Skip Maine state header navigation

Agencies | Online Services | Help
   
Planning Processes & Programs
Planning Documents
Major Planning Studies
  Public Involvement
  Passenger
Transportation Planning
  Freight Transportation Planning
Transportation Research
Safety Programs
  Traffic Counts
  Metropolitan Planning Organizations
  Home
 


Newsletters

Transportation Research Newsletter

Maine DOT Transportation Research Division January 2000

 

Permeability of Superpave Pavements

When MDOT adopted the Superpave mix design method for hot mix asphalt pavements, one of the primary concerns raised was that these pavements would be significantly more permeable than the dense graded mixes of the past. It was believed that the increased percentage of coarse aggregate in the coarse graded Superpave mixes coupled with potentially lower in-place density levels could allow an excessive amount of water to enter the pavements. Were this to occur, it could lead to premature roadway failure due to increased stripping of asphalt from the aggregate particles, as well as a possible increase in freeze-thaw damage. Several states have already experienced problems with increased permeability since switching to Superpave.

To determine whether or not Maine's Superpave pavements may be prone to similar problems, a research study was awarded to Dr. Rajib Mallick at the Worcester Polytechnic Institute. Dr. Mallick, assisted by Matt Teto of WPI, and Allen Cooley from the National Center for Asphalt Technology visited five MDOT projects to perform field permeability tests as well as to collect mix samples and pavement cores. The pavements tested were: 9.5mm fine, 9.5mm coarse, 12.5mm, 19mm, and 25mm. On each project, ten randomly chosen sites were tested with a field permeameter to measure water flow through the pavement. Core samples were taken at each site for laboratory permeability testing. In addition, samples of loose mix were compacted at various thickness levels in a gyratory compactor and tested for permeability.

The final report indicates that in general, Maine's Superpave pavements do not exhibit excessive permeability. The study found a very strong relationship between pavement density and permeability, and concludes that MDOT's pavement density requirements are sufficient to prevent the severe problems experienced elsewhere. As expected, the 19mm and 25mm base course mixes are more likely to have permeability problems if density levels are below the target value. It was strongly suggested that these base courses should not be left unsurfaced over the winter.

Pavement Performance Studies

Half of the states 8,300 miles of arterial and collector highways are built to handle current traffic loads and meet current standards for vehicle safety. To maintain this standard of highway, preventative maintenance must be performed at the proper time. One maintenance treatment for these highways is preservation paving. The proper time to pave is before depreciating damage occurs which would significantly increase the cost to restore the integrity of the highway. Knowing how long our pavements last is complicated by the implementation of Superpave.

Two pavement performance studies are underway to monitor and evaluate the Departments Preservation Paving Program and Superpave projects.

From 1995 to 1997 a Preservation Paving Program (PPP) was implemented as a maintenance program for highways built to state standards prior to 1995. A number of these highways are being monitored to evaluate the effectiveness of the PPP. Data from Design, Construction, and Pavement

.

Field permeability testing-Big Squaw

The results of this study have answered some of the questions and concerns raised since adoption of the Superpave mix design system. MDOT can continue to specify Superpave mixes with the confidence that the specified gradation and density requirements, air void levels, and layer thicknesses will not allow a detrimental amount of water to enter the pavement layer.

For more information, please contact Rick Bradbury at 941-4597 (rick.bradbury@state.me.us)

 

Management are collected annually to evaluate these PPP projects. Some of the data includes Pavement Condition Ratings (PCR), rut depths and roughness from Pavement Management using the ARAN test vehicle. Average Annual Daily Traffic counts are also used in this study. Below is an example of the data.

In 1997 Superpave mix design was experimentally used on a few projects in place of Hveem mix design, by 1999 Superpave mix was fully implemented at the Department. Superpave mix is designed based on volumetric properties of gyratory compacted samples, traffic levels and regional climate. There was concern with the implementation of Superpave that there may be a problem with in place density of the mix over time with low traffic volume. Because of this, core densities will be collected on a number of Superpave projects statewide for a period of three years to determine if changes should be made in compactive efforts in the future. This along with volumetric properties and pavement management data will be used in the evaluation of Superpave projects.

For more information, please contact Brian Marquis, 947-4067 (brian.marquis@state.me.us)

 

The MDOT recently completed the sealing of the concrete bridge deck at Wiscasset-Edgecomb with a modified high molecular weight methacrylate. To gain an appreciation for the importance of this accomplishment we need to step back to see why and how we came to use a rapid-curing penetrating sealer designed to structurally repair hairline cracks in concrete bridge decks.

In 1993 the Research Engineer was asked by the Bridge Maintenance Engineer for an evaluation of the effectiveness of the latex modified wearing surface that was designed to act as an abrasion and chloride barrier for the protection of the precast-prestressed-segmental concrete one cell box structure.

The wearing surface, which has an overall length of 2737 feet and a roadway width of 36 feet, was cored in twelve locations in 1993 to determine the degree of chloride intrusion. The result was that the wearing surface protection had started to break down allowing the chlorides to penetrate into the concrete slab. Three additional cores were cut in 1994 which confirmed the earlier results. The Department had to start considering some form of repair strategy. Due to the importance of this type of structure and

 

"A". The product also had a low flash point so there were major safety concerns which resulted in a number of safety meetings. There were also the questions of traffic control and the length of time needed for lane closures to accommodate the products curing period which is effected by temperature. The work required the use of crews from Divisions 4 and 5 which involved two managers, multiple crew leaders, and about 30 workers. It was important that safety, job function, and application process issues were resolved before the job started. After much debate it was decided not to do the work at night as planned, but to delay the project until October 5th so that the traffic would be least affected. Six days had been anticipated to complete the sealing of the bridge, however, production far exceeded expectations and the sealing was completed in three days.

To date everyone appears to be satisfied with the results and are hoping that the bridge will remain maintenance free for many years to come.

For more information, Please contact

Guy Berthiaume, 287-2257 (guy.berthiaume@state.me.us)

MAINE

Named 1999's Most Innovative State

by

N.A.S.A.O.

The National Association of State Aviation Officials proclaimed Maine the "Most Innovative State" of 1999 for development of a video-based pavement inspection system. The Maine Department of Transportation adopted existing highway technology for airport use. The Automated Road Analyzer (ARAN) "inspects" the 32 publicly owned airports. This data is being used for a statewide airport pavement management system. Now, a two runway airport can be videotaped in about two hours, where a manual inspection can take as long as two days.

Congratulation to all those involved!

Recent Publications

 

Technical Report 95-02, Fourth Year Interim for Reflective Cracking Control, Experimental Use of Reinforcing Membrane and Grid on Thermal Cracks of HMA

Technical Report 96-25 & 97-19, Second Year Interim for Experimental Use of Sawed and Sealed Joints to Minimize Thermal Cracking of HMA

Technical Report 97-7, Final Report, An Evaluation of Winter Maintenance Material Metering and Placement Equipment

Technical Report 97-21, First and Second Year Interim Report for Saw and Seal Airport HMA Pavement

Technical Report 97-24, Final Report, Alkali-Silica Reactivity Aggregate Screening

Technical Report 98-3, Second Year Interim Report for Potential Benefits of Adding Emulsion to Reclaimed Base Material

Technical Report 99-5, Fast Ferry Report - Phase 1

Technical Report 00-1, Final Report, Evaluation of Permeability of Superpave Mixes in Maine

Technical Report 99-8, Construction Report, Experimental Use of Geogrids as an Alternative to Gravel Placement

Technical Report 96-10, Final Report, Determination of Resilient Modulus of Maine Roadway Soils

Technical Report 98-08, Construction Report, Experimental Utilization of Permeable Base

the need to be reasonably assured that this structure would not be comprised, only two solutions seemed viable. One solution was the placement of a waterproofing membrane over the wearing surface and cover it with a hot mix asphalt pavement. The second was removal and replacement of the latex wearing surface. Both solutions would have cost in the range of half a million dollars.

The Chief Engineer believed that there was some type of concrete sealer that would act as a protective system at a lesser cost. So between 1995 and 1999 the Product Approval Committee tested cementitious epoxy, epoxies, methacrylates, vinyl toluene acrylic polymers, silane/siloxane water repellents, silanes, and siloxanes penetrating sealers to determine the product type that would be most effective in stopping chloride intrusion with a latex wearing surface.

Based on the results of testing completed by the Product Approval Committee the decision was made to have the Bridge Maintenance Division place a methacrylate type sealer on the deck at an anticipated cost of less than one hundred thousand dollars.

In July of 1999 the procedure began for the final phase. To say that a large amount of coordination was required may be an understatement. The task involved using a three component product that would cause a violent explosion if components "B" and "C" came in contact with each other before mixing with component

 

Development of Mix Design System

For

Full Depth Reclamation

The Maine Department of Transportation is partnering with Worcester Polytechnic Institute, the National Center for Asphalt Technology, and others on research that will develop a rational and practical mix design system for full depth reclamation. Full depth reclamation (FDR) is a technique in which the existing hot mix asphalt and partial underlying gravel is recycled in-place to produce a stabilized course. This technique provides a convenient way of restoring proper cross slope and grade to the roadway while providing a crack resistant base course. This can save material and money. Although the practice of FDR is used widely, at times with the addition of stabilizing materials such as emulsion and cement, there is no accepted method of mix design. To utilize its potential fully, there is a need to develop a mix design system for selecting correct amounts of additives. There is a need, as well, to evaluate the effectiveness or performance of different additives in the field.

The project will consist of development of a preliminary mix design system using the Superpave gyratory compactor, construction and performance monitoring of test sites, and "tweaking" the mix design system based on the field tests. Project objectives also include determining proper compaction efforts required, proper curing procedures, and proper structural numbers for FDR base material. Worcester Polytechnic Institute will be conducting the laboratory testing while MDOT will construct the test and control sections along a portion of highway.

Other project partners are Gorman Bros., Inc. Of Albany, New York, the Asphalt Institute, Koch Materials, Vermont Agency of Transportation, Connecticut Department of Transportation, and the New Hampshire Department of Transportation.

This project is being funded by the Recycled Materials Resource Center at the University of New Hampshire. The Center was established in 1998 to promote the appropriate use of recycled materials in the highway environment and was formed in a close partnership with FHWA. For more information on the

Center please check out their website at http://www.rmrc.unh.edu./

For more project information please contact Rick Bradbury at 941-4597 (richard.bradbury@state.me.us) or Dale Peabody at 287-5662 (dale.peabody@state.me.us)

Partnerships in Transportation Research

 

Establishing internal and external partnerships to facilitate research can reap benefits. The FDR article describes one partnership the Maine DOT is involved with. Two other partnerships worthy to note are discussed below.

The Department's Geotechnical Division along with the University of Maine was able to secure $100,000 worth of geosynthetics on a recently completed experimental construction project along Rt. 1A in Frankfort, ME. Reconstruction of this section of highway required measures to stabilize and drain the roadway structure due to extremely poor subgrade conditions. The geosynthetics, including grids, membranes, and drainage geocomposites were donated to this project by the Geosynthetic Materials Association. These geosynthetics were instrumented and performance evaluated by the University of Maine. The project results were successful enough to convince the Department and its partners to try other test sections using geosynthetics. In a project funded through the New England Transportation Consortium with materials once again being donated by GMA, roadway test sections will be constructed to evaluate effects of thin pavement sections.

The State of Maine was recently awarded over $2 million dollars to promote and enhance the use of composites in transportation infrastructure.

This is largely a result of a Composites in Transportation Infrastructure Partnership involving Maine DOT, FHWA, University of Maine, and the Maine Composites Alliance. Other partners include Central Maine Power Company and the Department of Economic and Community Development. This group has worked together to identify potential applications for fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) and FRP/wood composites in the transportation infrastructure. Funded projects include FRP reinforced wood deck for a marine facility, FRP reinforced wood railroad ties for at grade crossings, FRP bridge deck drains, and a FRP bridge deck. Additionally, the University of Maine's Advanced Engineering Wood Composites Center received funding to establish material specifications and design guidelines for AASHTO consideration.

For more information, please contact Dale Peabody, 287-5662 (dale.peabody@state.me.us)