Skip Maine state header navigation

Agencies | Online Services | Help

Skip First Level Navigation | Skip All Navigation

Home -> Adult Protective Services -> Abuse, Neglect & Exploitation in LIcensed Facilities

Abuse, Neglect & Exploitation
in Licensed Facilities

  • Recognize it
  • Prevent it
  • Report it


Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Definitions and Indicators
  3. Risk Factors
  4. Prevention
  5. Maine's Reporting Law
  6. Investigations of Reports of Abuse, Neglect or Exploitation
  7. Where to Report
  8. Long Term Care Ombudsman Program

INTRODUCTION

In Maine there are approximately 15,000 beds in licensed nursing homes, residential care facilities, adult family care homes and adult foster homes.

This booklet is a guide for facility staff regarding abuse, neglect and exploitation of residents: how to recognize it; how to prevent it; and responsibilities for reporting it. It was developed by the Office of Elder Services (OAS) which is part of the Maine Department of Health and Human Services.

The Department recognizes the responsibility of facility staff to assure the welfare and safety of their residents. At the same time, we recognize that the care of adults residing in long-term care facilities is a demanding and often difficult job. Unfortunately, there will be times when family members or staff of the facility may abuse, neglect or exploit residents. In addition, almost all facilities have experienced problems with patients abusing one another.

The Department is responsible for investigating reports of abuse, neglect and exploitation of incapacitated and dependent adults and for protecting incapacitated and dependent adults in danger or at substantial risk of danger. OES staff is available at no charge to train facility staff on site and there are several video tapes available on the subject of abuse, neglect and exploitation which can be borrowed without cost. For more information, contact the OES Protective Program Administrator in your region's Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) office.

The Department’s goal is to maintain a partnership with facilities that will assure the protection of residents and the preservation of their rights.

 

DEFINITIONS AND INDICATORS

Definition of Abuse

"Abuse" means the infliction of injury, unreasonable confinement, intimidation or cruel punishment with resulting physical harm or pain or mental anguish; sexual abuse or exploitation; or the willful deprivation of essential needs.

(22 MRSA §3472)

The cases described briefly below are examples of cases referred to the Department:

95 year old woman, nursing home resident, physically and sexually abused by son-in-law and grandson during visits.

37 year old man, boarding home resident, kicked in groin and stabbed with a paring knife by another resident.

35 year old man with mental illness, involved in a series of violent outbursts toward other patients, including dislocating the shoulder of an elderly patient.

23 year old woman, mental health institute patient, sexually assaulted while home on a weekend pass.

101 year old woman, nursing home resident, slapped by C.N.A. resulting in serious facial bruises.

There may be times when you observe signs of abuse but were not actually a witness to what happened. The tangible signs or indicators of abuse, neglect or exploitation described on the following pages tend to be ones that can be detected by trained observers such as facility staff members. More difficult to detect or to determine are intimidation and mental anguish. Residents who are ridiculed, maliciously teased, cursed at or threatened may fear retaliation if they speak up or complain about a family member, another resident or a member of the facility staff. It takes skill and sensitivity beyond that required for routine observation to find out if verbal abuse has occurred.

Physical Abuse

Indicators

Physical assaults, cruel discipline, excessive use of physical or chemical restraints, and unnecessary or incorrect medication may cause any one of the following:

Broken bones

  • Pain and inability to move a limb may be a sign of a broken bone. This may occur when a resident with osteoporosis is handled roughly by visitors or staff. Broken bones in various stages of healing and spiral fractures may indicate abuse as well as fractures of the skull, nose or facial structure.

Burns

  • Burns and blistering skin over a wide area may show up because a resident was placed in a scalding hot tub of water. A more confined spot of burned skin may indicate purposeful burning with a cigarette. Rope burns on arms, legs, neck or torso may also indicate abuse.

Cuts

  • Cuts or scratches may result when a resident was jabbed with a sharp object such as a pencil or scratched with fingernails.

Internal Injuries

  • Watch for such signs as vomiting, pain, stuporous states, bleeding, swelling or bloody stools. You may observe any one or a combination of these if someone gave a resident alcohol or drugs that can cause sickness; or if someone overdoses a resident with anti-diarrhea medicine causing severe constipation; or if a blow to the stomach or head has caused internal injuries

Marks/Bruises

  • A resident may have a hand-print shaped bruise where a person slapped them across the face or buttocks. Multiple bruises in various stages of healing may indicate abuse. Look for injuries to the face, neck, inner arms, inner thighs, especially bilateral injuries on upper arms.

Scars

  • Scars could indicate that the resident has been a victim of repeated or past abuses.

Definition of Sexual Abuse

"Sexual abuse or exploitation" means contact or interaction of a sexual nature involving an incapacitated or dependent adult without that adult's consent (22 MRSA §3472).

Sexual Abuse Indicators

  • A family member offers affectionate gestures to a resident that are too lingering and seductive or become centered on the sex organs, anus or breasts.
  • Injury to a resident's genitals, anus, breast or mouth.
  • A resident attempts to talk an incapacitated resident into sexual intercourse, fellatio, or cunnilingus.
  • A young resident tells you that her father manipulates her genitals, buttocks and breasts during his visits.
  • A staff member exposes his/her genitals to a resident.
  • A visitor takes nude photographs of residents.
  • Venereal disease, torn, stained or bloody underwear, difficulty walking or sitting, and pain or itching in genital area are all suspicious of sexual abuse.

Definition of Neglect

"Neglect" means a threat to an adult's health or welfare by physical or mental injury or impairment, deprivation of essential needs or lack of protection from these (22 MRSA §3472).

Indicators of Neglect

  • Residents suffer from neglect when they are left alone, ignored by staff or left with staff who fail to care for them appropriately.
  • A group of assaultive residents have been left alone and unsupervised.
  • An aide has fallen asleep or is intoxicated while on duty.
  • A resident has bleeding gums and some loose teeth, indicating that a visit to the dentist is long overdue.
  • A resident is continually fearful about leaving her room and seems almost panicky when it's time to leave the facility for an outing. Staff "leave her be" rather than attempting to determine the cause of her fear.
  • A resident fell several days ago. Her ankle is swollen and bruised, and she complains of pain when walking. The resident's doctor or family were not notified of the fall immediately. X-rays taken several days after the fact reveal a fracture.

Definition of Exploitation

"Exploitation" means the illegal or improper use of an incapacitated adult or his resources for another's profit or advantage. (22 MRSA §3472) Maine law prevents facility employees from being appointed guardians or conservators

(18-A MRSA §5-311).

Indicators of Exploitation

  • A resident's relative, who is representative payee, fails to pay nursing, boarding or foster home bills and provide personal needs money.
  • The facility administrator, who is a resident's representative payee, purchases furniture or clothing not intended for the resident.
  • A resident is manipulated into giving away money or personal property such as a TV, jewelry, or furniture.
  • Disappearance of personal property; transfer of property, savings, insurance; unexplained change in cash flow; change in will, representative payee, power of attorney; or depleted bank accounts.

RISK FACTORS

Types of Abuse, Neglect and Exploitation

Abuse in facilities may occur in a variety of ways. Residents may abuse one another, facility staff may abuse residents or residents may be abusive toward staff. Abuse may be an act of violence such as physical or sexual assault, or it may be verbal abuse, medication errors or failure to provide proper assistance resulting in injuries. Residents may be neglected by facility staff or family members. Residents may be exploited by facility staff, family members or other residents.

Risk Factors

Risk factors for abuse can be related to facility employees, to conditions in the facility itself or to residents. Listed below are some factors which increase the risk of abuse. The more of them that are present in a situation, the greater the risk. There are also other forces which may contribute to a problem such as the season, holidays, reactions to family visits, weather and time of day. Being aware of what to watch for and averting a build up of such risk factors can help to prevent abuse.

Employee Risk Factors

* Alcohol/drug abuse
* Chronic physical illness
* Excessive absenteeism
* Family problems/history of family violence
* Financial problems
* Insubordination/power conflicts/rivalry
* Mental illness
* Numerous disciplinary actions
* Poorly trained
* Role reversal, e.g. looking to resident to fulfill the employee's needs
* Social isolation
* Tardiness/unexplained absences

Facility Risk Factors

 

 

 

 

 

* Accepting residents whose needs cannot be met by facility
* Crowding/concentration of vulnerable adults
* Frequent "reorganizations"
* High employee absenteeism
* High overtime demands
* High personnel turnover
* Inadequate and uninformed administrator response to abuse
* Inconsistent and unclear expectations of staff

  • Lack of staff training
  • Lake of clear role definition for staff
  • Poor communication between administrators and staff (in both directions)
  • Poorly paid staff
  • Staff shortages, e.g. least experienced staff required to work holidays when staffing is skeletal/residents agitated

* Poor building maintenance (ventilation, noise, lighting)

Resident Risk Factors

 

* Argumentative
* Assaultive
* Demanding
* History of multiple incidents
* History of substance abuse
* Hostile
* Incompetent, organic brain syndrome (OBS), demented
* Incontinent
* Intrusive
* Manipulative
* Mute
* Passive/passive aggressive
* Sexual acting out behavior
* Verbally abusive

PREVENTION

Preventing abuse, neglect and exploitation in facilities requires trained staff at all levels. In addition, staff must have administrative support to act to prevent abuse and to file proper incident reports. The following conditions may enhance the prevention of abuse, neglect and exploitation:

  • Facility administration communicates clearly and consistently that all residents and staff must be treated with dignity and respect.
  • Orientation and ongoing training programs are provided that develop appropriate attitudes in new employees and teach staff about resident behavior and needs.
  • Administrators and supervisors are competent, accessible to and supportive of staff.
  • Employees feel comfortable about discussing personal problems with their supervisors or facility administration. Administrators make appropriate referrals for counseling or assistance.
  • Staff who are becoming angry with a particular patient can request reassignment.
  • Staff have a pleasant and clean break room.
  • Staff have supplies and equipment necessary to do their jobs.
  • Staff deal with even minor incidents of abuse immediately. No level of abuse, no matter how "minor", is tolerated.
  • Administrators and supervisors convey to staff and residents the importance of reporting suspected abuse, neglect or exploitation to the Department of Health and Human Services. (Note in the section on reporting that in addition to reporting to one's supervisor or the facility administrator, the staff person must also make a report directly to the Department).
  • Facility protects confidentiality of staff/resident reporters.
  • Facility administration and staff are aware of, understand the purpose of and call upon the Long-term Care Ombudsman Program for assistance. (See page 14 for program description).

MAINE'S REPORTING LAW

Mandatory Reporting:

Maine law (22 MRSA §3477-3479-A) requires that if the following people, while acting in a professional capacity, suspect that an adult has been abused, neglected or exploited, and there is reasonable cause to suspect that the adult is incapacitated, then those professionals shall immediately report or cause a report to be made to the Department.

 

Professionals who must report:

  • Ambulance Attendant Law Enforcement Official Physician (MD and DO)
  • Certified Nursing Assistant Licensed Practical Nurse Physician's Assistant
  • Chiropractor Medical Examiner Podiatrist
  • Coroner Medical Intern Psychologist
  • Dentist Mental Health Professional Registered Nurse
  • Emergency Medical Technician Occupational Therapist Social Worker
  • Emergency Room Personnel Pharmacist Speech Therapist
  • Physical Therapist Unlicensed Assistive Personnel

Facility Reporting:

Maine law further states that whenever a person is required to report in his or her capacity as a member of the staff of a medical, public or private institution, facility or agency, that person shall immediately make a report directly to the Department of Health and Human Services.

Optional reporting:

Any person may make a report if that person knows or has reasonable cause to suspect abuse, neglect or exploitation of a dependent or incapacitated adult, or has reasonable cause to suspect that an adult is incapacitated.

 


Where to report:

Mandatory and optional reports are made to the Department of Health and Human Services, Bureau of Medical Services, Division of Licensing and Certification. When the alleged victim has mental retardation, the report must be made to the Department of Mental Health, Mental Retardation and Substance Abuse Services. (Phone numbers are on page 13).

Immunity

When reports are made in good faith, reporters are immune from any civil liability. Facility staff who comply with the mandatory reporting law also are protected from discharge, threats or discrimination regarding their conditions of employment by their employers under Maine's "whistleblowers protection act" (26 MRSA §831-840).

Liability

A fine of not more than $500 may be imposed upon a professional who is convicted of knowingly failing to report and the conviction will also be reported to the professional's licensing board or accrediting unit. A referral may be made to the professional's licensing board by OES.

Confidentiality

The Department will respect a request for confidentiality. All department records and activities are confidential. Disclosure may be required in very limited circumstances.

Self-Abuse

Self-abuse or self-neglect must be recorded in the resident's chart and noted in an incident report but is not reportable to the Department unless the resident is suspected to be, or is, incapacitated.

Accidents

Injuries from a known accident are not reportable but must be noted in the resident's chart.

Resident vs. Staff abuse

Abuse of staff by residents does not have to be reported to the Department unless the resident is a OES client or under public guardianship. These resident incidents must be documented and brought to the attention of appropriate supervisory personnel. The staff member may choose to press charges in cases of assault. The facility is responsible for taking steps to address such abusive behavior on the part of the residents. Residents who abuse staff may also be reported if the resident is incapacitated and has no involved family.

INVESTIGATIONS OF REPORTS

What happens after the incident or suspicion is reported to the Department depends on Maine law (Adult Protective Services Act, 22 MRSA §3470-3492) and on the policies and procedures governing the Department’s operations.

Cases Assigned:

When a report of alleged abuse, neglect or exploitation of a resident is made to the Department, OES is notified and will record the report and decide whether to assign the case for investigation. In general, a case will be assigned if any one of the following conditions exist:

 

Conditions:

ð Resident was physically harmed, suffered pain or mental anguish and abuse or neglect was suspected.

ð Resident's resources have been used or taken by a family member, another resident, or facility staff person.

ð Resident was believed to be or was sexually abused or sexually exploited.

ð Victim or perpetrator is incapacitated and may need a guardian or conservator.

Referrals to Law Enforcement:

Upon finding evidence indicating that a person has abused or neglected an incapacitated or dependent adult resulting in serious harm, or has exploited an incapacitated or dependent adult, the Department is required to notify the District Attorney or law enforcement. Suspected abuse, neglect or exploitation on the part of staff in licensed facilities is also reported to the Health Care Crimes Unit of the Attorney General's Office.

 

Offices of OES Protective Program Administrators

 

Southern Region

Cumberland, York, Androscoggin, Oxford and Sagadahoc Counties (except town of Richmond)

509 Forest Avenue
Portland Maine 04101
822-2149
1-800-482-7520
TTY: 822-2293
Fax: 822-2162

 

Central Region

Kennebec, Somerset, Franklin, Waldo, Knox, Lincoln Counties (and town of Richmond)

35 Anthony Avenue
Augusta Maine 04333-0011
624-8060
1-800-452-1926
TTY: 624-5895
Fax: 624-5886

 

Northern Region

Penobscot, Piscataquis, Hancock, Washington and Aroostook Counties

396 Griffin Road
Bangor Maine 04401
561-4380
1-800-432-7825
TTY: 561-4248
Fax: 561-4396

Report abuse neglect or exploitation in licensed nursing facilities to the

Department of Health and Human Services, Division of Licensing and Certification at:

Statewide toll-free 1-800-383-2441

TTY 624-5512

Report all other adult abuse, neglect or exploitation to Office of Elder Services, Adult Protective Services at:

Statewide 24-hour Toll Free 1-800-624-8404

TTY (during business hours) 1-800-624-8404

TTY (after hours) 1-800-963-9490

For Out-of-State Calls

All calls, V/TTY (during business hours) 207-532-5047

After hours 207-287-6083

TTY (after hours) 207-287-3492


Persons with mental retardation

To make a report of abuse, neglect or exploitation of a person with mental retardation, call the Department of Mental Health, Mental Retardation and Substance Abuse Services Advocate at:

Region 1 (York & Cumberland) 822-0270 TTY 828-0272

Region 2 (Central & Mid Coast) 287-2205 TTY 287-1798

Region 3 (Northern & Eastern Aroostook) 941-4360 TTY 941-4392

If not successful, and for after business hours reports, call the Chief Advocate or leave a message at 287-4228 TTY 287-1798


Report suspected Medicaid fraud to:

MEDICAID FRAUD CONTROL UNIT

6 State House Station,
State Office Building 6th Floor
Augusta, Maine 04333 626-8870 TTY 626-8865

This unit is mandated to investigate fraud perpetrated by Medicaid providers and situations where there are allegations of abuse, neglect or exploitation by staff in a facility that receives Medicaid.

 


LONG-TERM CARE OMBUDSMAN PROGRAM
http://www.maineombudsman.org

One Weston Court, PO Box 126
Augusta, Maine 04332-0126
621-1079
Toll Free Statewide TTY 1-800-499-0229
Fax: 621-0509

The Long-term Care Ombudsman Program investigates and resolves complaints made on behalf of residents of Maine's nursing, boarding, and adult foster homes and recipients of home care. Any person may ask for assistance from the Ombudsman Program on behalf of these individuals. The Ombudsman receives complaints directly from residents, from friends and relatives, employees and administrators, and public agencies and community groups. They include complaints about the quality of care that a resident receives in a long-term care facility, and about problems that residents have regarding eligibility for state programs, financial status, legal problems, and transfer assistance. The Ombudsman Program also provides training on resident rights and on federal and state regulations and identifies issues that may require legislative or regulatory changes.

THE RIGHTS OF LONG-TERM CARE RESIDENTS

  1. To voice grievances without fear of reprisal and receive a prompt response from the facility.
  2. To exercise their rights as a resident and as a citizen.
  3. To be free from mental and physical abuse and to be free from chemical and physical restraints.
  4. To be discharged or transferred only if the facility is unable to meet the resident's medical needs, if the resident's health has improved such that he/she no longer needs nursing home care, if the health or safety of other residents is endangered, or if the resident has failed, after reasonable notice, to pay for his/her stay in the facility. Discharge notice must be given in writing at least 30 days in advance or as soon as possible if more immediate changes in health require a more immediate transfer.
  5. To associate and communicate privately with persons of their choice.
  6. To participate in social, religious, and community activities.
  7. To have access to their personal and medical records, to be informed of their medical condition, to participate in planning their care and treatment.
  8. To manage personal financial affairs.
  9. To keep and use personal belongings as space permits.
  10. If married, to share a room with a spouse.
  11. To receive a reasonable accommodation by the facility for individual needs and preferences.
  12. To choose activities, schedules and health care consistent with his/her interests, assessments and plan of care.
  13. To advance notice of change in room or roommate.
  14. To organize and participate in residents groups.
  15. To have access to results of licensing surveys.

If you feel that these or other rights have been denied to any person in a long-term care facility, call the Ombudsman Program.