on one
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20951-2
02:37:32.119 --> 02:37:37.192
statement and then you can document how
many people support it instead of having
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20951-3
02:37:37.192 --> 02:37:38.006
staff having.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20961-0
02:37:40.096 --> 02:37:42.576
So many of the same letter.
There's only three of us.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20963-0
02:37:42.696 --> 02:37:44.696
So yeah, but you could.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20968-0
02:37:44.696 --> 02:37:46.416
I will give that some consideration.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20969-0
02:37:46.416 --> 02:37:46.976
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20983-0
02:37:49.516 --> 02:37:56.556
Yeah. OK. And all this will be to the DEP.
Battery, e-mail, e-mail, correct.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20987-0
02:37:56.596 --> 02:37:59.716
Yep, 200% OK alright.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20992-0
02:38:01.016 --> 02:38:02.456
Oh, Ashley's got a question.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/20999-0
02:38:03.116 --> 02:38:05.556
Hi I know I had my hand up many times.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21014-0
02:38:05.556 --> 02:38:09.556
Thank you so much again for your time and
this this detailed discussion.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21033-0
02:38:09.636 --> 02:38:13.942
I had a note before that the comments
would be due a week after the September
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21033-1
02:38:13.942 --> 02:38:17.916
4th meeting and I was just a little bit
confused by the last statement.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21036-0
02:38:17.916 --> 02:38:18.756
So should we?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21049-0
02:38:18.796 --> 02:38:22.509
We're encouraged to submit comments as
quick as possible to help inform the next
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21049-1
02:38:22.509 --> 02:38:22.876
meeting.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21062-0
02:38:23.806 --> 02:38:25.853
Yes,
you're encouraged to submit comments from
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21062-1
02:38:25.853 --> 02:38:27.246
the Open Forum for next meeting.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21073-0
02:38:27.246 --> 02:38:33.606
But when we actually start putting,
we're gonna look for the end of comments.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21075-0
02:38:35.056 --> 02:38:35.376
Period.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21079-0
02:38:37.336 --> 02:38:38.016
By that.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21089-0
02:38:38.016 --> 02:38:41.296
After that second week of the last date,
I said earlier.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21092-0
02:38:41.296 --> 02:38:42.056
So we can begin.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21107-0
02:38:42.056 --> 02:38:47.005
So we can begin drafting what we yeah,
so we can begin drafting what we need to
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21107-1
02:38:47.005 --> 02:38:47.376
draft.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21109-0
02:38:48.036 --> 02:38:48.476
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21116-0
02:38:48.476 --> 02:38:50.236
Well,
we want to be as helpful as possible.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21118-0
02:38:49.296 --> 02:38:49.416
Yes.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21130-0
02:38:50.236 --> 02:38:53.236
So we will get ours in as quick as we can.
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21133-0
02:38:52.786 --> 02:38:54.306
Right. Yeah, we really appreciate.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21162-0
02:38:54.306 --> 02:38:57.853
I'll be honest,
having gone through several stakeholder
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21162-1
02:38:57.853 --> 02:39:02.983
sessions and a lot of people wait till
the last minute to submit stuff and be if
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21162-2
02:39:02.983 --> 02:39:07.226
it'd be great if if if folks can get them
in sooner than later so.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21176-0
02:39:09.606 --> 02:39:12.797
So my understanding is that at the next
stakeholder meeting,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21176-1
02:39:12.797 --> 02:39:14.366
you'll have something drafted.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21193-0
02:39:14.366 --> 02:39:17.660
On what you think you would be proposing
to the legislature, well,
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21193-1
02:39:17.660 --> 02:39:19.086
I is that what you're saying?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21206-0
02:39:19.086 --> 02:39:22.062
Yes, a concept.
And that's what kind of the next
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21206-1
02:39:22.062 --> 02:39:24.006
discussion will be about, right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21207-0
02:39:24.006 --> 02:39:25.446
Yeah. OK. OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21220-0
02:39:25.766 --> 02:39:28.447
Optimistically speaking,
optimistic put out like another
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21220-1
02:39:28.447 --> 02:39:29.246
background sheet.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21228-0
02:39:29.486 --> 02:39:31.633
Yeah,
put out by the background sheet so that
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21228-1
02:39:31.633 --> 02:39:32.846
we can prep ahead of time.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21230-0
02:39:32.846 --> 02:39:33.606
Yep, OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21232-0
02:39:35.656 --> 02:39:36.096
Thank you.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21238-0
02:39:36.566 --> 02:39:39.646
Great. Thank you. Thanks. All right,
Katie.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21248-0
02:39:40.966 --> 02:39:43.446
Sorry, I know I've spoken a lot as well.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21258-0
02:39:43.446 --> 02:39:47.006
Thank you for your time today.
Following up on that comment.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21277-0
02:39:47.006 --> 02:39:53.926
So DEP is putting out a sort of draft,
a draft concept or draft proposal.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21292-0
02:39:54.006 --> 02:39:56.423
When do you anticipate that being
available?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21292-1
02:39:56.423 --> 02:39:59.646
And I'm trying to figure out like when do
we comment right?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21311-0
02:39:59.646 --> 02:40:04.686
Do we comment once a draft concept is out
there for us to comment on?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21315-0
02:40:04.256 --> 02:40:04.736
Well, if.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21319-0
02:40:04.686 --> 02:40:06.606
Or do we comment on this meeting?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21321-0
02:40:06.606 --> 02:40:07.806
Are you OK if we comment?
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21324-0
02:40:08.496 --> 02:40:09.456
Multiple times in this process.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21332-0
02:40:09.446 --> 02:40:10.486
Before and after.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21355-0
02:40:10.526 --> 02:40:13.699
I mean, yeah,
we'd comment now so we can incorporate
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21338-0
02:40:11.926 --> 02:40:12.286
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21355-1
02:40:13.699 --> 02:40:18.307
what we've heard into that draft document
and then when we put out the draft
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21355-2
02:40:18.307 --> 02:40:18.846
document.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21359-0
02:40:20.256 --> 02:40:20.896
Let us know what you think.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21370-0
02:40:22.366 --> 02:40:25.126
OK. And then after September 4th as well,
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21369-0
02:40:23.086 --> 02:40:23.566
OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21374-0
02:40:24.726 --> 02:40:26.766
Yes. Yeah. OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21375-0
02:40:26.406 --> 02:40:26.726
Got it.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21383-0
02:40:28.576 --> 02:40:30.696
Alright,
folding folder really don't offer me.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21385-0
02:40:32.696 --> 02:40:33.016
Thanks everyone.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21414-0
02:40:35.266 --> 02:40:39.749
Yeah, because you're going for informal.
Given for. Yeah, OK.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21414-1
02:40:39.749 --> 02:40:42.786
Because this is informal, you know, right.
c09a47c9-d64f-4c8b-b20f-07da7460f84b/21415-0
02:40:43.026 --> 02:40:44.026
Yeah, yeah.